The Precinct is out today and reviews are mixed

by

Today marks the release of The Precinct, a police sandbox simulator game, and opinions are divided. This top-down shooter hails from Fallen Tree Games, and it’s currently rated 65 on Metacritic and 69 on OpenCritic. So, it seems that this highly anticipated game didn’t quite meet expectations. While we encourage you to read our comprehensive review, it appears the challenge of creating an enjoyable experience while accurately depicting life as a beat cop in an 80s-inspired city was more difficult to strike a balance than initially thought.

The Precinct receives mixed reviews: the challenges of balancing fun with simulation

According to numerous reviews, it appears that The Precinct starts off with an engaging plot that maintains interest during the initial playtime, but later becomes repetitive. Interestingly, opinions on the game’s Steam page are significantly more favorable. Currently, The Precinct boasts a 90% positive rating from over 120 player reviews. This discrepancy might be due to critics and players having different experiences, as many of these reviews only reflect two or three hours of gameplay. To get a clearer perspective, it’s advisable to allow players more time to progress in the game and observe how their opinions evolve.

Some reviews mention the game’s mechanics related to simulations. Critics have pointed out that surprisingly enjoyable aspects exist within the game, such as issuing parking tickets or checking IDs, apprehending criminals, and waiting for crimes to be reported before taking action. Although these tasks can be mundane and somewhat dull, the game does strive to simulate the experience of being an honest, diligent police officer.

As a gamer, it’s disappointing when the immersion breaks so easily. For instance, there are no repercussions for ramming my car into city assets or darting out in front of unsuspecting drivers to dish out hit-and-run citations. It’s also questionable that my partner can just magically appear in the car with me as we flee, despite the game explicitly instructing me to wait for them first. This inconsistency between what feels real and what doesn’t detracts from the overall gaming experience.

In the game “The Precinct”, if it’s aiming to mimic traditional cop movies as some reviews suggest, perhaps they could introduce a police chief who becomes increasingly angry at the player for performing risky stunts. The penalties should be severe enough that the protagonist ultimately loses their badge, compelling them to become a vigilante in the name of justice. This element is often seen in cop movies, but it’s less common in video games, especially sandbox-style games. It would be intriguing to observe how players navigate the challenge of being a good cop and then turning to lawlessness when the system fails them.

The “angry police chief” character is commendable, however, a more authentic depiction might involve implementing a “point system” that penalizes the player for actions such as reckless driving, law-breaking, or causing destruction. This would transform each criminal chase into a delicate equilibrium between pursuing the criminal swiftly and avoiding costly mishaps like damaging the police vehicle or incurring hefty city expenses. Such a system could serve as an engaging representation of moral dilemmas, albeit on a simplified level.

Let’s observe how gamers respond to playing extended periods of “The Precinct”. While some platforms like Steam collect reviews immediately, others such as Metacritic encourage users to play more before submitting their opinions. Therefore, in the coming days, as an influx of reviews arrives, we can determine if this is simply a matter of differing viewpoints between players and critics or if the game receives mixed feedback overall.

Read More

2025-05-13 23:06