Top Chef Recap: Les Quatre Saisons

by

What does it take to be a Top Chef?

Over the course of time, the nature of the winners has undergone a substantial shift. Regardless of intention, each victor has symbolized an aspect of the development and refinement of gastronomy and haute cuisine in our society. We’ve witnessed prodigious talents like Richard Blais and Michael Voltaggio who excelled in technical finesse, as well as comfort-focused stars such as Stephanie Izard and Joe Flamm. We’ve observed emerging artists from the Michelin family, including Kelsey Barnard Clark and Jeremy Ford, branching out on their own paths. Remarkable resurgences have been seen in chefs like Melissa King and our respected host Kristen Kish, who attained success by refining their individual culinary styles. The tales of their journeys inevitably find expression in their dishes – but is there a need for food to tell a story to be truly exceptional?

This week’s episode opens with an intriguing question and a pivotal moment. Following César’s elimination, Vinny expresses relief that he “escaped a bullet – or a laser” by not being sent home for his accidentally frozen tartare. However, when Vinny suggests that he might need to cook less with a specific story in mind, Tristen disagrees, arguing that it’s impossible for him to create dishes that “don’t have a tale.

Massimo doesn’t follow a story when he cooks,” he says casually. “Instead, I ask myself: ‘What are the finest ingredients available, and how would I like to enjoy them?’

Tristen seemed unusually somber in this episode, not his typical affable self. Considering that it’s just been about a week since his father passed away, it’s reasonable he might still be dealing with the shock and grief. With the excitement of Restaurant Wars behind him, it was only a matter of time before Tristen fully processed the news.

By intensifying his rivalry in the competition as a tribute to his father, Tristen has given victory an additional depth of importance. Perhaps this is why he’s also chosen to make one of his fellow chefs an adversary, despite admitting in a private moment that it could come across as quite harsh.

Tristen states that Massimo is his greatest inspiration. In essence, he symbolizes the standard Tristen strives to surpass. With Massimo constantly challenging him with French and Italian dishes, Tristen is determined to outdo him,” says Tristen.

I’m torn on this subject. While Tristen, a talented Black chef from the South, incorporates unique West African flavors into fine dining, setting him apart on shows like Top Chef, he should be more widely recognized for his achievements. Unfortunately, the culinary world can be exclusive and tends to favor similar types of chefs. This is evident in the unfortunate reality that Top Chef has only ever crowned one Black chef as a winner.

Instead of saying that Tristen labeling Massimo as embodying the historical fixation on French and Italian cuisine in the culinary world feels like projection, it might be clearer to express it this way: Tristen’s characterization of Massimo as a symbol of the historic fascination with French and Italian cuisine seems somewhat self-reflective or biased. Despite being vocal, Massimo is not pushy about his opinions, even when his menu idea was rejected by Tristen’s Restaurant Wars team. Food, in Massimo’s case, may not require a “story” to be heartfelt, and it appears that the image of Massimo bothers Tristen more than the real man does.

Currently, Massimo appears quite unfazed. (Throughout the season, I’ve often likened him to Fabio Viviani, but it’s clear that Fabio would have shown more excitement.) It’s also worth noting that since it’s Montreal Week, Massimo feels comfortable – despite the fact they haven’t left Toronto for some financial reasons.

Credit goes to the set designers of Top Chef for transforming the kitchen’s pantry into an intricate duplicate of a Montreal bodega (or a “dépanneur”). When Tom brings Last Chance Kitchen winner César back into the competition (Farewell, Katianna, you were so very close!), Saturday Night Live alum Punkie Johnson appears to set the Quickfire challenge. The chefs must create dishes using solely ingredients from the dépanneur and appliances available backstage. This means no blenders, no skillets, no ovens, and most inconveniently, no utensils sharper than a plastic knife.

I quite enjoy the challenging “no-tool” Quickfires, but this one was particularly tough. Many chefs prepared dishes reminiscent of fast food, similar to the hasty creations made by season eight’s all-stars during their ferry voyage. For just the second time this season, Tristen’s undercooked hot dog soup and Bailey’s burnt toast landed them in the bottom. Lana’s dry waffle also didn’t impress, and Vinny’s attempt to innovate with an “Uncrustable” variant only seemed to upset Tom. (When you mix foie gras and goat cheese but omit any kind of jam, Tom gets grumpy.)

As a movie enthusiast, I must say that the top accolades belong to Massimo’s luxurious pig-in-a-blanket, César’s exquisite pressure-cooked popcorn grits, and Shuai’s delectable air-fried croque monsieur. To his delightful astonishment, it was César who emerged victorious, making a remarkable comeback and pocketing the $10,000 prize. Congratulations on your triumphant return, dear César! Treat yourself to some beautiful indoor planters that can gracefully adorn your living space outside of your bed.

