Minority Mindset

Smart investments

Entertainment

The 20 Best Movies About American Presidents

Oct 13, 2024

The 20 Best Movies About American Presidents

As a film enthusiast with a soft spot for political dramas and a keen interest in American history, I must say that each of these films offers a unique perspective on the complex characters who occupied the highest office in the land.

One consistent feature across films based on real-life presidents is a profound respect for the presidency itself, a trait that might not be as prevalent in future movies. In these movies, even events from before, during, or after their time in the White House are viewed through this prism: This individual formerly held the most influential position globally. Everything they do appears more significant, more impactful: We seek to understand their character not just in monumental, but also in everyday moments. Their life story is essentially their origin tale.

Reflecting on our current predicament, I can’t help but feel that everything we know will shift dramatically. The notion of reverence for one’s job might seem like a distant memory post-this situation. Yet, one consistent theme in these movies about real-life presidents is the weight and significance of the office versus the inherent humanity of the person occupying it. Not all presidents portrayed in these films are paragons of virtue. However, they are all figures of magnitude, wielding influence and power. I suspect that image will alter drastically within the next two decades. As a movie buff, I find this fascinating to ponder about.

In my opinion as a movie reviewer, let me share an observation about the list I’ve compiled – it excludes documentaries, such as “Jimmy Carter: Man From Plains.” Instead, it delves into fictional portrayals of real-life presidents, both commendable and, more frequently, questionable.

20.
Hyde Park on Hudson (2012)

As a fan, I must confess that Bill Murray’s performance as Franklin Delano Roosevelt seemed to be aiming for an Oscar, but it appears he chose the wrong platform for it. This film, marketed as a “whimsical” historical drama, turns out to be a rather forgettable one. The movie presents FDR as a decent man with flaws, who occasionally steps away from his duties to receive, shall we say, ‘unorthodox’ companionship from Laura Linney. A scene that will linger in your mind for quite some time, I assure you.

19.
The Better Angels (2014)

Under the direction of Terrence Malick, The Better Angels features newcomer Braydon Denney as a young Abraham Lincoln residing in Indiana with his mother (Brit Marling) and father (Jason Clarke). A.J. Edwards, who previously worked as an editor on To the Wonder and Knight of Cups, serves as writer-director and imparts a dreamlike quality reminiscent of Malick’s style. The cinematography, in black-and-white, is visually stunning, but it portrays the characters as idealized, almost mythical figures (Lincoln’s father as stoic, his mother as ethereal). While filmmakers may craft impressionistic depictions of notable figures, The Better Angels‘s execution is so leisurely that it fails to convey anything substantial about Lincoln’s historical significance or influence.

18.
LBJ (2017)

Imagine if your lifelong dream was to become president, but the only way that could happen is by stepping into the shoes of a beloved POTUS who had been suddenly and tragically assassinated. That’s the intriguing premise behind Rob Reiner’s film, LBJ, which stars Woody Harrelson as Lyndon Baines Johnson, a tenacious yet awkward politician who couldn’t secure the White House on his own terms and settled for being vice-president to the charming but aloof John F. Kennedy (portrayed by Jeffrey Donovan).

17.
Elvis & Nixon (2016)

I must admit, the anticipation leading up to this film was primarily focused on Michael Shannon’s portrayal of Elvis Presley. However, as I watched Kevin Spacey step into the role of Richard Nixon, I can’t help but feel somewhat uncomfortable with both performances, truth be told. Spacey’s Nixon is more pitiful than malevolent, and the film’s attempt to depict the infamous meeting between Nixon and Presley as a farce is a delicate dance it struggles to master. The Elvis storyline in this movie is actually quite captivating, and it seems that Spacey is primarily imitating Nixon rather than embodying him. All in all, it’s not a spectacle worth investing your time or energy into. (Streamable on Prime Video.)

