The Four-Word Response Simon Cowell Would Have If His Son Gave A Bad Singing Audition

by

Simon Cowell remains a fixture on television, recently completing his judging duties on season 20 of America’s Got Talent, where Jessica Sanchez emerged as the winner. He’s also launching a new Netflix show in 2025, Simon Cowell: The Next Act, which will focus on discovering the next big boy band. Known for his direct and often critical feedback, viewers are left wondering if he’d offer the same harsh assessment to his own son, Eric, should he perform poorly in an audition. True to form, the famously blunt judge responded with a concise, four-word answer.

Simon Cowell predicted in 2023 that his son might one day audition for Britain’s Got Talent, as Eric has always wanted to be a drummer who sings. In a recent interview with Rolling Stone, Cowell discussed how he would react if Eric gave a poor performance, stating his blunt, four-word response would be:

If my son, Eric, ever came to me and said he wanted to be a singer, I’d be honest with him, even if it was hard. Let’s say he sang for me, and honestly, it wasn’t very good – completely off-key. I still wouldn’t sugarcoat it. I’d tell him straight up that singing might not be his thing. I believe in being truthful with my kids, even when it’s difficult.

Simon Cowell has often been labeled harsh, especially during his time on America’s Got Talent and American Idol, and some have criticized his direct feedback. However, he’s always been known for honesty, believing in constructive criticism even if it’s blunt. Shouldn’t that same approach apply when giving feedback to family members?

Simon Cowell is famous for being brutally honest, and it makes you wonder if he ever regretted some of his harsh critiques. While the former X Factor judge usually stood by his opinions, he wasn’t always completely unwavering.

We all make mistakes and say things we regret. But it’s more helpful to be honest with someone who clearly lacks a skill. For example, if someone can’t sing, it’s best to tell them that simply continuing won’t magically turn them into a famous musician. This show is meant to be truthful, and I won’t mislead contestants by giving them false hope.

I get where the judge is coming from. Even if the way something is said isn’t perfect, the overall message can still be valid. It’s important to be honest – you shouldn’t tell someone they’re singing well if they’re not. If Simon Cowell just let everyone pass, he wouldn’t be doing his job as a judge.

Simon Cowell’s comments sometimes upset people, but many others valued his directness. For instance, after Cowell described Korean Soul’s song on AGT as predictable, singer Sooyong Yoon took it as constructive criticism and used it to inspire their next performance, focusing on their group’s strengths. Even American Idol contestant Clay Aiken admitted he appreciated the feedback he received, as it helped him grow. Knowing this, I think Eric would recognize his father’s critiques are meant to be helpful.

Even when it comes to his son, Simon Cowell is known for giving honest feedback, even if it’s critical. But remember, helpful criticism is essential for improvement. If Eric still wants to pursue his dream of being in a band, he’ll likely appreciate his dad’s honesty later on, just like many others have. You can watch Simon Cowell: The Next Act now on Netflix.

Read More

2025-12-28 01:08