Moving on to elimination round. In celebration of Montreal’s “green roof movement,” the chefs are tasked with creating dishes using local produce that align with a particular season. As the winner of the Quickfire Challenge, César gets to skip one contestant from his responsibility. He selects summer. The remaining competitors then draw knives, which results in Tristen and Vinny getting spring, Lana and Bailey receiving fall, and Massimo and Shuai being assigned winter.

Before the chef Shuai, there was a letter from his wife discovered in his baggage earlier than anticipated. It was a heartfelt message detailing their joint efforts to establish their initial food truck and how ‘Top Chef’ could symbolize another equally gratifying risk. He described it as “quite inspiring,” though this phrase triggers my Ominous Edit Radar, suggesting he will either excel or depart. His fate hangs in the balance.

It seems that the chefs were mentally debating between Tristen’s and Massimo’s culinary philosophies, given the abundance of mythological influences in their dishes. Lana, who aimed to pay tribute to her German roots with a squash spaetzle, fell short, disappointing the judges. Vinny went overboard with the “sustainability” theme by adding leftover lamb to his mushroom consommé, making it overly pungent in both taste and smell (oh dear!). Tristen, who appeared to be off his game, attempted to blend flavors from his Polish grandmother and Swedish experiences under Marcus Samuelsson. Unfortunately, his cabbage-and-potato dish ended up being either excessively seasoned or not seasoned enough. When the judges questioned if a particular ingredient was present, Tristen understood the criticism loud and clear.

During Cesar’s individual summer stint, his cherry tomato and pistachio cream corn gazpacho didn’t quite impress the judges. Punkie, in particular, was taken aback by Cesar’s claim of poached lobster, as it seemed scarcely present. Although his dish wasn’t offensive, given his Quickfire win, Cesar is currently safe. However, Tom cautioned the other judges, “At this point in the competition, you aim to astound us.

The top three dishes harmoniously blend technical finesse and rich flavors to faithfully represent their respective seasons. Bailey anticipates that her boldly spiced squash agrodolce might displease a few judges, and she nearly achieves this when Kristen finds the dish seems “more like a sauce.” However, once Tom gave it a hearty approval, she was well on her way to victory.

In a slightly different phrasing, we could say: The winter chefs also emerged victorious, despite Massimo’s initial comment that Montrealers might indulge in heavier meals, more drinks, and increased intimacy during the cold season. Although the judges suggested adding something else to enrich the dish (perhaps a potato), the skilled cook’s mastery of the salt-crust chicken compensated for this oversight.

The victor in this round is indeed Shuai! Hooray! Breaking free from the possible Letters From Home jinx, he prepared a “last hot pot” dish that’s both cozy and sophisticated. Tom can’t stop praising it. “It gave me a taste of how you cook,” he shares. “Each bite had a clear intention.” It appears that both the judges and I have been eagerly waiting for Shuai to regain his culinary stride, so we’re all ecstatic about this outcome.

In a contrasting turn of events, it appears Vinny isn’t able to evade the criticism this round. Tom remarks, “I’m yet to truly understand your culinary identity,” which undoubtedly struck him. However, Vinny demonstrates admirable sportsmanship by saying, “I’m at peace,” to his peers in the Stew Room, followed by a wish for their future success.

Everyone seems to be down; it’s evident that he will be greatly missed. If he manages to establish his unique culinary approach and eventually makes it to an All-Star season, I can assure you I would be equally excited to witness him, along with his humorous antics, back in the kitchen of Top Chef.

Leftovers

I couldn’t quite connect with her brown leather Quickfire corset, yet I find myself completely captivated by the clean striped vest and trouser combination she donned at the Elimination dinner. Score: 8/10.

• “Punkie, thank you for bringing this lovely challenge.” “I’m sorry for ruining the show!”

Regarding Punkie, I strongly recommend reading Padma Lakshmi’s essay in the 2021 edition of “Best American Food and Travel Writing” anthology, which she co-edited with Jaya Saxena, where she describes her visit to her New Orleans family during Mardi Gras.

This season on “Top Chef,” there’s been less personal drama than usual. Given this, it’s understandable that the editors have focused on every suspicious moment involving Massimo. When Massimo greeted his fellow Montreal chefs with a loud “Welcome!” and Tristen rolled his eyes in response, those subtle actions were definitely not going to be overlooked.

An authentic Southern moment for Tristen: casually looking into the camera as he reflexively stirs Bailey’s polenta, adhering to the unwritten rule in every Southern kitchen – “never pass by the grits without giving them a stir.” Well done, good sir.

Next week brings us to Calgary, but the highlight that truly matters: TOM IS DONNING A HAT AGAIN! The global tension we’ve felt has been lifted!

Read More

2025-05-16 06:56