NBA 2K25 Review - Luxury Taxed

As a long-time basketball enthusiast and video game connoisseur, I’ve been captivated by NBA 2K since its inception. Year after year, it manages to reel me back in with its immersive gameplay and vibrant social scene – The City being the pièce de résistance. However, this year’s beach boardwalk setting has done more than just refresh the scenery; it’s given me a newfound appreciation for virtual shopping malls!


Similar to its previous versions, NBA 2K25 stands out as the exceptional sports game I’ve played this year, but it carries a noticeable warning label. This year’s basketball simulation from Visual Concepts continues to lead the pack in the sports genre, a category of games all aiming to become your go-to live-service fix. Among them, NBA 2K25 offers the best justification for your time investment, setting itself apart with superior presentation, gameplay, and overall immersion. However, despite its individual excellence, I worry that persistent pay-to-win mechanics may persist, potentially undermining the overall experience.

As a dedicated gamer diving into NBA 2K25 this year, I’ve noticed some significant improvements that truly elevate the gaming experience. The new dribbling physics system gives the ball handling a remarkably realistic touch, something you can instantly feel while playing. It’s like the game is mirroring the sensation of maintaining control over a real basketball, making those tricky maneuvers around defenders and keeping the ball secure feel incredibly authentic.

Unlike some other series that abandon concepts if they’re not successful after a while, the NBA 2K series appears to be more dedicated to refining, adjusting problematic elements until they become appealing, and enhancing good aspects into excellent ones. This commitment is evident in the second year of their ProPlay system. In NBA 2K24, the fundamental overhaul is made more intricate with a multitude of new animations, many designed to mimic a player’s real-life playing style. Basketball is a sport where each individual plays differently, making no two players identical. NBA 2K25 further captures this unique player distinctiveness by introducing more unique jump shots, signature moves, and even post-score celebrations inspired by real-life performances.

NBA 2K25 Review - Luxury Taxed

Previously, the community was critical about the game’s shooting mechanics that required players to hit a specific zone (the green zone) for successful shots or miss completely. Now, the developers have responded by introducing two different shooting styles. The initial one retains the old system with its high-risk, high-reward nature, depending on your controller skills to manage tricky or off-balance situations. The second option is more lenient, allowing for some errors but focusing more on strategic elements such as positioning and defense. Essentially, the first could be likened to the “competitive” mode in Madden games, while the second is akin to the “simulation” mode.

Essentially, this option provides each player with the ability to select either an upgraded version of last year’s game system or the one from before 2K24. Both scenarios are made user-friendly due to the game’s advanced UI customization and create-a-jumpshot features. Together, these elements enable you to modify the visual aspects of your on-screen shot meter (such as size, shape, colors, and position), as well as design your own shooting style to find a timing pattern that suits you best.

For beginners in basketball, navigating on-court play can be quite challenging. Fortunately, NBA 2K now includes an extensive skills trainer that guides players through the entire game. The Learn 2K mode caters to novices, intermediate players, and even professional athletes seeking a practice arena between matches. It covers fundamental basketball basics all the way up to advanced features like ball handling and deceptive moves, including ankle-breaking techniques.

This fresh suite is certainly beneficial since sports games often grow complex due to the assumption that many players are repeating from previous years. However, every game welcomes a new set of players, some of whom are experiencing it for the first time. It’s wonderful to have this comprehensive new game mode available to ease the onboarding process for these novice players.

NBA 2K25 Review - Luxury Taxed

2K has consistently nailed the vibe of live TV broadcasts for its sports games, something unmatched by others, and this tradition continues with 2K25. While there might not be any groundbreaking new features in presentation this year, it’s hard to imagine how it could get better. The series seems to have reached a pinnacle in this aspect, and few other sports games are even close.

The commentary remains exceptionally lifelike, maintaining its top position among video games. It employs various commentary teams, including charismatic individuals like Kevin Harlan, who manage to sound authentic. They provide a rich tapestry of detail, making it seem as if you’re listening to a real NBA game, even without visuals. The commentators accurately recall past matches and discuss NBA history and upcoming rivalries, before engaging players in post-game press conferences where they respond to media questions.

Timeouts shift from the strategic discussions between coaches and players on the sidelines to the diverse forms of entertainment on the court, such as mascots showing off stunts or dance groups presenting lively performances during potential quiet moments. The ambiance, score display, audience reactions, and commentator comments – it’s all captivating. It’s remained this engaging for quite some time, yet it never feels old.

