The Challenge 40: Battle of the Eras Season-Premiere Recap: This Is 40

As a longtime fan of The Challenge, I must say that this season is shaping up to be quite the spectacle! It’s like watching a high-stakes game of chess played by characters who are as captivating as they are ruthless.


For over four decades, there have been heated brawls over frozen pizzas, sensual wrestling matches in mud pits, and clandestine affairs on buses, all among 40 of the most formidable contestants from MTV’s long-running series, “The Challenge”. Originally spun off from the hit show “Road Rules” featuring young adults causing chaos in an RV, it eventually incorporated participants from “The Real World” and later, stars from any reality show within the Paramount Global network (making us fans of such mergers). Unlike other strategy-based competition shows like “Survivor” or “Big Brother”, which introduce new cast members each season, “The Challenge” keeps a revolving door of eccentric characters year after year, elevating rookies to main roles if they can successfully claim screen time from established favorites.

As a seasoned movie critic, I’ve had the privilege to witness the evolution of these unconventional characters, from playfully chasing each other through mansions with ketchup bottles in hand to somberly hosting funeral ceremonies for wigs. Now, as they reach a significant milestone, The Challenge has gathered an exceptional ensemble for this historic season – legends like Johnny Bananas and Cara Maria, fresh faces such as Survivor champion Michele Fitzgerald, and veterans who’ve hung up their competition shoes, including Emily, Leroy, and Aviv, returning to the scene one last time. In The Challenge: Battle of the Eras, these aging rebels will engage in epic battles for the only prize that truly matters: proving themselves worthy to their children.

Essentially, they’re vying for a million dollars, but instead of discussing more adult topics, most contestants focus on their children at home, except for Aviv who occasionally discusses her desire for plastic surgery. It’s surprising that even a show like ‘The Challenge’, known for its wild and rowdy nature, is now dominated by discussions about babies. This might be a sign of aging, as one would expect a more adult-oriented conversation from such a program.

The team is transported to their initial hurdle inside a massive cargo trailer, reminiscent of Cara Maria’s horses being led to the stable. Upon arrival, they find themselves on a picturesque Vietnamese dock, with drones flying off in the background – it’s 2024 indeed! The players then sort themselves into groups labeled as Eras I-IV, reflecting the seasons of the show where they first debuted.

Every time, host T.J. Lavin appears, donning attire suitable for boisterous sidelines at his son’s Little League soccer match. He launches into his customary speech from the cue cards, yet barely manages to complete two sentences before C.T. Tamburello bursts into tears, moved by feelings. His agent will surely have some strong words for him regarding Josh’s signature move!

The warm, sentimental feelings and positive energy are swiftly knocked off the Burj Khalifa when T.J. reveals that to proceed to the next phase of the game, they’ll be required to challenge their own team members from Era in the Era Invitational.

No, this is not an invitation to Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour, despite the painfully misleading title. It’s a purgelike event where the losing man and woman from each Era will be forced to fight for their spot in the game in an elimination round. Their opponent will be decided by their team’s winners.

Absolutely, that implies eight players will leave the competition very quickly, which can be quite disappointing. One of the exciting aspects of this significant season is its impressive ensemble cast, yet 20% of them will have limited on-screen time before being asked to return to their homes, essentially babysitting again. I don’t typically support redemption houses, but I would welcome one this season.

In order to ensure everyone’s safety, contestants will participate in a game called “Light Up”. The initial challenge for the players is to swiftly assemble a 3-D jigsaw puzzle representing the number 40. Once completed, they need to board a miniature, glowing boat that resembles a Disney teacup on roller skates and navigate through the sea to collect ten lights that match specific colors and are attached to floating buoys. The first male and female contestants from each time period who successfully return to land, place their collected strobes at their designated stations, and cross the finish line will emerge victorious.

