Why Jeremy Renner’s Doc Holliday Movie Never Happened: The Untold Story!

by

For years, numerous projects have faced what’s often referred to as “development limbo,” due to various issues such as production delays, creative disputes, and a host of other challenges and hurdles; Jeremy Renner‘s biopic on Doc Holliday is no exception, as it has yet to come to fruition since it was announced that the Hawkeye actor would portray the iconic gunslinger in 2017. Despite generating much excitement and anticipation online at its inception, the project’s fate remains uncertain eight years later, particularly after Renner’s snow plow accident in 2023.

As a film enthusiast, I’ve always been fascinated by the enigmatic figure of Doc Holliday. The richness of his story and the various interpretations it has inspired are evident from the numerous movies that have portrayed him. However, despite the potential for an outstanding portrayal with Jeremy Renner, a compelling Doc Holliday film never materialized, leaving this project in a state of suspended animation for years.

Jeremy Renner’s Planned Doc Holliday Movie Explained

The Film Would’ve Shown A Lot Of Holliday’s Life Before Tombstone, AZ

Back in 2017, it was revealed that Jeremy Renner’s portrayal of Doc Holliday would be based on two novels by author Mary Doria Russell: “Doc” and “Epitaph: A Novel of the O.K. Corral”. Unlike previous films like “Wyatt Earp” and “Gunfight at the O.K. Corral”, this biopic starring Renner would offer a personal perspective on Holliday’s life before he became a famed gunslinger, focusing on his past as a dentist from Georgia, his struggle-filled journey that eventually led to the Tombstone showdown in Arizona, and even his years of gambling and battle with tuberculosis.

Following this approach, the upcoming biographical movie about Holliday, as portrayed by Renner, was shaping up to delve deeper into the character’s psyche rather than focusing on action-packed scenes typical of a western genre. Films like Dances with Wolves and The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford serve as good examples of this style. While the story might concentrate on Holliday’s early life, it’s highly improbable that the iconic gunfight at the O.K. Corral would be omitted from the movie’s finale. Given that any comprehensive biopic about Holliday should acknowledge his involvement in the showdown – a significant event that has been depicted and mythologized in countless western movies for close to a century.

Why Hasn’t Jeremy Renner’s Doc Holliday Movie Happened?

The Answer’s More Complicated Than You Think

Despite garnering much online interest for Jeremy Renner’s portrayal of the western hero, the Holliday biopic has struggled to gain momentum over the past eight years, as evidenced by the scarcity of significant updates about the project since its initial announcement almost a decade ago. A variety of reasons have contributed to the film’s delayed production, with the COVID-19 pandemic and Renner’s near-fatal accident in 2023 being among the most prominent. This unfortunate event halted the actor’s career and led him on a lengthy recovery journey, but fortunately, he made a successful comeback.

Another possible reason for the film’s production delay could be the poor box office performance of western films lately. For instance, Clint Eastwood’s “Cry Macho” and Kevin Costner’s “Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter 1” didn’t initially make a profit when they were released. Moreover, it seems that the interest in western stories has moved from movies to television over the last five years. This is evident with the recent success of Taylor Sheridan’s “Yellowstone” franchise and its spinoffs, including “1883” and “1923.

As an admirer, I believe that the most expedient way for the long-delayed biopic of Renner’s Holliday might find a swift path to production could be by reimagining its storyline as a captivating miniseries, meticulously portraying the complex and tumultuous life of the gunslinger.

It May Be For The Best That Renner’s Doc Holliday Movie Didn’t Happen

Development Hell Could Be A Blessing In Disguise

It’s regrettable that Jeremy Renner may not portray Doc Holliday as some of us had hoped, but it could ultimately turn out to be a blessing in disguise, given Val Kilmer’s passing in April. In fact, Kilmer’s portrayal of Holliday in the 1993 film “Tombstone” is widely regarded as the definitive one, eclipsing that of other renowned actors like Kurt Russell, Bill Paxton, Billy Bob Thornton, and Sam Elliott. His captivating performance of the charismatic and refined gunslinger was truly unforgettable.

As a dedicated cinephile, it feels like the right time for Jeremy Renner’s Doc Holliday biopic to find its resolution amidst the current pause. This isn’t because of any shortcoming on Renner’s part, but rather as a tribute and respect for Val Kilmer’s unforgettable portrayal of the character. Just like sports teams retiring the numbers of legendary players such as Lou Gehrig and Jackie Robinson, Kilmer’s iconic performance holds a special place that deserves due reverence.

In the grand scheme of cinematic endeavors, tackling a project on this scale is an incredibly challenging task, one that requires immense skill and bravery for any actor to take on. While I always appreciate an actor who’s willing to swing for the fences, considering Kilmer’s recent passing, even a mediocre attempt might leave a bitter aftertaste in the hearts of fans.

While it might not guarantee success, the prospect of Renner’s biopic finally coming to life should still be embraced. If the movie eventually materializes after years in production limbo, it would be appropriate to wish the filmmakers good luck and hope they manage to achieve even a hint of the greatness they aspire for. In the end, whether this biopic will become another American masterpiece is something that only time can tell. The one thing I’m confident about is that we had already witnessed such a classic in 1993.

Read More

2025-06-07 23:08