During half-time, the shows continue to be amusing and worth tuning into, as the hosts move from team to team discussing other scores and exciting moments, combining humor and insight. In NBA 2K25, a TV show within the game—typically awkward in games like MLB The Show and Madden—is surprisingly enjoyable. I never miss these shows. They’re fully produced with animation, voices, and they keep me engaged. For instance, one episode features the hosts debating the ranking of historical dynasties within the league.

Unlike any other sports game out there, NBA 2K25 goes above and beyond in terms of immersion. While other series strive to replicate some of its unique elements, they often fall short, providing an experience that’s only enjoyable once or twice. In NBA 2K25, I seldom use the fast-forward button. Beginning a new season with the Celtics, I attended their championship ring ceremony on opening night and was captivated by how seamlessly the cutscene was executed. NBA 2K25’s visuals, audio, and gameplay feel incredibly authentic, making me an even bigger basketball enthusiast due to its engaging features.

NBA 2K25 Review - Luxury Taxed

One way to rephrase the text in a more natural and easy-to-read manner is as follows: Each year, the uniqueness of this series in surpassing its competitors is showcased through its franchise-like mode called MyNBA. Two years ago, Visual Concepts debuted a groundbreaking feature called Eras, which allows you to establish a league set in one of several distinct decades dating back over 40 years. Each era accurately recreates the atmosphere, rules, playing styles, visuals, and rosters from those specific periods. This was already impressive when it first launched, and similar to last year, another Era has been added in NBA 2K25: the Steph Curry Era.

Similar to how the Kobe Era revolutionized basketball last year by introducing a gamified beginning, this new addition marks another significant milestone in NBA history. It offers a more complex account of player contracts and introduces an in-season tournament for the NBA Cup. Although many of its exciting features were unveiled two years ago, this new era provides an opportunity to expand upon them. However, compared to the other eras, this one may not have as much allure since it’s set in the present day and lacks the intriguing time capsule quality of the others.

Over the past few years, NBA 2K has been growing its WNBA features significantly, and this year is no exception – it boasts an even more expansive set of options than ever before, although it still falls short when it comes to matching the men’s league in terms of feature parity. The popularity of the WNBA is at an all-time high right now, thanks in part to promising newcomers like Caitlin Clark and Angel Reese. To reflect this surge in interest, the game incorporates the same impressive presentation elements that emphasize the significance of this era for women’s basketball. In The W (similar to the men’s MyCareer mode), you can now attend press conferences as your custom-created athlete, marking a first for the series. A significant portion of gameplay will revolve around competing against renowned rookies like Clark and Reese, with in-game challenges pushing you to surpass them on your journey towards becoming the greatest player in WNBA history.

I find this feature appealing because it offers a different set of experiences compared to MyCareer. For me, the former is more about revisiting basketball history that I’m already familiar with, while the WNBA version feels fresh and educational for me. The commentators often bring up legends from the past or recent achievements like Becky Hammon’s consecutive titles with Las Vegas. Additionally, press conferences provide insights that help me understand more about a league that was previously not as prominent. Now that it’s gaining more attention, I feel that 2K’s offerings are designed to reflect this increased interest at a higher level.

NBA 2K25 Review - Luxury Taxed

Unfortunately, you can’t interact with your WNBA player within the game’s social environment as described, but it appears that the 2K team is putting genuine effort into enlarging the variety of modes in this area. This expansion seems to offer roughly the same amount of content as other popular sports games available today. In numerous aspects, the WNBA segment of the game indicates a significant investment or utilization of resources to create such an engaging experience.

The game captivates players with two interconnected highlights: MyPlayer and The City. MyPlayer allows users to design their own character, selecting from various RPG-style builds or fine-tuning stats across numerous categories such as dunking, three-point shooting, vertical jumping, and much more. You can even add your own face to the character using a mobile app companion, an aspect that has improved over time to the point where I now use it every year and am satisfied with the results – something that wasn’t always possible in the past.

In 2K25, you get to live your character’s background story, starting from high school, moving on to a FIBA World Cup match, and eventually signing with an NBA team in the solo-player mode called MyCareer. This game continues to expand upon the GOAT (Greatest of All Time) list introduced last year, where players aimed to surpass legends like Jordan, forging their own path towards becoming the greatest player ever. Now, you can establish a dynasty that could outshine teams like the Showtime Lakers, LeBron’s Heat, and Curry’s Warriors.

In other sports games, this solo story mode often feels like a barebones preamble to some other longer-term mode you’re meant to move onto swiftly. But in 2K25, this isn’t the case. Though there is a separate element the game wants to funnel you into, it’s also built out a lot to make playing multiple seasons in the NBA very enjoyable in its own right. Chasing NBA history is tough, and the game makes your championships and accolades feel well-recognized, with a social feed, media reactions, and live-action messages from other athletes sliding into your DMs to congratulate you. The mode successfully captures the magnitude of moments, owing to the aforementioned best-in-class presentation.

