Kumail Nanjiani Is a Taskmaster Cautionary Tale

by

Spoilers follow for season 21 of Taskmaster, the finale episode of which aired on June 11. 

Contestants on Taskmaster often fit into familiar roles. You’ve got the established comedy veterans who seem a bit unenthusiastic (like Armando Iannucci, Jack Dee, and Frankie Boyle), the witty younger women who playfully tease host Greg Davies (such as Sophie Duker, Fern Brady, and Ania Magliano), and the unpredictable comedians whose awkwardness is part of their charm (think James Acaster, Sam Campbell, and Noel Fielding). Recently, we’ve seen a trend of American actors appearing on the show, seemingly trying to impress Davies (Jason Mantzoukas and Kumail Nanjiani have both been on in recent years). However, considering Kumail Nanjiani’s fairly average performance, this ‘American actor’ archetype shouldn’t become a regular thing.

Zach Galifianakis truly shined during season 19 in spring 2025. His unpredictable humor and quick thinking, combined with the bizarre challenges set by Alex Horne and series creator Davies, made him one of the most entertaining contestants ever. However, Kumail Nanjiani’s appearance in season 21 (spring 2026) didn’t fare as well. He seemed destined to struggle – being asked to find a worm outdoors, right next to grass, felt like an impossible task! The show itself didn’t quite know how to showcase him beyond his physical strength. Nanjiani’s performance highlights some issues with how Taskmaster chooses its contestants and what the show needs to offer them in return. Let’s look at three reasons why Nanjiani wasn’t a successful competitor.

Jason Mantzoukas, the Taskmaster Student

Just kidding! If anyone deserves credit (or blame), it’s Jason Mantzoukas for raising the stakes for Americans competing on Taskmaster. While North Americans had appeared on the show before, they were expats already living in the U.K. Mantzoukas was unique because he traveled from America specifically to compete as a devoted fan, and that ‘outsider’ perspective shaped his whole approach. He both loved and wanted to playfully sabotage Taskmaster, often highlighting his Americanness through self-deprecating humor and mock frustration with British culture. The show’s hosts, Davies and Horne, played along perfectly, gently teasing his American accent and unfamiliarity with British slang.

Despite having a solid career in film and television, Zach Mantzoukas felt like an equal among the other contestants on Taskmaster. He wasn’t significantly more famous than people like Fatiha El-Ghorri, Mathew Baynton, Rosie Ramsey, and Stevie Martin. He came onto the show as a fan who had studied Taskmaster closely, understood how it worked, and had a deliberate plan to shake things up. This plan guided his actions and made him a hit with viewers. Mantzoukas was willing to be silly and even look foolish, happily destroying furniture and enthusiastically cheering “USA!”—all as part of a calculated strategy to both embrace and playfully mock the show. He was a unique force, and the show wouldn’t have the same spark with another American comedian.

Kumail Nanjiani, the Hollywood Star

Kumail Nanjiani faced a tough challenge on Taskmaster: how could he bring his own style to the show without repeating Zach Galifianakis’s approach? The bar was set incredibly high, and unfortunately, he didn’t quite reach it. Unlike Galifianakis, who instantly felt at home, Nanjiani took time to find his footing both in the pre-recorded challenges and during the studio segments with his fellow contestants – Amy Gledhill, Armando Iannucci, Joanna Page, and Joel Dommett. Having shifted his focus to acting and producing, especially after a ten-year break from stand-up culminating in his 2025 special, Night Thoughts, Nanjiani seemed less able to spontaneously embrace the show’s chaotic energy. He appeared to overthink his performance in the studio, trying different ways to connect with Alex Horne and Greg Davies – sometimes playfully teasing, other times overly eager to please. Throughout it all, he often came across as desperately seeking approval, frequently falling into a nitpicky pattern of questioning the scoring and complaining when others received more points – a familiar but frustrating behavior on Taskmaster.

