‘The Sopranos’ Creator David Chase Worried James Gandolfini ‘Wasn’t Threatening Enough’ Before Casting Him in Iconic Lead Role: ‘I Have One Concern’

If events had unfolded differently, a different actor might have headed “The Sopranos” ensemble. However, thankfully, the show’s creator, David Chase, refrained from his initial impulsive decision regarding James Gandolfini.

As a movie reviewer, I found myself reflecting on David Chase’s concerns about James Gandolfini not appearing “menacing enough” when he was initially considering him for the iconic role of Tony Soprano, as detailed in Jason Bailey’s book “Gandolfini: Jim, Tony, and the Life of a Legend.” However, after some deliberation, Chase ultimately decided to cast Gandolfini in what would become his career-defining performance.

During the process of creating the series, Nancy Sanders, Gandolfini’s manager, shared with Chase that she believed she had found the character of Tony Soprano. However, Chase was initially hesitant about this idea.

Alright, here’s the situation,” Chase shared with Sanders following his review of Gandolfini’s work. “I believe he’s incredibly talented, but there’s a single question mark – does he come across as menacing enough?

Sanders vigorously defended her client, swiftly assuaging Chase’s worries, “If you told me he was somewhat overweight or balding, I could comprehend. But he appears intimidating. That’s your man.

The casting directors for “The Sopranos,” Sheila Jaffe and Georgianne Walken, shared Sanders’ excitement. They recalled that Gandolfini had always been their top pick since the project’s inception.

In his own thoughts, Gandolfini doubted he’d secure the role of Tony Soprano. He reminisced about his skepticism, saying, “I believe I said something like, ‘I could easily give this guy a good kick, but I’ll never be chosen. They’ll pick some handsome young man instead.’ I assumed they would cast, as they often do nowadays, one of those Irish-looking actors who are so prevalent on television.

He too had fears that collaborating with Chase might prove challenging or difficult. Yet, once they had their breakfast together, all his worries seemed unfounded.

“When he finally settled down and really did a reading, it was just obvious,” Chase said.

“The Sopranos” is currently streaming on Max.

Read More

2025-04-27 00:49