TVL: Crypto’s Shiny Lie?! 🤯

by

Total Value Locked (TVL), like a samovar at a techno party, is brandished as the ultimate yardstick for DeFi projects. Popularity? Adoption? Overall health? All supposedly laid bare. But is it, really? David Silverman from Polygon Labs, with the weary wisdom of a babushka who’s seen it all, suggests TVL is more about fleeting fame than genuine insight. 🧐

In an exclusive chat with BeInCrypto (yes, we’re that important), Silverman, with a sigh that could rival the Volga’s current, explained TVL’s shortcomings. He then hinted at a savior: Chain-Aligned TVL (CAT). A feline metric, perhaps? One that actually chases value instead of napping on it? 😼

Why TVL, Like a Bad Vodka, Leaves You Wanting More

Silverman concedes that TVL offers a superficial glance at assets held within a protocol or chain. But, he argues, its importance is as reliable as a Lada in winter. Its accuracy? Well, let’s just say it’s more “artistic interpretation” than hard fact. 🎨

“TVL is mostly a headline-grabber, a fleeting overview of the value residing on a DeFi platform or chain. But most people, bless their cotton socks, haven’t a clue what it truly means. 🤷‍♀️ To say Ethereum boasts a TVL of $44.38 billion is like saying the Kremlin has a lot of walls—true, but hardly illuminating.” Silverman, channeling his inner Tolstoy, tells BeInCrypto.

According to DefiLlama, Ethereum (ETH), in April 2025, reigns supreme in TVL, hoarding more than half the market like a dragon its gold. Polygon (POL), meanwhile, languishes at $760.9 million, the 13th largest chain. A respectable number, but still… 😔

DefiLlama Data on TVL

Despite attempts to refine TVL tracking, Silverman maintains that fundamental flaws persist. Thus, he champions Chain-Aligned TVL—a metric with a name so direct, it’s practically shouting from the rooftops! 📣

CAT, Silverman explains, focuses on the active use of assets, not just their mere existence. Like a good dancer, it contributes to the party, not just occupies space. 💃

“Knowing how much USDC or USDT lounges around on a chain is headline fodder. But if those tokens are just snoozing in a wallet, contributing nothing, do they really add value? It’s like having a Faberge egg you only use as a paperweight.” He questions with theatrical flare.

To illustrate, he points out that $1 million worth of USDT in Morpho is far more beneficial, earning yield and growing the chain’s TVL by extending credit. A working asset, not a decorative one. 💪

“This is the core of Chain-Aligned TVL: the total value of assets that actively support and strengthen their underlying chain, whether held natively or within aligned protocols.” Silverman declares, as if revealing a state secret.

The aim, he adds, is to link CAT with projects that genuinely benefit their communities. Like a well-stocked community garden, it nourishes all who participate. 🥕

Unleashing DeFi Potential: How Chain-Aligned TVL Benefits YOU (Yes, You!)

Silverman outlines the user benefits of Chain-Aligned TVL, explaining that its nuanced approach helps users discover juicier yield opportunities. Like finding a hidden stash of borscht at a potluck! 🍲

“Chains will naturally favor projects that benefit them. Hence, they’re more likely to promote projects with higher chain-aligned TVLs, making it easier for users to find high-yielding opportunities.” He notes, as if sharing the location of buried treasure.

Silverman also emphasizes that CAT drives the development of more effective and user-friendly applications. Chains will prioritize projects that integrate well and benefit the ecosystem. Like a harmonious choir, everyone sings in tune. 🎶

“Benefits include easier/cheaper/faster transitions and better DeFi opportunities.” He claims, with the confidence of a fortune teller reading tea leaves.

CAT-driven projects may offer better interest rates and more engaging experiences in games and NFTs, as developers are incentivized to boost ecosystem engagement. Like a carnival barker luring you in with promises of fun and prizes! 🎪

The benefits extend beyond users, positively impacting entire blockchains. A rising tide lifts all boats, as they say. ⛵

“CAT is a metric that all chains can leverage to better understand where their development efforts should be focused.” Silverman reveals, as if imparting ancient wisdom.

He points out that transaction fees alone aren’t a sustainable business model. Focusing on CAT brings long-term value, not just fleeting transaction revenue. Like investing in a well-tended orchard rather than a field of dandelions. 🌳

To showcase Chain-Aligned TVL, Silverman cites Agora’s AUSD deployment on Polygon. An example so specific, it’s almost a product placement! 🎬

“While other stables may have large amounts of idle TVL, only the issuer benefits. With AUSD, a portion of the yield generated from reserves is emitted on the chain as incentives, growing protocols, rewarding users, and boosting the chain’s economy.” He highlights, as if presenting the Holy Grail of DeFi.

While Silverman makes a compelling case for Chain-Aligned TVL, widespread adoption remains a challenge. TVL has dominated DeFi for years, becoming the gold standard. Like trying to replace vodka with kombucha at a Russian wedding! 👰‍♀️

Shifting to a more nuanced metric like CAT requires industry-wide education and a change in how developers and users evaluate blockchain value. A daunting task, but not impossible. 🏔️

However, as the ecosystem matures, metrics like CAT could gain traction, offering a more sustainable way to measure a chain’s true impact. Like a slow-burning fire, it will eventually warm the entire house. 🔥

Read More

2025-04-18 15:55