The Beast in Me Recap: Spilled Milk

by

With only two episodes left, the show has reached a critical turning point. Any remaining hope that Nile might be innocent, or capable of genuine affection, is now gone. However, new secrets continue to surface – we’re getting closer to understanding what the Jarvis family, particularly Rick, knows about Agent Breton – and I still believe someone else is responsible for Madison’s disappearance. Nile may be involved, but I suspect a different, unexpected character is the real culprit, and their role will only make sense once the full story is revealed. Is Rick hiding something? What about Martin? Or could Nina be involved in a surprising way?

It’s not unexpected, given how common this behavior seems to be. Nile is clearly struggling to maintain a calm exterior. When he visits Teddy Fenig at the art show, his frustration is obvious. While it’s unknown what Nile originally intended to do with Teddy, Abbott’s involvement has disrupted his plans. Since Nile arrived in Oyster Bay, two people connected to him through Aggie have either died or gone missing. This raises suspicions about Nile, but also casts a shadow on Aggie as well.

Aggie is smart and realizes something bad is about to happen. Unable to reach Abbott, she goes to his apartment. When he doesn’t respond, she tells the building superintendent she’s his cousin to gain access. The superintendent is wary, so Aggie cleverly distracts him. She asks him to hold a fake suitcase, and while he’s not looking, quickly steals Abbott’s spare key from a nearby board. The apartment is empty, but the bathroom sink is covered in blood and hair. Aggie searches through Abbott’s belongings, hoping to find a hint of his whereabouts. She finds a thumb drive taped to the drawer containing his files on Madison Jarvis – and it’s definitely important.

Just as Aggie was about to connect the device to Abbott’s computer, someone knocked and unlocked the door. Aggie quickly hid in a closet while Erika entered, searching for Abbott. Aggie attempted to slip away unnoticed, but Erika spotted her. Aggie explained she was concerned about Abbott, just like Erika. Hoping to share important information, Aggie told Erika she believed she had evidence that Nile murdered his wife. She showed Erika a suicide note, Nile’s birdwatching diary, and pointed out bloodstains in the bathroom, finally handing over the thumb drive. The drive revealed a live tracking feed of Teddy Fenig’s location. Aggie filled Erika in on everything she and Abbott had been doing, including accessing Nile’s computer. Erika promised to obtain a search warrant for Nile’s property and call in forensics to examine Abbott’s apartment. She firmly instructed Aggie to stay away from Nile under any circumstances.

Meanwhile, Olivia Benitez and her aide, Elijah, are preparing for a press conference to respond to the unrest that occurred at her recent rally, which is dominating the news and online. Elijah suggests waiting to see if the situation calms down on its own, but Benitez wants to address it immediately before it escalates. Speaking to reporters, she strongly condemns the violence, but also blames real estate developers Martin and Nile Jarvis for intentionally creating the crisis. Martin watches the conference with Rick, and he’s satisfied to see reporters challenging Benitez with difficult questions. Nile arrives after having confronted Teddy, but Martin cuts him off, deciding to handle Benitez directly since Nile’s previous attempt failed. After Martin leaves, Nile asks Rick for a private conversation, testing Rick’s loyalty. He asks Rick to prove he’s willing to do anything to protect Martin.

Okay, so I’m starting to think Rick, with his history of… well, let’s just say unauthorized entry, is connected to something that happens at Aggie’s place later on. But right now, the story cuts to Nile heading to the storage unit where he keeps Teddy, and he gets a call from Nina. She just left the doctor, and this is huge: she’s pregnant. She thought she couldn’t have kids because of endometriosis, so this is a total shock. She’s scared because she knows Nile has always been firm about not wanting children. She’d actually accepted she’d never be a mom, but now she’s thinking maybe she does want to go through with it. Nile, though? He’s… not thrilled. He just says, “It’s fine, Nina, it’s great,” in this really flat tone. She’s crying, and he’s just trying to get off the phone so he can get back to whatever awful stuff he’s planning. Seriously, this woman needs to get out of that marriage, and fast.

Meanwhile, Martin reaches out to Benitez, requesting a face-to-face meeting. Benitez is frustrated and suspects Martin orchestrated the riot, and he does nothing to convince her otherwise. He actually wants her to think he’s responsible, as it gives him leverage. He’s trying to control her by demonstrating his power and ability to damage her reputation. Martin presents Benitez with the same property deal Nile previously offered, which she’d already turned down. However, after Martin subtly threatens her, hinting at repercussions given recent events, she gives in. Her attempt to frame the deal as a step toward positive change feels insincere, especially since she visibly shrinks under Martin’s pressure. Honestly, this storyline is getting tiresome. It touches on important issues like housing, the environment, and corruption, but doesn’t explore them in enough depth. Benitez feels like a stereotypical “young Democrat,” leaving the actress with little to work with. The message is clear: Martin Jarvis is intimidating, and his appearance alone is enough to convey that.

