Survivor Recap: Hands Tied

by

There’s nothing I dislike more than being mistaken, so I can’t help but acknowledge that this week’s Shot in the Dark twist was surprisingly good. For quite some time now, I’ve been critical of its application and its contribution to the game, but this Tribal Council really flipped things upside down. When Jeff Probst revealed “SAFE,” I let out a small yelp in my living room.

In light of this recent episode, it has become clearer than ever that my previous misjudgment regarding SITD was unfounded. This incident underscores for me that I’ve been correct about most other aspects in the new game era. This episode demonstrated how elements we (many fans) dislike post-Winners at War, such as the game’s instability and an individual’s excessive influence over a tribe’s fate, can lead to crisis situations within the game itself. A person on a four-member tribe should not have the power to decide who gets eliminated. Those who uphold the integrity and philosophy of the game – that it is the tribe, not one individual, that decides winners and losers – should not support these changes.

Initially, let’s address an issue that arises from the outset: the grouping of characters into three small teams, often resulting in one team suffering heavy losses. At first glance, it appears as though equal attention is given to each team; however, this equality quickly becomes irrelevant. In the latest episode, there was a strong indication that David, who resides in his father’s front yard in a trailer and frequently discusses his desire to win $1 million for his girlfriend to become a stay-at-home mother of four, would play a pivotal role. Regrettably, this anticipation is dashed, as it seems the entire plotline becomes inconsequential.

It’s worth noting that David needs to reconsider his relationship. His girlfriend has expressed that she will end their relationship if he doesn’t win $1 million to support her desire to stay at home with four children. She seems more enamored with an idyllic, imagined lifestyle than with David himself. Even his friends share this sentiment, believing that if David wins the money, it would be best for him to part ways with her.

The show starts by dividing characters into three small groups, often leading to one group suffering heavy losses. At first, it seems like David will play a crucial role in the episode since he lives in his father’s front yard and talks about needing the money to support his girlfriend who wants to stay at home with four kids. However, this expectation is never realized, making his storyline irrelevant. It’s also important to mention that David should consider ending his relationship because his girlfriend values an idealized lifestyle over him, even his friends think so.

In a similar fashion, whatever information we gather from Lagi (similar to the nerve), such as Eva’s actions hinting at expelling Thomas and Bianca while they grow closer to Star for the same purpose, appears to be false. A delightful interaction with my counterpart, Thomas, occurred when Bianca withdrew her vote for him, seemingly hoarding his advantage. However, this brief happiness pales in comparison to the sense of time wasted.

These two tribes are essentially insignificant in the current scenario. This is because the Vulu tribe has lost three consecutive challenges, one being a classic “Survivor” task where a caller guides blindfolded tribe members through an obstacle course. As they will be facing tribal council once more, it’s only the internal dynamics of their tribe that hold significance.

When the contest concluded, it was clear that there was more episode left to unfold, leading me to suspect that something unusual was happening due to the unexpected timing. The competition, of course, had a destination, but even after reaching it, the sequence of events seemed out of sync. In the end, Lagi claimed victory and selected Bianca from their own group, Kamilla from Civa (orange you grateful I didn’t use Civa), and Justin from Vulu for the journey. This brings me to my second concern: the new era and what could be my most significant gripe. The journey is a game of chance involving seven dice adorned with skulls and flames. If a player rolls four skulls first, they lose their vote; if they roll four flames, they earn an extra vote. Nothing on Survivor should ever be left to chance, full stop. Players don’t even have the option to decide whether or not they want to participate. I could tolerate a puzzle because it requires skill. I would also appreciate another challenge that tests players’ morals or intellect, such as deciding between taking a large bag of rice for the tribe or an extra vote for themselves. However, this is mere luck, and as you know, luck can be quite foolish. Foolish, foolish, foolish, foolish, foolish.

Justin, headed for the Tribal Council, loses his vote, as does Bianca, making Kamilla the sole winner with an extra vote. I’d care more if we ever visited Civa, but we never do because we’re always stuck at Vulu, dealing with Sai’s frustrating gameplay that benefits Rome 2.0. Justin chooses to hide his loss and tells the tribe he was tossing dice with various question mark-shaped tokens, but since he’s from Boston, he actually meant to say ‘marbles’.

Yesterday, before I was about to be eliminated, I was darting across the campgrounds, desperately trying to evade Sai long enough to locate an idol. But following our defeat, I returned and chose to take a dip in the water to give the impression that I might have found an idol or some edge. This move turned out to be quite cunning as Sai only knows one way to play this game, which is as challenging as navigating a Jennifer Convertibles with JD Vance at the wheel. “I can’t fathom you surrendering so easily; there’s something fishy here,” Sai accused me, to which I merely shrugged and told her that my time had come, and I had made peace with it.