16.
Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter (2012)

This action movie, although unhealthy and absurd at times, manages to be delightfully eccentric when you’re in the right frame of mind, aiming to capitalize on the “historic figures or books with a horror twist” trend that included “Pride and Prejudice and Zombies”. Directed by Timur Bekmambetov, this film adapts Seth Grahame-Smith’s novel, where Abraham Lincoln is transformed into a vampire slayer. However, the movie overdoes the somber splendor and bloody action scenes. Yet, there’s an appeal in the ridiculousness of the plot, greatly enhanced by Benjamin Walker’s portrayal of Honest Abe with such sincerity that it draws you into the film’s absurd yet serious-comedic atmosphere. Unsurprisingly, “Vampire Hunter” was a commercial flop, but its campy enthusiasm makes it an ideal choice for a lazy Sunday afternoon on cable television. (Streamable on Hulu.) )

15.
Jefferson in Paris (1995)

The film that ended Merchant-Ivory’s run of critical and commercial art-house hits, Jefferson in Paris is a muddled drama that’s not without some intriguing ideas rustling around inside it. Looking at Thomas Jefferson’s tenure as American ambassador to France a couple of decades before his presidency, the movie draws from two romances he pursued at the time: with the painter Maria Cosway (Greta Scacchi) and his slave Sally Hemings (Thandie Newton). As played by Nick Nolte, the Jefferson we meet is a man who’s lost, grieving a dead wife while trying to keep his nascent nation together, a storytelling perspective that offers some insights into the secret self-doubts of our Founding Fathers. But Jefferson in Paris never quite succeeds as either a character study or a love story. (Available to rent or purchase on Apple TV, Prime Video, and Google Play.)

14.
Barry (2016)

An origin story of sorts that shows the formative years of Barack Obama, Barry follows our 44th president as a college student (played by Devon Terrell) in New York trying to find his footing in the big city. There’s a love story at Barry’s center — Anya Taylor-Joy plays one of his classmates — but director Vikram Gandhi is more interested in Obama’s search to find himself as he tries to come to terms with not feeling wholly comfortable with either white students or black friends. There’s a genuine attempt to strip away Obama’s mythic persona — the real man was getting ready to wind down his time in the Oval Office at the time of the movie’s release — but Barry suffers a bit because it doesn’t have quite enough distance or perspective to really offer a compelling take on the transformative politician. It will be interesting to rewatch Barry down the road: In several ways, the movie is less about Obama than it is our relationship to a president who seemed to be too good to be true — and seems even more that way now. (Available to stream on Netflix.)

13.
The Butler (2013)

This is the slightly cuckoo, slightly reverent Lee Daniels movie about a White House butler (Forest Whitaker) who serves multiple generations of presidents and attempts to raise a family (with wife Oprah Winfrey and son David Oyelowo; this movie does not lack a pedigree, that’s for sure) through a particularly combustible period in our nation’s history. The movie moves along well enough but, oddly, screeches to a halt every time we meet a president played by a famous actor who doesn’t so much inhabit the real-life figure as wave bemusedly behind his mask. Robin Williams’s Eisenhower and John Cusack’s Richard Nixon are both just strange, but there’s a little more going on with Alan Rickman’s Ronald Reagan (with Jane Fonda as Nancy!). A whole movie with Rickman as Reagan might have been onto something. (Available to rent or purchase on Apple TV, Prime Video, and Google Play.)

12.
Dick (1999)

In a comical take, the Watergate scandal unfolds from the perspective of two witty and seemingly naive teenagers, played by Michelle Williams and Kirsten Dunst. This film excels as comedy rather than offering insightful real-life commentary. Dan Hedaya’s portrayal of Nixon is appropriately eccentric and paranoid, but he serves more as a transient character. Fortunately, Williams and Dunst are the true standouts. Additionally, the supporting cast, including Dave Foley, Harry Shearer, Jim Breuer, Will Ferrell, and Bruce McCulloch, adds brilliantly unexpected touches to their roles as Haldeman, G. Gordon Liddy, John Dean, Woodward, and Bernstein respectively – a pair of bumbling journalists who are clueless about the events unfolding but thoroughly enjoy their time on television. (This production is available for rental or purchase on Apple TV and Prime Video.)