I’m more focused on what Jarvis was manipulating. After leaving Abbott’s apartment, Erika calls Frank while on the stairs, asking him to pick up the kids and take them to her parents’ house. She admits she made some serious mistakes when Frank was in trouble years ago, believing she was protecting their family, but now she has to report it to the Bureau, and there will be repercussions. Frank is confused, but she ends the call without explaining. I suspect she accepted a favor from the Jarvises in exchange for being covered up within the Bureau, and that arrangement is about to fall apart given everything that’s happening. However, that will have to wait, as a kidnapping in Oyster Bay has just been reported, and the entire office is now focused on that case.

Aggie is returning to Oyster Bay, unaware of the trouble ahead. While driving to Cooper’s grave, she receives a call from Carol, which goes to voicemail. Carol calls again, and Aggie answers this time. The editor is incredibly enthusiastic about the first four chapters of the book, comparing it to both In Cold Blood and The Year of Magical Thinking. The publisher, Bob, shares the excitement and is already planning a major summer launch. However, Carol senses something is wrong with Aggie, who doesn’t seem engaged. The situation escalates when Aggie arrives home to find Nile waiting for her. She abruptly tells Carol she’ll call back in five minutes, and if she doesn’t respond, Carol should call the police.

Aggie is a poor liar when it comes to Nile, and he quickly brings up the jogging path they previously discussed, showing her where his team has marked it. Aggie delays getting out of the car while talking to him. The scene is tense because Nile is aware of what Aggie knows, but she doesn’t realize he’s figured it out. Nile seems to enjoy upsetting Aggie, almost like a bully teasing a small animal. He playfully mentions the awkwardness between them since she saw him dance. Aggie attempts to dismiss him by claiming she’s expecting a call from Carol, but Nile persists. She reluctantly follows him to the path, where he repeats their previous intense conversation, but this time he’s even more intimidating. He presses her about reading the first hundred pages of her book and if she knows how the story ends, repeatedly asking, “Did I do it?” Conveniently, Carol calls at that moment. Aggie tells her she’s with Nile and asks her to stay on the line until she reaches her desk, then she practically runs home.

She quickly locked up and promised Carol an explanation later, but couldn’t reach Erika by phone – neither her personal number nor the FBI office answered. Tension was building rapidly. On her drive home, Nina was overtaken by a line of black SUVs. Back at the office, Aggie discovered someone had messed with her manuscript, heavily marking it up with a red pen. The title had even been changed from “The Beast and Me” to “The Beast in Me.” Nile called to ask if Aggie’s editor had liked the pages she sent. Aggie directly accused him of breaking into her house, but he avoided the question, insisting they discuss their friendship instead. He brought up a past incident, hinting he knew she wanted Teddy to face consequences. He claimed he didn’t realize she was capable of taking action until he went upstairs. Confused, Aggie went up the stairs and, while still on the phone with Nile, discovered Teddy dead in Cooper’s room. He had been suffocated with a bag, and the room was decorated to look exactly like the live video feed.

Intrusive Thoughts

Nile apparently isn’t aware of everything Aggie revealed to Erika at the apartment, or that Aggie was attempting to contact the FBI. He also doesn’t know what specific evidence Aggie has linking him to Madison’s disappearance. If all of this comes to light, it could prove Aggie isn’t guilty of the framing. However, we still aren’t sure how strong the deal Erika has with the Jarvises is, so none of it may ultimately make a difference.

• Noted: Martin speaking in Russian with Olga, who works in his house.

While The Beast in Me remains captivating, the show is losing some of its subtlety as the story progresses. The character of Nile was more compelling when his motivations were unclear; now, he’s becoming an over-the-top villain. I also expected the book Aggie was working on to play a bigger role, but it mostly just moves the plot forward instead of adding depth to both the story and her character. The 2010 film The Ghost Writer strikes a better balance between the writing process and the central mystery. It’s a cozy fall watch with plenty of sweaters, and Kim Cattrall’s English accent is surprisingly good, but that’s beside the point!

Read More

2025-11-14 03:56