Seinfeld’s Near Cancellation After Pilot Episode: How the Iconic Sitcom Survived

by

Everyone has their favorite, but when people talk about the greatest sitcom ever, Seinfeld on NBC often comes up. The show, which ran for nine seasons and was inspired by comedian Jerry Seinfeld’s life, is considered a standard for modern TV comedy because of its funny, everyday observations and unique way of telling stories.

Despite its incredible success, Seinfeld almost didn’t make it past its first season. Surprisingly, the show was nearly canceled even before it really began – after just a pilot episode was filmed. Looking back, it’s hard to believe that NBC almost dropped a show that eventually drew 76 million viewers for its final episode.

Most fans agree that the first season of Seinfeld, with only five episodes, is the weakest. It’s so different from the show’s later, more popular seasons that many viewers on streaming services skip it entirely. In fact, after seeing the first episode, network bosses almost cancelled the show.

Seinfeld Was Almost Canceled After Its Pilot Episode

A former NBC executive shared a story on the 2023 podcast The Town with Matthew Belloni about an early screening of Seinfeld’s pilot episode in 1989. Warren Littlefield said the screening was a “total disaster” and that the show almost didn’t get picked up.

When people rewatch the first episode of Seinfeld today, it’s easy to see why the initial test audience didn’t love it. It feels forced and a little awkward, like Jerry Seinfeld and Larry David were overly concerned with making a good impression on NBC. Despite this, NBC gave them money for a few more episodes, surprisingly ordered a second season, and the show went on to become a huge success.

After A Slow Start, Seinfeld Became A Huge Hit In Season 4

Despite a rocky start, the sitcom Seinfeld didn’t truly become a television classic until its third season, with Larry David’s personal favorite episode. For the first two seasons, ratings were consistently low, leaving the producers unsure if NBC would renew the show.

A pivotal moment for Seinfeld came with the episode “The Contest.” This installment, where the four main characters bet on who can go the longest without indulging in a specific act – playfully referred to as being a “master of their domain” – remains iconic. It’s not only Larry David’s favorite episode, but a cultural landmark that broadened the boundaries of humor on television.

Seinfeld Wouldn’t Have Survived More Than 1 Season In 2025

Today’s TV executives likely wouldn’t have allowed Seinfeld to succeed, especially considering current trends. Netflix, which streams the show worldwide, is known for quickly canceling programs, and this approach is starting to affect the overall quality of what they offer.

It’s really frustrating to see how quickly streaming services are cancelling shows that are actually good, like GLOW, Mindhunter, and The OA. It makes me think a classic like Seinfeld probably wouldn’t have lasted very long today. We might never have gotten iconic episodes like “The Contest,” and honestly, comedy on TV could look completely different if these platforms had been around back then. It feels like they just don’t give shows enough time to find an audience anymore.

Fortunately, Warren Littlefield and his colleagues decided to give Seinfeld a chance despite some valid concerns. This risk proved incredibly successful, and the show ultimately became what many consider the greatest sitcom ever made.

Read More

2025-11-01 04:48