Southern Charm Recap: Sorry, Charley

by

This season of Southern Charm was fantastic – easily one of the best in recent years. The women really made it, with a great mix of personalities. While Austen, Craig, Shep, and Whitney are staples of the show, the ongoing drama between Austen and Craig is starting to feel repetitive. Thankfully, the female cast members brought a fresh energy. Molly was charmingly quirky, Charley was hilariously expressive, Venita brought grace and avoided conflict, and Madison’s pregnancy journey had a heartwarming conclusion, especially with her son Hudson meeting his new baby sister, Teddi, and affectionately calling Madison “Booger.” Don’t mind me, just a little dust in my eye.

Let’s be honest, this season was all about Salley and her dramatic personality. She’s frustrating, often says one thing and does another, and honestly, she gets under my skin more than getting the end piece of banana bread – nobody wants the heel! Just toss it, along with Emmy from Southern Hospitality. Don’t make me buy another loaf just to get a good slice! Where was I? Oh, right, Salley. She really pushes our buttons, but she was the most captivating part of the episode and the entire season. I’m glad we love to hate her, because I have a feeling she’s not going anywhere. She’s like that annoying coworker who’s good at their job – you don’t want to be around them, but you have to admit they get things done. Salley is good at her job. Okay, fine, she can stay.

The episode concludes the group’s healing trip to Mexico, with Shep frustrated that they didn’t experience anything mind-altering. He then tries to get Craig and Austen to make amends, and they agree to be civil for a bit. Craig explains in a private interview that while he loves Austen and believes the feeling is mutual, they need to essentially start over as strangers to move forward, letting go of past assumptions. However, I disagree with that approach. While relationships do need to evolve, completely erasing the past isn’t realistic or helpful. The real issue isn’t forgetting history, but adjusting expectations. Craig is right about needing to shed preconceived notions, but pretending they’re strangers won’t work, and isn’t the best solution. Their shared history is actually what could make them great friends again, if they can find a way to accept how things have changed.

Craig claims he always treats people with kindness, but that doesn’t seem to be true, especially recently. He’s talking about having a great time, while Salley is still upset from the previous night, when he apparently lost his temper with her. She’s rightfully telling him she was hurt, and someone needs to call him out on his behavior – it’s good she’s standing up for herself.

She gives in incredibly easily, like a cardboard box getting soaked. Craig quickly apologizes for his harsh words, insisting he doesn’t think she’s a failure. He tries to look charming, running his hand through his hair, and she responds with a bright smile. A pat on the knee is enough for her to forgive him, and she even suggests they both need to improve. Later, she admits he’s good at turning on the charm and begging for forgiveness, which she finds easy to give, mostly because she—and others—don’t want to deal with his angry outbursts. This dynamic was highlighted at the last reunion when Andy asked who was afraid of Craig, and everyone admitted they were.

Everyone in their social circle attends Miss Patricia’s annual Carolina Day party, which she jokingly acknowledges is mostly an excuse to drink on a weekday. Craig asks Charley to be his date, but she’s already planning to go with her friend, Tyler. When they arrive at the party, Charley and Tyler immediately run into Rodrigo’s fiancé – also named Tyler. It quickly becomes clear there’s only room for one Tyler on the show (and maybe in existence!), and a rivalry is brewing between the two.

Craig brings his friend Kory Keefer instead, and let’s just say Kory’s outfit is… a choice. Driving to the event, he’s wearing a white jacket with nothing underneath, a dead-battery Christmas light necklace, and tiny red sunglasses that give off serious Blues Traveler vibes. But it gets worse when they arrive. The jacket is a white, satin double-breasted one, tucked into extra wide white pinstripe pants. He even has a wallet chain! Whitney Sudler-Smith perfectly sums it up, saying Kory looks like both Vanilla Ice and the guy from “2 Legit 2 Quit.” I’d add Michael Jackson’s “Smooth Criminal” if Kory were getting married. I appreciate guys trying to be stylish on this show, especially since most are either underdressed or wearing boring khakis. However, this outfit is just too much. It’s like he’s trying to escape a fancy spaceship from the movie The Fifth Element.

