NBC’s ‘Grosse Pointe Garden Society’ Delivers Murder, Mayhem and Soapy Chaos: TV Review

A captivating murder mystery combined with distinctive characters and over-the-top humor makes “Grosse Pointe Garden Society” an enticing TV show to watch. Created by Jenna Bans, along with her co-creator Bill Krebs, this new drama shares similarities with popular shows like “Desperate Housewives” and “How to Get Away with Murder.” Despite some initial missteps, the NBC series is engaging and leaves viewers both puzzled and intrigued. Set in Grosse Pointe, Michigan – a wealthy suburb of Detroit – and focusing on four members of the local garden club, this show demonstrates that adding a soap opera twist to familiar plotlines often results in success.

The story begins with a shovel striking the ground, revealing a hidden grave, and then swiftly moves back six months in time. At the headquarters of the Grosse Pointe Garden Society, we find ourselves amidst two interwoven stories. Alice (AnnaSophia Robb), a young literature teacher, is frantic with worry over her lost golden retriever, Molly. Simultaneously, Brett (Ben Rappaport), a landscaper and single father since his wife’s scandalous affair, struggles to adapt to his new life. Completing the trio is Catherine (Aja Naomi King), a meticulous real-estate agent and vice president of the Garden Society, who has won the town’s affection with her perfectionism, though this admiration begins to wane over time.

The team experiences an unexpected shakeup when Birdie (played brilliantly by Melissa Fumero), a wealthy socialite/romance novelist, joins them after a DUI and court-mandated community service. As they grow more acquainted, the group starts revealing their personal issues and messy private lives, culminating in a night of covering up a murder at the Garden Society’s annual black-tie event.

In “Grosse Pointe,” it’s King and Fumero who truly steal the show in their roles. The more captivating moments of the series revolve around their characters. Catherine, preoccupied with image, finds comfort in her friendship with Birdie, a character who lives freely and authentically. The contrast between these two, portrayed by Bans and Krebs, adds depth to the series. When Catherine and Birdie’s individual choices (and distinct styles) clash, it creates some of the most interesting scenes. In diverse ways, both women grapple with issues of perception, self-acceptance, and fitting in.

Alice and Brett encounter difficulties just like everyone else, but their struggles aren’t as compelling compared to others. Additionally, the character of Alexander Hodge, portraying Alice’s artist husband Doug, is not utilized effectively. When Alice discovers her dog’s fate, she spirals out of control, creating turmoil in her marriage and at work, instead of focusing on what she can manage. Since there isn’t much else for him to do, Brett frequently finds himself locked in power struggles with his ex-wife Melissa’s new husband, Connor, who seems overly interfering. There is also a trope where Alice and Brett are supposed to be best friends but the feelings between them develop into something more, which doesn’t feel genuine due to lack of chemistry between Robb and Rappaport in their romantic scenes.

The main issue with the show lies in its complex narrative structure, as it features multiple timelines – past, present, and future. While the storyline in “Grosse Pointe” is generally straightforward, the frequent shifts between these timelines and the constant chronology cues can make for a somewhat confusing viewing experience.

In the heart of Grosse Pointe, the show subtly incorporates gardening terminology and plant behaviors that mirror the on-screen action. While those without a knack for gardening might miss these references, they don’t detract from the main storyline. On the other hand, plant enthusiasts will appreciate the dialogue and the breathtaking visuals of the grand central greenhouse, adding an extra layer of enjoyment to this unique blend of comedy and drama.

Viewers might find themselves puzzled as they try to figure out who’s buried among the flowers. Various speculations and hints will arise, multiply, or even lead to more perplexity. However, the delightful chaos of “Grosse Pointe Garden Society” is sure to entice viewers to tune in every week. But if nothing significant is uncovered by the end of Season 1, it’s questionable whether viewers will stick around for another season.

The ‘Grosse Pointe Garden Society’ makes its debut on NBC on February 23rd. Every week, new episodes will be released on Sundays.

Read More

2025-02-23 21:16