As a cinephile, it feels like I’ve got a strategic move up my sleeve, one that hinges on Cedrek and myself voting for Justin, while hoping Mary does the same for me. The idea is, if Mary happens to possess a hidden advantage and casts her vote in my favor, I’m secure. However, there’s a snag: Justin doesn’t have a vote. He’s smartly kept this under wraps, as revealing it could lead to his elimination if Mary ever pieced together that both of us would be voting for him.

When we reach the voting phase, there’s still quite a bit more drama to unfold. Since no Idol has been played, we’re left wondering what will happen with this vote. As I mentioned earlier, Mary uses her Save-I-Must-Decide-To-Eliminate card and is safe. This card carries some uncertainty, but I don’t mind it too much because it’s a risk players willingly accept. Mary didn’t have to rely on chance, but she chose to give up her vote and take the chance. Making decisions and facing their outcomes is exciting; recklessly rolling dice gets dull quickly.

Jeff examined the two ballots, both favoring Mary. To be honest, I was taken aback that Sai hadn’t rebelled and voted for Justin since she doesn’t appear to be the kind of person who follows others’ advice easily. Plus, the fact that there were only two votes should have served as a warning sign for Sai and Cedrek, hinting at something suspicious. They decide to re-vote, and when Sai reaches the podium, she remarks, “This is what happens when you trust men.” Frankly, I believe both Thomas and I could advise her, based on our own sour experiences, that one should never put faith in a man, especially an attractive one.

In a simple and conversational manner: Jeff examines the votes, finding one for Justin and another for Sai. If there’s a tie, no voter can cast another vote; however, since Justin has none, it falls to Sai to cast her ballot—but she can only vote for Justin. This leaves Cedrek with a choice: he can either send Justin home alongside Sai or trigger another tie. After the second round of voting, Sai approaches the parchment and says, “Cedrek is truly awful.” Unsurprisingly, Cedrek votes for Sai again, likely due to her newfound disdain for him. The situation then takes a turn, signaled by Jeff stepping down from his podium and settling back in his chair. Listen closely, kids, because Grandpa Probst is about to share an intriguing tale—or at least that’s how he’s presenting it. He claims this moment is “historic” instead, but let’s be honest, the COVID-19 pandemic was quite the historical event as well.

In our tribal community, Grandpa Jeff explains, a deadlock often leads us to a discussion where we can’t decide who to eliminate. If no consensus is reached, we resort to drawing rocks. Interestingly, those whose votes are against them won’t be participating in the rock drawing. Given that Mary is safe, it implies that Cedrek unknowingly cast his vote against Sai for a second time. As a result, it seems as though Cedrek holds the power to decide who stays or leaves the tribe, potentially jeopardizing his own game without realizing it.

I dislike the novelty of this era due to its uncertainty, which Jeff tries to present as thrilling because we’re unsure of what’s next. However, the mystery isn’t fun; it’s not because someone played an idol cleverly, manipulated numbers, or found a loophole in the rules. Instead, we’re left guessing due to our lack of understanding of the complex Survivor gameplay rules regarding what transpires when one contestant loses their vote, another gives up a vote, and a third is declared safe by SITD, and moreover, a surgeon who can’t recognize good strategy even if it operated on them.

Cedrek claims he encountered Justin first, making it seem like he might keep him, although the order they met seems random, like flipping biased dice. Later, Sai presents the most convincing argument, stating that she’s always been honest with Cedrek, while Justin deceived him about losing his vote. This point seems valid, and Cedrek then addresses Mary and Sai, expressing he’ll make a decision contingent on them resolving their disagreement and cooperating as a group.

There are several compelling reasons to question Cedrek’s actions. He has not only broken Sai’s trust but done so twice. Is it sensible for her to collaborate with him again? If wisdom prevails, Sai should resolve her differences with Mary by joining forces and ousting Cedrek. Since he relied on Justin, why not simply dismiss Sai permanently?
In the upcoming episode, they will be redistributing tribes, thus invalidating the agreement he made for a stronger tribe. Instead of retaining Justin, who would have remained loyal due to his rescue, Cedrek now faces Sai leaving for another tribe and informing them that Cedrek cannot be trusted. Essentially, he has sabotaged his own game following a series of unfortunate events, primarily due to a complex set of rules that were introduced to accommodate the numerous twists, risks, and potential voter losses – something that should never occur. We watch Survivor for the intricate interpersonal relationships, the unexpected betrayals, and the dramatic reversals. What we don’t want is a lecture on the fine print, which was the focus of tonight’s episode.

Read More

2025-03-13 05:54