Star Trek: Picard Quietly Killed the Biggest Fumble in Sci-Fi History

by

For almost 60 years, Gene Roddenberry’s Star Trek has always had demanding fans. The series has been criticized by many for either not staying true to its original spirit or for leaning too heavily on things designed to please existing fans. However, one particular Star Trek show managed to do both – disappoint purists and overdo the fan service.

It’s common for long-running series like Star Trek to reference its history, but the term “fan service” often has a negative connotation for writers. While many sci-fi revivals rely too much on appealing to existing fans, Star Trek, particularly Picard, managed to strike a good balance. It acknowledged the show’s 60-year legacy while still trying to tell compelling and thought-provoking stories – even if those stories weren’t always what fans expected.

Star Trek: Picard Balanced Fan Service and Storytelling In a Way Sci-Fi Usually Doesn’t

According to bonus content on the complete Blu-ray set, Patrick Stewart, the star and executive producer of Star Trek: Picard, was the driving force behind making the show unique. He specifically wanted to avoid simply revisiting familiar territory with his character, Jean-Luc Picard.

He initially didn’t want to include dream sequences or have characters wearing Starfleet uniforms. Ironically, the very first episode did feature a dream sequence where he wore a uniform. However, right from the start – with the first scene taking place on a rebuilt set of Ten Forward and featuring Brent Spiner as Data – the show made it clear it would heavily reference Picard’s history.

Fans weren’t happy with how the story first showed Starfleet – portrayed as being controlled by a Romulan spy – and they disliked the details revealed about Picard’s family, especially his mother. While fans sometimes complain about sci-fi shows bringing back familiar characters or settings, they can also be upset when stories change their established understanding of beloved heroes.

Sometimes, the changes made in these stories can hide moments that are simply there to please fans, like small details added to scenes. The first two seasons of Picard focused more on surprising viewers than on giving them exactly what they wanted.

According to series co-creator Alex Kurtzman, Season 3 is meant to be a satisfying conclusion, like dessert after the main course of the first two seasons.

Terry Matalas, the executive producer and showrunner, shared that the creative team for Season 3 didn’t really focus on fan expectations while developing the story. However, given the long history of Star Trek, most people involved in making these shows are fans themselves.

The Star Trek: Picard Cast and Crew Are Fans Trying to Serve the Story

Recently, people who worked on Star Trek – both actors and those working behind the scenes – have begun sharing stories about their time on the shows and the experiences of others.

Brock Lofton, known for his role as Jake Sisko on Deep Space Nine, is the subject of The 7th Rule, a show documenting his initial experience as a Star Trek fan. He shared with Ronald D. Moore that he’d begun watching before completing The Next Generation. Lofton also pointed out the show’s clever use of references to the entire Star Trek universe, including appearances by Walter Koenig from The Original Series and even a nod to a planned upgrade that never made it into Enterprise.

Lofton felt Matalas was focused on giving fans what they wanted, but the showrunner explained that wasn’t his main priority while developing the story. Matalas admitted it was a delicate balance, clarifying, “We didn’t start by asking what fans would enjoy. Instead, we focused on creating a story we, as fans ourselves, would love.”

For example, Ron Matalas began his career working on Star Trek and The Next Generation. He also noticed that the cast members quickly started sharing stories about their experiences from earlier times.

If the show was simply trying to capitalize on fans’ fond memories, it would have started with the entire crew back on the bridge of the USS Enterprise. But instead, each character has meaningful scenes, and every nod to the show’s history feels natural and relevant to the plot. Moments like Data recreating Moriarty fit perfectly into the story.

Matalas argued that criticism of nostalgia and fan service often comes from people who don’t appreciate its value. He compared it to visiting a family home filled with decades of memories – photos, heirlooms, and personal items that represent a family’s history.

Actually, weaving together these existing story threads is proving harder than creating something completely fresh. Details from Season 1, like Picard’s artificial body and Raffi’s personal issues, are essential to understanding who these characters have become when viewers reconnect with them.

It’s more than just hidden references or a tribute to Star Trek. It’s the amazing feeling that writers, actors, and artists throughout history are all contributing to a single, ongoing story.

Every Fan Service Element in Star Trek: Picard Also Served the Show Itself

Each returning character on Star Trek: Picard was given a clear and believable role – whether it was Geordi La Forge at the Fleet Museum or Worf working for Starfleet intelligence. The show also logically explained the return of the original Enterprise and why the crew needed it.

As a big Trek fan, I have to admit one of the coolest things about the show was seeing Moriarty, played by Daniel Davis, back! I thought he was gone for good after both Nemesis and the end of Picard Season 1. But it totally worked because the story explained his return through Data’s ‘revival’ – it turns out Data’s consciousness was being held, essentially imprisoned, at the Daystrom Institute, and that’s how Moriarty fit in. It was a clever way to bring him back and make it feel connected to the larger story.

Moriarty, a remarkably intelligent holographic villain who wanted to be independent, perfectly represented his friend’s plea for help. It was a clever reference that only a dedicated fan would understand. Crafting Data’s storyline was a bit more challenging, but the writers successfully built upon the strong foundation established by the storytelling team in Season 1.

Creating a second version of the ship not only brought the character back, but also fulfilled Gene Roddenberry’s last vision for them.

According to Spiner, the character of the Great Bird of the Galaxy predicted that when Data’s story concluded, he would be almost human, but not quite. While some fans use the term ‘fan service’ negatively, Spiner considers it a compliment.

It’s easy to revisit established stories in a way that weakens them. But Star Trek: Picard successfully built on the show’s long history to deliver a complete, meaningful, and genuinely satisfying conclusion. While Picard Season 3 could be called “fan service,” that’s because the creators were fans themselves, and they ultimately enriched the story, its characters, and the Star Trek franchise as a whole.

You can now buy Star Trek: Picard on Blu-ray or DVD, and all three seasons are available to stream on Paramount+.

Read More

2026-05-29 22:10