As a seasoned game show enthusiast with years of viewing under my belt, I have come to observe that certain puzzles can be either frustratingly complex or, more often than not, they appear deceptively simple, leaving even the most knowledgeable contestants scratching their heads. Take, for instance, the episode where Tony seemed to be stuck on a particular puzzle for what felt like an eternity. It was almost as if he were trying to will the correct answer into existence with his impressive biceps and seemingly limited intellect – a tactic that, alas, proved fruitless. This experience reminded me of my own struggles in school when faced with a challenging problem or concept, leaving me wondering if I too might be as knowledge-challenged as Tony seemed to be on this particular occasion. The infamous “northern continent” puzzle still lingers in my memory as an example of the unexpected challenges that can arise during a seemingly straightforward game.

In a simpler and more natural manner: Laurel, known for her road rage temperament, swiftly installs her car’s flashing lights. Meanwhile, her sister Cara Maria follows closely in hot pursuit, although they are actually the same age. (Laurel calls Cara her “little sister” as a way of being condescending.)

Over a decade has passed since Laurel criticized Cara severely on “Cutthroat”, yet Cara continues to value Laurel’s approval, even though she has outshined Laurel in terms of final appearances, elimination victories, and earnings. In a private conversation, Cara acknowledges that Laurel is kind only when she feels confident that she’s superior to Cara, which is a sign of an admirable, absolutely non-toxic individual whose approval you should strive for.

In the Era II competition, Laurel beats Cara to claim the women’s top spot, while Bananas takes the lead among the men. Unfortunately, KellyAnne and Ryan didn’t make it, so I bid them farewell with the phrase, “May the exit not slam you on your way out.”

In a first for Era I, two-time champion Rachel triumphed in collaboration with puzzle expert C.T., who frequently compares his puzzle prowess to a muscular Bobby Fischer. On the other hand, Grandpa Mark and Katie “I’m on vacation” Cooley placed last, an outcome that didn’t come as a shock to spectators.

1. In Era III, the fellows suffer a tough defeat – they fail to solve a puzzle challenge against Cory, which is similar to bombing out in the initial round of “Are You Smarter Than a 5th Grader.” After Devin’s teacup overturns, he decides to plow through his strobe collection while swimming, eventually reaching shore and spitting out water as if he were an unwell Victorian child. The general consensus is that this is quite unusual. Tori triumphs for the women, with Nia and Leroy coming up short.

Season IV has been chaotic and unpredictable since its inception, with no signs of slowing down. In the latest challenge, Horacio, boasting a chiseled physique, along with former Survivor champion Michele, emerged victorious. However, even Horacio’s power proves futile when it comes to safeguarding Nuracio, as he is unable to prevent his beloved girlfriend Nurys from being eliminated alongside Theo, the U.K.’s antagonist.

Nury feels overwhelmed and fears being eliminated due to the strong competition from women like Jenny, who defeated all male contestants in her season “Total Madness”, Kaycee with her impressive 7-2 elimination record (her two losses were largely due to her handicap during “Ride or Dies” by her brother with spindly limbs), and Olivia, who resembles Charli XCX to her in terms of charisma.

It’s a lineup that would instill the fear of Pazuzu in most, but Nurys is selling herself short! We can’t forget that she sent home Horacio and Kyland, two of the most dominant men of Battle for a New Champion, just last season in a daunting elimination round.

Following the competition, we catch our initial glimpse of this year’s mansion, lavishly adorned with a flamboyant, fiery-red fabric covering, lending an eerie, “McDonald’s After Midnight” vibe throughout the place. In the upstairs bedrooms, C.T. and Darrell conduct a special episode of The Joe Rogan Experience, expressing their disappointment about the harmful effects of plastics nowadays and expressing gratitude that they won’t have to grapple with bunk beds this season due to their arthritic joints. It seems that The Challenge contestants are indeed past the age for bunk beds, but they would be perfectly suitable for the women on The Golden Bachelor. Quite intriguing!