After, whether it’s before, during, or after your NBA career, you can explore The City, a dynamic sports MMO social space filled with live-service elements such as daily and weekly challenges, diverse game modes, and numerous shopping opportunities. This is where I spend a significant amount of time post-game reviews in September, as it’s the heart of the game’s extensive community, and the activities within are generally entertaining. However, the demanding nature of its daily and weekly challenge system requires an excessive amount of my time, making it unlikely for me to consider purchasing the battle pass since I would need to sacrifice other games in my leisure time to meet all of NBA 2K25’s live-service objectives. In other live-service games where I’ve committed my time, completing daily tasks typically takes between 15 and 45 minutes. The demands of NBA 2K25 are more extensive, to the point that it seems impractical for me to maintain pace with them.

NBA 2K25 Review - Luxury Taxed

In various districts across the city, you’ll find a diverse array of games, each with unique, sometimes retro-style regulations. You could engage in CPU battles against basketball greats as a formidable challenge, join spontaneous 3-versus-3 matches with fellow players, work on enhancing your player’s abilities at the gym and acquiring skill-enhancing perks, or join intense Pro-Am teams aiming to establish themselves among the game’s elite.

In terms of providing a play area, The City reigns supreme. Other sports games appear less appealing year after year as they fall short in delivering comparable experiences. A bustling social environment is crucial for live-service games, and NBA 2K continues to stand alone as the annual sports game that provides an exceptional virtual gathering spot for its players.

Previously, The City has provided me pleasure yet left me dismayed by its advertisement-heavy atmosphere; it seemed like a nightmare version of a shopping mall filled with billboards and promotional content everywhere you looked. This year’s edition of the game addresses this issue in an ingenious manner, albeit unintentionally, by transforming The City into a beach boardwalk setting. Unlike malls that I find repulsive, a beach boardwalk feels more inviting as a place where multiple stores are typically located. Consequently, the constant presence of shoe, clothing, tattoo, and backpack stores doesn’t bother me anymore. Surprisingly, just by changing its presentation, I no longer feel overwhelmed with ads to spend my virtual money, even though the same shopping options remain.

As a passionate gamer, I’ve got to admit, NBA 2K’s virtual city is an absolute masterpiece that draws me in every time. However, there’s one glaring issue that just won’t let go – the pay-to-win economy. It’s frustrating because the currency you spend on personalizing your player character can also be used to boost their skills on the court. From a mediocre 60 overall player to a top-tier 99, if you’ve got the cash for virtual currency, you can rule the game. This unique feature, which I love, is held back by this system, and I just can’t wrap my head around why it continues year after year. It’s a shame because NBA 2K has built a dedicated community that’s more than happy to shell out extra cash on day one, but at the cost of undermining the game’s overall charm.

NBA 2K25 Review - Luxury Taxed

For several years, I’ve been critiquing the internal conflicts within NBA 2K in my reviews. This year, instead of a traditional review, I’ve decided to write an accompanying piece that delves deeper into the game’s transaction problem, which can be more accurately described as a macrotransaction issue. This is a concern that has persisted in the game’s annual releases for many years. Despite the new features like easier matchmaking with casual players and building squads with avatars of similar ratings, the problem in NBA 2K25 hasn’t seemed to be resolved noticeably.

The proposed solution addresses some of the game’s financial issues, but it might not be fully effective because it involves restricting players from purchasing stat upgrades. Implementing such a change would likely result in significant financial loss for the publisher, which is why I have concerns about its implementation. Unfortunately, this flaw seems to mar the otherwise impressive gameplay of NBA 2K25. You can find my detailed analysis on this topic at the link provided, but it’s clear that this aspect casts a shadow over the overall gaming experience.

NBA 2K can be challenging to evaluate due to its complex nature, much like evaluating a messy relationship on social media. My previous article’s points have influenced my current view, making this review essentially two parts. The main issue with NBA 2K25 is apparent: Its economic designs detract from the gameplay experience, and it’s hard for anyone who doesn’t hold a “greed is good” perspective to rationalize it.

Simultaneously, it excels in numerous aspects, both as a basketball simulation and compared to other sports games, making it challenging to express adequately. It performs exceptionally well in many areas, much of which is done uniquely. However, its insistence on linking its key features with its virtual currency prevents this potential title contender from fully realizing its capabilities.

Read More

2024-09-11 01:39