Kumail Nanjiani’s approach on Taskmaster felt uncertain – he seemed unsure whether to follow the patterns of previous contestants or be completely himself. This made his role on the show a little unclear. For example, in one episode, he offered a haunted painting as part of a challenge, echoing a similar story told by another contestant, Joe Mantzoukas. Another contestant, Frankie Boyle, had also done a bit about a spooky painting earlier in the series. The fact that two Americans presented nearly identical haunted painting stories, using similar language, raised questions: was Nanjiani paying tribute to Mantzoukas, experiencing a strange coincidence, or simply copying his idea?

This pattern continued throughout the season. When another contestant, Joel Dommett, made puns a signature part of his performance, Nanjiani later imitated him in the finale with a “cool tee” featuring a koala. Dommett visibly reacted to this mimicry. In one episode, Nanjiani shared his unedited search history – which included adult content and searches about himself – and then questioned whether it needed to be shown. It was hard to tell if he was genuinely concerned about the potential impact on his career or if that concern was the performance.

The problem is, this lack of clarity detracts from what makes Taskmaster so enjoyable: contestants usually feel very natural and spontaneous. Nanjiani often appeared uncomfortable, physically embarrassed, and spent much of the filming with his head in his hands. He didn’t stand out as a strong competitor like Mantzoukas, nor did he fully engage with the game in the same way other North American participants did. Ultimately, it seems the issue lies with…

Taskmaster, the Show That Casts Comedians

Since it first aired in 2015, Taskmaster has become incredibly popular as a hilarious platform for British comedians. For American viewers, part of the fun is getting a glimpse into a UK comedy scene where everyone knows each other and isn’t afraid to make fools of themselves. The contestants generally seem like their genuine selves – they aren’t typically massive stars that most Americans would recognize, which keeps things feeling authentic. Both the show’s house and studio setting create a level playing field for everyone involved. However, Kumail Nanjiani, who was already well-known from his role in the 2021 Marvel film Eternals, didn’t quite fit this dynamic. His fellow competitors, along with hosts Greg Davies and Alex Horne, playfully teased him as an outsider from Hollywood, and that perception seemed to affect his performance on the show and even limit its humor.

Kumail Nanjiani approached the show differently than Joel Kim Booster, who readily embraced self-promotion and playful put-downs for laughs. Nanjiani, however, seemed stuck between his old persona as a detail-oriented, intellectual fan and his newer image as a muscular movie star. When his teammates, Gledhill and Dommett, first met him, they were visibly starstruck, excitedly repeating how famous he was and even mentioning they’d add working with him to their resumes. Host Davies jokingly complained about their over-the-top reaction, but the show continued to highlight Nanjiani’s celebrity, and he played along. During film-making challenges, everyone commented on how “Hollywood” he acted, and he leaned into that role, giving dramatic stares and even playfully scowling at Dommett during a silly scene. Nanjiani seemed most at ease when he felt in control of these moments, and perhaps how they were presented in the final edit. Otherwise, he struggled to balance his different sides – the intelligent fan, the physically fit star, the detail-oriented perfectionist – into something consistently funny.

Kumail Nanjiani’s fame made it difficult for him to blend in with the other contestants on Taskmaster. The show deserves credit for not sacrificing its playful, self-aware style despite his celebrity; for example, when Nanjiani asked to redo a frustrating moment with Alex Davies for a better on-camera reaction, Davies refused, and the awkward exchange stayed in the episode. However, Taskmaster didn’t really try to see Nanjiani as anything other than a famous actor, which made it hard for him to find his footing as a competitor. This raises a concern: the more well-known personalities, particularly from outside the UK, the show features, the greater the risk of a season where a contestant is defined by the surprise of the others simply being there. The next season’s cast of British sitcom stars, panel show regulars, and comedians feels safe in that regard. But the upcoming appearance of an Oscar winner? That’s a bit worrying.

Alex Horne has mentioned finding contestants by asking for suggestions from comedians he knows in the U.K. Meanwhile, Taskmaster is incredibly popular, boasting millions of YouTube followers, numerous spin-offs, and a successful U.S. tour earlier this year. It’s reasonable to expect the show will increasingly feature well-known personalities – particularly those with international recognition – as its global audience grows. However, Kumail Nanjiani’s appearance demonstrated how quickly the unique vibe of Taskmaster can be disrupted when a contestant is so famous that it overshadows everything else.

Read More

2026-06-17 19:56