Survivor Recap: The Wrong Moves

by

Among all the novelties of this new period – the small communities, the travel, the fire-making competition – there’s one innovation that I believe could significantly improve things and bring immense joy to ex-copy editors like myself: It would be beneficial to have a simple reference chart in the voting booth during Tribal Council meetings so that competitors can correctly spell each other’s names. Earlier this season, when Cedrek was voted out and no one managed to spell his name correctly, I mentioned it. However, this time there were four votes for Shauhin, but only two of them were accurate. Eva almost got it right with “Shawhin,” but Joe – who we all know has never used Hooked on Phonics, as last week he attempted to pass off “Got Fun Betrale” as the winning phrase in the word-block puzzle – completely missed the mark with “Sha-Hen.

Although I’m slightly annoyed that he had to endure those spelling mistakes and the humiliation that came with them, it was indeed the correct decision. In the end, someone finally took action against Shauhin, who, much like many Greek literary characters, was afflicted by excessive pride – a fatal flaw. “You eliminated the best player,” he says after his flame was extinguished. However, I must clarify that the ‘best player’ is the one who wins the game. Throughout the episodes, Shauhin seemed to harbor delusions of grandeur. He would often boast, “Everyone says that Joe is playing the best game. I know he’s not playing the best game. I’m playing the best game.” In a different context, I might say, “You and what jury?” But since there are no armies in Survivor, I will instead say, “You and what jury?” Shauhin has contributed little more than sitting in the collective shadows of Joe and Eva, who have dominated the challenges, discovered all advantages, and dictated the pecking order without his input. Regrettably, Shauhin is a goat. He’s a goat who provides captivating soundbites, so we’ve seen quite a bit of him, but he remains a goat nonetheless.

This latest episode added to the frustration of an already frustrating season, as it was clearly past the point where any meaningful action could be taken. Mitch argues that now is the right time for a move, but the truth is that the opportunity had passed three episodes back. Everyone seemed to have waited too long. Last week, I speculated that Eva might use her Safety Without Power at Tribal Council, and I was wrong (my apologies!). However, even if she had used it, Shauhin wouldn’t have been serious about flipping sides. Either Eva or Joe will make it to the finals, and one of them is bound to win – it’s just a matter of time.

The storytelling suggests Joe as a strong contender, but we already knew their decisions were set beforehand, so these visual hints may serve primarily to enhance suspense rather than revealing anything new.

It’s noticeable that the current season of Survivor often follows a predictable pattern, as Kamilla deduces from the Tree Mail that today’s challenge involves contestants hanging onto a ramp over the ocean and trying to be the last one to slide in. As usual, it appears Joe will excel at this task. Yet surprisingly, Shauhin and his ganglion cyst manage to succeed because he yearns not only for the Sanctuary, offering an abundance of food and comfortable lodging, but also for the letter his mother sent him.

I was almost ready to pardon the charming mama’s boy Shauhin for his poor gameplay, but then he chose Joe to join him on the reward. Really? He wants to provide additional food and rest to the man who has already won all the challenges before the immunity challenge? Goodness gracious! Kamilla remarks that if Shauhin gets eliminated, it’s because he favored Joe, and she is spot-on. When they have a private moment in the Sanctuary (you know the routine), Shauhin inquires from Joe if there could be a scenario where they vote out Kyle. Joe replies “no.” He believes the strategy is to eliminate Mitch first, followed by Kamilla, and then bring their alliance to the final four.

I’ve noticed a recurring issue with Joe’s strategy in the game, as well as the overall flow of this season. It seems that Joe, much like everyone else still in the competition, is solely focused on reaching the final. The exception to this is my ally Kamilla, who remains the only contestant worth supporting due to her focus on winning.

Now, it appears these four will make it to the end together. However, the question arises: Who among them will secure final immunity? I believe it’s Joe who will win this challenge. And if he does, he’ll take Eva with him. This leaves Shauhin and Kyle in a tough spot, battling it out at fire. Unfortunately, Mother Nature can be unpredictable, and the wind might not cooperate, causing one of them to lose the game.

