Warner Bros. TV Fires Back at Michael Crichton’s Widow Over ‘Baseless’ Claim ‘The Pitt’ Is an ‘ER’ Ripoff: It’s a ‘New and Original Show’ (EXCLUSIVE)

As a seasoned film critic with decades of experience watching medical dramas unfold on the small screen, I must say that the ongoing legal battle between Warner Bros. TV and Michael Crichton’s widow over their upcoming series “The Pitt” has piqued my curiosity. Having witnessed the rise and fall (and occasional resurgence) of countless medical procedurals throughout the years, I can confidently assert that the similarities between “ER” and “The Pitt,” while undeniable in certain aspects, are not enough to warrant a courtroom showdown.


Warner Bros. Television is countering a lawsuit initiated on Tuesday by Michael Crichton’s wife, labeling it as “unfounded”. They assert that their forthcoming medical series titled “The Pitt” bears no resemblance to the show “ER”, arguing distinct differences between the two productions.

“In response to the lawsuit brought forth by the Crichton Estate, the studio firmly asserts that ‘The Pitt’ is an entirely new and unique production. Any implication to the contrary is unfounded, and Warner Bros. Television plans to strongly counter these groundless accusations.”

After the Crichton estate accused executive producer John Wells of a “personal betrayal,” claiming he and Noah Wyle conceived “The Pitt” following the estate’s refusal to allow a reboot of “ER.” The lawsuit states, ” ‘The Pitt’ is ‘ER.’ It isn’t similar to ‘ER,’ it isn’t somewhat like ‘ER,’ nor is it reminiscent of ‘ER.’ It is ‘ER,’ featuring the same executive producer, writer, main actor, production companies, studio, and network as the proposed reboot of ‘ER.'” In simpler terms, “The Pitt” is essentially a rebranded version of “ER,” using the same team that was intended to bring back the original series.

However, there seems to be a disagreement about the likeness between “ER” and “The Pitt”. Experts point out that the only real correlation lies in the fact that both shows are set in an emergency room, produced by Wells, and feature Noah Wyle as the lead actor. Nevertheless, Wells is emphasizing distinct themes and moods with “The Pitt”, diverging from the path taken by “ER”.

It’s clear that each episode’s narrative will have its unique flow, and it’s thought that this new show will veer sharply from “ER” in terms of appearance, atmosphere, and sound. Unlike “ER,” which was set in a Chicago hospital, this series is based in Pittsburgh, with no recurring characters or similar visual cues found in “ER.”

Instead of the initial 22-episode seasons that “ER” ran on NBC, our show will air on streaming platform Max, comprising only 15 episodes. As a result, our production, “The Pitt,” will delve deeper into more mature and explicit themes due to its streamer format.

“Wells mentioned another perk of producing shows for streaming platforms, stating that they don’t have the same strict broadcasting standards. This allows for a more mature portrayal of content than what was previously possible under FCC rules for television. The show ‘The Pitt’, in particular, excites them because it enables the depiction of authentic hospital scenarios and human interactions within the healthcare system. Wells believes that streaming platforms can host sophisticated visual and storytelling versions of such programs.”

It’s been confirmed that Wells originally pitched an idea for revamping hospital dramas in the post-COVID world to Warner Bros. TV, focusing on the changes experienced by hospitals and emergency rooms during and following the pandemic – a departure from “ER.” However, when negotiations with the Crichton estate broke down, the producers decided instead to proceed with creating a new medical series that isn’t connected to the “ER” franchise or its history.

It’s often noted that medical dramas are quite prevalent on television. In fact, when “ER” first aired on NBC, CBS countered with another hospital series, this one also based in Chicago, titled “Chicago Hope.”

Wyle takes the lead in a series that follows “the everyday heroes working at a contemporary hospital in Pittsburgh,” as stated in the show’s description. Additionally starring are Tracy Ifeachor, Patrick Ball, Supriya Ganesh, Fiona Dourif, Taylor Dearden, Isa Briones, Gerran Howell, Shabana Azeez, and Katherine LaNasa.

R. Scott Gemmill will pen the initial episode and serve as an executive producer, working alongside Wyle. Additionally, John Wells of John Wells Productions (JWP) and team members Erin Jontow, Simran Baidwan, and Michael Hissrich will also executive produce. The studio responsible for production is Warner Bros. Television, where JWP has an overall deal.

Read More

2024-08-28 02:47