Charley is clearly avoiding Craig at the party. Craig confides in Salley that he and Charley were actually very close. They used to FaceTime whenever they were bored, often late at night. They’d spend hours on the phone like kids, just chatting about anything and everything, until Charley’s dad would interrupt, telling him to get off the phone and do his homework. Hearing this throws Salley for a loop. She decides that relationship is over – Charley is done with Craig. She tells Craig he’s won the argument, but also needs to give it a rest. (And she adds that he looks great in his dress, no further comment needed.)

Craig locates Charley, and they sit down on the porch to talk. Charley gently lets him know she no longer sees him as a romantic partner, explaining that her feelings changed while she was in Mexico. She wants to remain friends, but Craig insists that’s impossible for him. Charley responds by saying they can at least attempt to be just friends.

The most difficult conversation is happening with Salley. Charley is currently with the group, and Salley is upset that she wasn’t fully informed about Charley and Craig’s situation. Charley explains she wanted to hear Craig’s side of things directly, without outside opinions. Leva then suggests that if your friend had feelings for him first, the friendship is over. Honestly, Leva’s opinion doesn’t really matter – she hasn’t been around much this season and doesn’t understand what’s going on. Everyone agrees Salley is out of line, especially considering how she reacted when Venita advised against dating Craig.

Charley apologized to Salley on the porch, and it came out that Salley had confessed to still having feelings for Craig over text – yet Charley went on a date with Craig anyway. While I understand Salley’s frustration, let’s consider the facts. Craig never seemed interested in her, so it wasn’t a viable relationship. Salley quickly moved on to Austen and seems much more focused on him than getting back with Craig. She’s upset that Charley wasn’t supportive, which is fair, but shouldn’t Venita feel the same way? Honestly, I don’t feel much sympathy for Salley. Charley, however, completely accepts her version of events, apologizes, and then ends up comforting her – after she’s the one who had to break up with someone on national television (and then again on Peacock).

Craig and Austen are having a conversation, and Craig complains about people constantly interfering in his life. As he’s talking, two women can be seen peering at the filming from a window, seemingly proving his point. Craig suggests Salley played a role in his recent breakup, but Austen strongly disagrees. He accuses Craig of saying hurtful things to people and then refusing to take responsibility for his actions. They fall into a familiar pattern: Craig claims he’s trying to improve, while Austen argues he won’t admit he has a problem with anger. Austen insists that acknowledging his anger is the first step for Craig to move forward.

I completely agree with Austen’s perspective. Craig claims he wants to improve, but his behavior hasn’t changed at all. He admitted to having an addiction, yet he’s still drinking. He says he’s working on his emotional control, but he continues to lash out at the cast. It seems likely he’ll be upset at the reunion when everyone confronts him about his actions. As Heather Dubrow famously said, “When everyone says you’re dead, it’s time to lie down.” If Craig actually took their feedback to heart, made an effort to change how he treats people, or even just drank less around the group – which would likely reduce his anger – he might not face so much criticism.

Craig storms off, and Austen quickly follows. Salley doesn’t let him get far, chasing after him and demanding he return to the party. It feels like a scene from a romantic comedy. They end up arguing – Salley on the stairs of the venue, and Austen on the other side of a fence. If they weren’t so caught up in social media, it could be a classic Meg Ryan and Tom Hanks moment. Salley apologizes for having feelings for him, and Austen admits he thinks she’s great, but isn’t ready for a relationship. She senses he feels the same way, but he avoids answering. She insists he does want to be with her. He then abruptly asks if he’s going to meet up with Whitney and Shep – and Shep’s surprisingly suitable date (who also happens to be Venita’s tennis coach) – whether or not she’ll be joining them. She is, definitely. Salley has been building up to this all season, and now it’s happening: she rushes down the stairs, jumps in the car with Austen, spends the night out with him, goes back to his place, and finally heads home in the morning.

She found her three chickens – Cantaloupe, Popcorn, and Hubba Bubba Max Cherry Lemonade – still in their pen in the backyard, pecking and making a mess as usual. They were a reminder of a failed plan, an attempt to tie a man to her life – a man who didn’t reciprocate her feelings and over whom she’d risked two friendships. Now, instead of being held captive, she felt trapped by their constant demands and the unpleasantness of their enclosure. It was a painful reminder that sometimes the hardest path is the one you need to take. She opened the gate, hoping they’d rush out, a flurry of feathers soaring into the sky, finally free. But they didn’t move, just continued pecking and stepping in their mess, seemingly confused by the sight of the woman by the door crying.

Read More

2026-03-12 04:59