Star Wars Fan Are Wrong About the Force

by

Being a fan isn’t about winning or losing, but dedicated fans deeply care about the details of their favorite universes. They immerse themselves in the story – starting with the original films, continuing with newer TV series, and exploring everything in the broader story world, including both official and older, non-official content. However, a single line from The Phantom Menace led to a misunderstanding about the Force that continues to bother fans even today.

While developing the Star Wars universe, the concept of midi-chlorians was introduced in The Phantom Menace and played a role in the prequel trilogy’s overall story. It’s ironic that fans often focus too much on a character’s “M-Count” – the number of midi-chlorians – because the Force should be accessible to everyone.

Midi-chlorians Confused Star Wars Fans About What It Takes to Be a Jedi and Strong in the Force

Midi-chlorians were introduced in The Phantom Menace mainly to provide a way to measure Anakin Skywalker’s potential, justifying why the Jedi would train someone so young. While the idea has been explored further with other characters—from ordinary people to powerful figures like Yoda, Anakin, and Grogu—midi-chlorians are living beings and, like all life, are connected to the will of the Force.

Often overlooked in The Phantom Menace, Qui-Gon Jinn touches on the origins of the Force. Later, in The Empire Strikes Back, Yoda clarifies that the Force is an energy field created by all living beings and flows through them. Midi-chlorians, inspired by the energy-producing mitochondria within cells, are simply the biological component that allows individuals to connect with and use the Force’s power.

While a high midi-chlorian count (M-count) was considered important, it wasn’t the sole indicator of a person’s potential to use the Force, or their suitability to become a Jedi. The Jedi Order’s strong reliance on M-count as a measure of ability demonstrates how strict and inflexible they had become, even trusting the test more than the Force itself. This emphasis on a number went against George Lucas’s original vision, suggesting that even someone with a low M-count could be strong with the Force.

George Lucas Originally Held a More Democratic View of Talent Wielding the Force

J.W. Rinzler’s book, The Making of Return of the Jedi, recounts a meeting where George Lucas explained the Force to writer Lawrence Kasdan and director Richard Marquand. He compared it to yoga, saying that anyone could use it, but those truly dedicated would be the ones who devoted the time to master it. Lucas also described the Emperor not as a Jedi, but as someone akin to Richard Nixon, and further explained…

Look, it’s obvious George Lucas did some rethinking on the Star Wars mythology. Calling Yoda a ‘guru’ feels like a shift, but the idea of midi-chlorians, while controversial, doesn’t actually invalidate his original vision of the Force. I mean, it makes sense that someone’s connection to the Force could strengthen their midi-chlorian count – it’s a natural progression. But even if that wasn’t the case, a lower count doesn’t necessarily mean someone is incapable of mastering the Force. It just suggests they might need to put in a little extra effort, right? It’s a nice way to keep the dream alive for all those aspiring Padawans… or even Sith!

The Force isn’t just a plot device in Star Wars stories and games; it’s the core idea behind everything George Lucas built. It’s cleverly used to make the universe feel alive and less controlled by the author. The Force isn’t simply a source of energy; it’s created by living things, flows through them via midi-chlorians, and reacts to their decisions, almost as if it has a mind of its own.

The Force Is Star Wars’ Greatest Mystery, and It Both Has a Will and Reacts to People’s Choices

Despite some flaws, the concept of the Force is still the most compelling aspect of the Star Wars saga. A common mistake fans make is interpreting characters and events too literally. Although midi-chlorians are part of the Force and connect to it in a unique way, even experienced Jedi like Qui-Gon and Yoda don’t fully grasp its nature. Qui-Gon described the ‘Living Force’ as being reactive to choices and offering guidance, while the ‘Cosmic Force’ represents the larger, overarching destiny – things like the ‘Chosen One’ prophecy or the powerful connection between Rey and Ben Solo.

It’s not simply about how powerful he was, but about Anakin Skywalker’s part in the larger cosmic balance. The Force designated a “Chosen One” to stand against the Sith, because the Dark Side creates instability. However, Anakin’s choices actually amplified Palpatine’s strength and led to the Jedi Order’s downfall. At the same time, the more benevolent side of the Force helped characters like Ahsoka Tano, Kanan Jarrus, Ezra Bridger, and Cal Kestis – Jedi and others – as they fought against the darkness in their own ways.

Beyond the cosmic forces and living beings in the galaxy, their connection remains a puzzle for both the characters and viewers. While the Force has a strong influence, the decisions characters make are just as, if not more, crucial. We see this with Anakin Skywalker, who finds redemption after twenty years as a villain simply by choosing to save his son. Choosing the light or dark side isn’t a simple matter of being good or evil; it’s an ongoing battle between selflessness and selfishness, and those choices can have far-reaching consequences.

Some Star Wars fans can be overly strict about who qualifies as a Jedi, but dismissing contributions from others is a mistake. These are just pieces of the larger story and themes within Star Wars. The Force is inherently mysterious, meaning anyone can potentially play a significant role or access a power beyond themselves. The Jedi’s focus on midi-chlorian counts was misguided, and Luke Skywalker was wrong in The Last Jedi to believe the galaxy didn’t need heroes. Because the Force connects all life in the galaxy, it’s logical that anyone could use it for good or evil.

You can now see The Mandalorian and Grogu in movie theaters. All the other Star Wars films and shows are available to stream on Disney+, and you can also buy them from most digital retailers.

Read More

2026-05-24 14:37