11.
Southside With You (2016)

In the last year of his presidency, the film Southside With You depicts a fictional account of Barack Obama’s first date with Michelle Robinson, similar to the romantic drama Before Sunrise. The movie showcases impressive performances by Parker Sawyers as the reserved yet charming Barack and Tika Sumpter as the determined Michelle. While there’s an element of wishful thinking in the portrayal, it offers a delightful glimpse into what we hope their first date was like, two intellectually gifted individuals embarking on a journey filled with endless possibilities. The film stumbles slightly when attempting to add meaning to their date, but shines brightest when focusing on the charming dynamics between the characters as they get to know each other. History can take a backseat for now; you can stream this heartwarming tale on Max.

10.
PT 109 (1963)

Originally criticized as hagiographic when it came out five months before JFK’s assassination in Dallas, this portrayal of Kennedy’s wartime heroics can be seen today as simply following the trend of most movies made in the past 50 years, featuring a younger Kennedy. It’s worth noting that Cliff Robertson was nearly two decades older than Kennedy at the time he played him. The film, produced under the guidance of Kennedy’s father, who had been a movie executive, presents JFK as an ideal representation of humanity. This may have caused controversy when it was released in June 1963, but by December, it seems less of an issue. The movie is well-made and quite enjoyable. If it weren’t about a president, you wouldn’t even notice it, let alone be bothered by it – you’d enjoy it just the same. (Available for rental or purchase on Apple TV, Prime Video, and Google Play.)

9.
Thirteen Days (2000)

2017’s Academy-nominated movie “Darkest Hour” portrays one of Winston Churchill’s most challenging periods as he confronted Germany. The film “Thirteen Days” resembles this, focusing on John F. Kennedy during the tense weeks of the Cuban Missile Crisis against the Soviet Union. Bruce Greenwood portrays JFK as a distant, complex, and hesitant character, but the story is primarily told from the perspective of his confidant Kenneth O’Donnell (Kevin Costner). Directed by Roger Donaldson with minimal flair, “Thirteen Days” highlights strategy, debate, deliberation, and agonizing decisions – it’s a film where the tension comes from ideas and dialogue. As a result, the film possesses both the appeal and constraints of a well-staged play, yet the actors (including Steven Culp as Bobby Kennedy and Dylan Baker as Robert McNamara) deliver compelling performances in the script’s stripped-down, high-stakes drama. It can be rented or purchased on Apple TV, Prime Video, and Google Play.

8.
W. (2008)

It’s not surprising that one might expect Oliver Stone, known for his liberal views, to criticize George W. Bush harshly in his biopic. However, surprisingly, the film W. shows a sense of pity towards a man who, according to the movie, was simply unprepared for the role fate assigned him. Josh Brolin portrays Bush as a well-meaning underachiever who, after converting to Christianity, feels compelled to do something significant. The film takes strong jabs at several individuals in Bush’s inner circle, with Thandie Newton’s portrayal of Condoleezza Rice being particularly scathing. The movie raises questions about the consequences when an innocent man is influenced by warmongers with flawed information. Stone suggests that Bush may not have truly desired to be president – had he remained in Major League Baseball, he might have been happier. Despite this, the world paid a heavy price for Bush’s misjudgment of his abilities and talents. The film is not condemning or satirical but instead carries an unusual tone of wistfulness and regret – an uncommon sentiment in Stone’s work. The movie can be streamed on Peacock, Pluto TV, and Tubi.

7.
Amistad (1997)

In this film, directed by Steven Spielberg and featuring Anthony Hopkins as John Quincy Adams, we witness another tale where white legal professionals come to the rescue of their African-American clients. The unique twist here is that Adams, a former U.S. president, takes on the case to argue for the citizenship of a ship full of slaves en route from Africa.

6.
Primary Colors (1998)

The release of the film “Primary Colors” couldn’t have been more timely. Coincidentally, the Lewinsky scandal erupted just two months prior, lending a striking relevance to the movie’s narrative about an intelligent, well-meaning presidential candidate who was undone by his own indiscretions. Though it didn’t boost the film’s box office earnings, John Travolta’s portrayal of this character exudes charm while maintaining an elusive quality that reminds us distinctly of Bill Clinton. Emma Thompson’s depiction of Hillary is more sympathetic than history would later portray her, and the movie remains as contemporary yet somewhat outdated, a mix that isn’t detrimental. Kathy Bates’s award-winning performance serves as a reminder of our initial trust in the Clintons, and how they eventually disappointed us. (The film is available for rental or purchase on Apple TV, Prime Video, and Google Play.)

