Persona 5 Retro: Fan Reactions to a 2012/2013 Release Concept

As a long-time fanatic of the Persona series, who has witnessed its evolution since the early days of Shin Megami Tensei: Persona, I found myself deeply engrossed in this fascinating discussion about an alternate timeline for Persona 5. The nostalgic yearning for bygone eras and the curiosity about how the game would’ve looked if released in 2012 or 2013 was palpable, making me feel like I had time-traveled myself.

Fans of Persona are constantly seeking out new things that can fuel their enthusiasm for the series, and a recent discussion about what Persona 5 might have been like if it had been released in 2012 or 2013 has sparked curiosity and a wave of nostalgia. Users shared their opinions on the differences in character designs, visual styles, and overall impressions of a possible alternate timeline for this popular game. From elaborate scarf designs to the fusion of various international influences, the discussion highlighted a range of appreciation, criticism, and even humor from enthusiastic members of the community.

Persona 5, if it had been released in 2012/2013. (the-phantom-peach)
byu/Long_Xiao inPERSoNA

Summary

Fans expressed curiosity over the altered aesthetic of characters, some viewing it as a Western twist on the original design.
Comments ranged from appreciation of the new designs to a stark disapproval, signaling a divided opinion on artistic choices.
Humorous remarks about character similarities and differences added a lighthearted vibe to the discussion.
The concept also invited nostalgic reflection on game design trends of the early 2010s.

The Aesthetic Debate

One of the hottest topics stemming from the idea of a 2012/2013 version of Persona 5 was how the aesthetic shifted to reflect a more Western vibe. User Zealousideal_You_938 noted, “Maybe it’s me but I find it curious that this version seems like an American version of the game, the aesthetics, the character designs, etc.” This perspective emphasizes how deeply entwined culture is with design choices made in video games. Traditional Japanese influences have largely shaped the Persona series’ styles, but imagining a shift to meet Western tastes opens various avenues for creative exploration. Some fans considered whether game companies like Atlus would alter the narratives and characterizations to cater to this shift, which inevitably affects gameplay and storytelling as well.

Character Design Reactions

In the bustling comment section of this game, discussions were swirling about character design comparisons, particularly focusing on Joker’s prototype adorned with a scarf. Cronogunpla chimed in, “I find the prototype art fascinating. The Joker with a scarf is cool, but I get why they opted for something different.” This comment showcases a blend of admiration for creative flair and recognition of design choices made for practicality. Interestingly, the scarf has developed its own cult following, as evidenced by comments like Mazu26’s, who simply said, “I dig the scarf. I just don’t know why.” It’s amazing how certain design elements can stir up strong emotions: some embrace innovation while others long for familiar designs that take them back to their gaming roots.

Character Comparisons and Humorous Takes

Users often find themselves identifying relatable characteristics or creating humorous comparisons between redesigned characters and well-known ones. For instance, Straw_Hat_Puffy commented that Akechi resembles Ken, while others jokingly matched other favorites with various cultural references. Such instances foster a sense of community connection through shared laughter and nostalgia. Lively banter and memes inject energy into conversations, demonstrating fans’ fervor and joviality towards their cherished series. Pootisman16 humorously quipped, “Femboy Yusuke, hold still my beating heart,” encapsulating shared adoration as well as the lively banter in the comments section. These playful remarks underline that fan expression in the gaming world can take numerous forms.

Ultimately Embracing Diversity in Design

This lively conversation showcases the overall opinion about major changes in game design within the gaming community. Open debates among players promote various viewpoints, leading to a greater understanding and appreciation for how the series can grow and adapt. The mix of praise and criticism towards what might have been indicates a strong bond fans share with Persona as a brand. It suggests they are eager to engage with the franchise beyond being mere consumers, instead participating in its development throughout its lifespan. These discussions function like an open virtual forum where opinions merge and influence future designs. It’s clear that each new release retains the spirit of its predecessors while injecting fresh creativity.

Delving into hypothetical scenarios, exploring Persona 5’s potential release in 2012/2013 offers a rich exploration of what resonates most with its community. The lively dialogues, character design analysis, and undeniable humor reveal a fanbase eager to savor the journey of their beloved franchises.

2024-11-08 14:43