Given their current standing at third place, how might they secure votes or set themselves apart from the competition? How can they demonstrate their actions as superior, unique, or exceptional compared to others who haven’t achieved this yet? Are they relying solely on their debating abilities, even though Joe is not guaranteed to win?

Joe has established strong relationships with almost everyone in the game and has won numerous challenges, placing him among an exclusive group of six contestants who have each won five challenges within a single season. However, only two of these individuals emerged as winners, while three others finished as runners-up. This underscores the fact that challenge victories do not guarantee success in Survivor. Joe’s strategy seems to revolve primarily around maintaining a tight alliance and winning challenges; but will this approach be sufficient in an era where jury members often seek excitement?

In a pivotal move, Shauhin invites Kyle to team up with them at the Sanctum. This choice turns out to be momentous, as it sparks an idea in Kyle that ultimately leads to Shauhin’s elimination. Before the immunity challenge, Shauhin suggests they target Eva to undermine Joe’s strategy. However, this seems questionable, as if he aims to weaken Joe, why would he help him by providing food? And if his goal is to weaken Joe, wouldn’t voting him out if he loses be a more logical approach? Unfortunately for Shauhin, making the right decision in this game appears to be beyond his reach.

Kyle’s statement underlines another issue they’ve encountered this season. He expresses his desire for action but doesn’t want to replicate Shauhin’s strategy, a sentiment we’ve heard frequently, almost as often as Jeff yells “balls” during competitions. They’ve been hesitant to repeat Chrissy’s move, Star’s move, Mary’s move, and even Shauhin’s move. In many instances, this reluctance led to no action being taken. At least Kyle has proposed a strategy.

If the strategy didn’t succeed, I would have called it foolish, but at least it was a scheme. After Joe secured immunity (which seemed almost certain that I won’t elaborate on the challenge except for this), Kyle informed Joe that Shauhin had flipped and was targeting Eva. He claimed Shauhin instructed him to verify with Kamilla, and Kamilla then told Kyle that Shauhin had shown her an idol. However, none of this was true, as Shauhin didn’t possess an idol. Eventually, Kyle suggested they vote out Shauhin. As soon as he finished speaking, Joe clarified, “Just to summarize, since I’m perplexed…” Yes, it was complex and puzzling. But in the end, it managed to work.

In a different phrasing: Joe behaves erratically towards Shauhin during their encounter, speaking condescendingly as if he holds secret information that Shauhin is hiding. Consequently, Shauhin feels belittled and becomes upset with Joe. Upon expressing his annoyance to Kyle, Shauhin reveals a change of heart regarding the evening’s vote. He explains that if they eliminate Eva, there is a fan of Joe on the jury, which is accurate. However, he argues that an additional Joe supporter won’t make a difference since there will be nine in total. Furthermore, he claims that Eva has no chance of reaching the final three. This seems questionable, considering Eva’s unique abilities such as her talent for not detecting lies and her strategic hoarding of advantages throughout the game. The idea that she has no chance is hard to believe, even for a moment! Shauhin’s supposedly brilliant strategy, this supposed mastermind of the game, opts instead to follow the majority and vote out Mitch. What a surprising move! Let’s reward this man and his cyst with $1 million.

Fortunately for us, Kamilla and Kyle’s strategy begins to unfold. Joe confers with Eva about it, confirming the details from Kamilla, and then returns to share this information with Eva. They both conclude that they have more faith in Kyle than Shauhin, which results in Shauhin no longer being considered the greatest strategist Survivor has ever produced – at least not since Coach.

I’m still unsure about a couple of things. Firstly, when Joe and Eva discover that Shauhin didn’t vote for Eva despite the votes, what will happen to Kyle and Kamilla? Will they accuse him of changing his vote? Or will they realize that K-Squared was deceiving them?

Secondly, I can’t understand why Kamilla voted for Mitch. They had enough votes against Shauhin without her vote, so were they trying to give others the impression that they weren’t collaborating? But if that’s true, then wouldn’t Joe and Eva want to eliminate Kamilla next since she was working with Shauhin? I simply can’t fathom how these individuals think! After all, most of them struggle with spelling.

Read More

2025-05-15 05:54