Concerning the elderly folks, even as the house transforms into a (fairly quiet) nighttime pool gathering, the Era I Elders are prepared for their mug of Sleepytime Tea and melatonin candies. However, they deserve credit: Not one of them complains about the ruckus – they understand the deal and tolerate the youngsters cavorting around in their underwear.

As Olivia and Theo engage in their disagreement about kissing, the rivals Cory and Tony quietly deliberate over the key conflict of the episode: Should one prioritize shielding the strongest team members to potentially reach the final, or eliminate them when convenient to avoid future encounters?

As a seasoned parliamentarian with years of experience under my belt, I can attest to the fact that certain issues cast a long and ominous shadow over the debates that unfold within the hallowed halls of our legislative chambers. This year’s deliberations, dubbed by some as “arbitrary term,” seem to resonate with an air of mystery and intrigue, much like the enigmatic allure of a BDSM-themed mansion. It’s ironic, really – a term that evokes such erotic undertones, yet one that we use to describe the cold, calculated maneuverings of corporate entities. I’ve seen it before, time and again – the subtle dance of power, the strategic moves, the artful manipulation of words and ideas in pursuit of self-interest. It’s a game that is as old as civilization itself, and one that I’ve grown all too familiar with over the years. So, let us tread carefully, my colleagues, for the stakes are high, and the lines between seduction and subjugation can often blur when corporate synergy takes hold.

Unlike traditional scenarios where the power dynamic often favors those who have already won, the Chamber isn’t about one-on-one negotiations over an interrogation table. Instead, it resembles a heated group discussion among classmates trying to complete a high-stakes school project before deadline, but these classmates are hyped up on energy drinks and fiercely competitive, each striving to have the final say.

In the Era I camp, CT faces a dilemma between safeguarding his brother Darrell and maintaining Brad as a potential team asset. However, before he must make a difficult choice, Derrick intervenes, volunteering to compete against Mark in order to repay Darrell for unspecified help from their private lives (Darrell says he would not have done this for Derrick). As for the women, Rachel steps back from decision-making, arguing that it’s only fair if CT decides for her since he will prioritize safety over any female-oriented strategies we might favor.

In the Era II Chamber, Ryan expresses his desire to compete against Brandon rather than Derek or Nehemiah. However, this lineup of male cast members is significantly less iconic compared to previous ones – I really miss Wes! As for the female contestants, it appears illogical to eliminate Cara, who’s always in shape, when there’s still a lot more game to play. Laurel and Bananas are as suspicious as a suburban mom from Westchester whose husband returns home smelling of Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium. To avoid elimination, Cara delivers an impressive speech that would make Shakespeare envious, stating she’s lowering her defensive walls for the first time in her Challenge career and humbly asking the powerful duo to forget their past and work together with her, side by side in this new era.

Theater auditions progress with Round III, featuring Jordan delivering a forceful speech reminiscent of “A Lannister always repays his debts,” emphasizing his character’s integrity and leadership skills, potentially swaying the vote in favor of Tony. However, it seems that this persuasive speech might be redundant given Cory’s existing dislike for Tony, and Tori’s refusal to support Jordan, her EX-FIANCÉ. On the female side of Round III, Averey is unknown to everyone, making her an easy target, while Amanda’s constant antagonism towards Tori makes her as popular as double-chocolate muffins from the Olympic Village.

In the fourth era, tensions rise as Nurys reveals her desire to confront Olivia, who was once her closest friend but has now become an adversary. Michele attempts to reason that Olivia holds a position for her similar to what Nurys does for Horacio, to which I respond with skepticism. The relationship between Horacio and Nurys is reminiscent of Bananas’ description of a “junior-high love sickness,” with plans to cohabit. In comparison, Olivia is merely an acquaintance from one season. Michele sheds tears like a crocodile in the opening episode itself.

The situation involving Era IV men, specifically Paulie and Theo, has become less complicated. Since their scandalous kiss on “War of the Worlds II”, they’ve been eager to escalate their enemies-turned-lovers relationship into something more. Here’s to it being a passionate wrestling match.

Read More

2024-08-15 05:54