5.
Frost/Nixon (2008)

Ron Howard’s ticktock of how British journalist David Frost (Michael Sheen) got an out-of-office and exiled Richard Nixon (Frank Langella) not only on his television show but to confess to his crimes is smart, linear filmmaking, what you’d expect from Howard, but not much more. It’s still particularly striking to watch it today, considering its big revelation — Nixon confessing — has basically happened already with our current president with Lester Holt, and it didn’t make a lick of difference. The movie, despite its mod fashion and sideburns, doesn’t make you nostalgic for the ’70s; it makes you nostalgic for 2008. (Available to stream on Max.)

4.
Young Mr. Lincoln (1939)

In this unique take on the classic superhero origin, we find Abraham Lincoln as our hero. His extraordinary ability? Discovering his true identity – none other than himself! Directed by John Ford, this courtroom drama, titled “Young Mr. Lincoln,” features a 34-year-old Henry Fonda portraying the future president. Unlike the grandeur of Oliver Stone’s work, this film serves more as a warm-up for Perry Mason rather than an ambitious production. However, it excels as a courtroom thriller, with Fonda’s portrayal of Lincoln setting a standard for honesty and integrity in legal dramas that would be emulated by countless films to come. You can stream this timeless classic on The Roku Channel and Tubi.

3.
Secret Honor (1984)

Richard Nixon, known for being a fan of the television series M*A*S*H, may not have been fondly regarded by director Robert Altman. However, with the film Secret Honor (adapted from a play by Donald Freed and Arnold M. Stone), it appears that Altman found some understanding of Nixon’s essence. In this movie, Philip Baker Hall portrays Nixon in a solitary 90-minute screen performance, wandering his study as he recounts his mistakes and heartaches. It is intriguing to consider Nixon as a representation of Altman, who, at that point in his career, was considered a commercial outcast and seemed to have lost his way. Consequently, it’s not surprising that Secret Honor is a relentlessly bitter and vengeful piece, with Nixon seeking less sympathy than an opportunity to lash out at his critics, trying to set the record straight. As a film, this is a talky, theatrical production, but its raw anger makes it electrifying, particularly during its fiery climax. (Can be rented or purchased on Apple TV and Prime Video.)

2.
Nixon (1995)

Movies often feature powerful American men, who climb to impressive heights but are ultimately brought down by the same insecurities and flaws that fueled their initial success. ‘Nixon’ stands out from films like ‘Citizen Kane’ and ‘There Will Be Blood’, as it is made even more intriguing by its director, Oliver Stone. While one might not expect Stone to be a Nixon advocate, he portrays our 37th president as a complex character, driven by a deep sense of inadequacy. Anthony Hopkins doesn’t physically resemble Nixon, but his performance encapsulates him perfectly. The film’s final third, dominated by the Watergate investigation, is both captivating and unsettling, as it portrays a man who, at his core, was always pessimistic. ‘Nixon’ doesn’t leave you with positive feelings towards Nixon, but it immerses you in the tragedy of his life, showing how his ego, anger, and ambition could never overcome his self-doubt, despite his hopes to the contrary. (Rent or buy on Apple TV and Prime Video.)

1.
Lincoln (2012)

As a film enthusiast, I’d like to share my thoughts on Steven Spielberg’s masterpiece, “Lincoln.” It’s not just about Lincoln the man, the leader, or the icon; it encompasses all these aspects brilliantly. What sets this movie apart is its unwavering faith in politics, portraying Lincoln as a relentless operator who navigates the complexities of government to bring about fundamental change. He employs every tactic from cajoling and deal-making to heartfelt appeals, always striving to tap into people’s goodness. Daniel Day-Lewis delivers an outstanding performance as Lincoln, making him not a larger-than-life figure but a man laboring tirelessly to do what is right with the tools at his disposal. The film exudes a profound respect for the presidency and its potential to transform society. Six years on, I can’t help but wonder if Spielberg still holds that belief. (This movie is available for rent or purchase on Apple TV and Prime Video.)

Grierson & Leitch frequently discuss films and even have a film-focused podcast. To stay updated with their insights, consider following them on Twitter or visiting their website.

Read More

2024-10-13 16:54