In simpler terms, a federal judge has given Coinbase permission to take its dispute with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) over cryptocurrency’s legal status to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals for review, as there are differing opinions on this issue among judges.
In a recent decision, Judge Katherine Failla overturned her previous ruling from March 2024, which had rejected the company’s request for a judgment in their favor.
A Big Legal Win for Coinbase
Paul Grewal, Coinbase’s chief legal officer, acknowledged the development in a January 7 X post:
Despite strong opposition from the SEC, Judge Failla has given us permission to proceed with an intermediary appeal and suspended the trial in the district court.
In simpler terms, Eleanor Terrett from Fox Business reported that the decision was a significant legal victory for Coinbase. This is because the judge allowed an unusual type of appeal (interlocutory appeal), which lets Coinbase challenge the Securities and Exchange Commission’s claims in front of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals.
On June 6, 2023, the financial regulatory body first filed a grievance against Coinbase, asserting that the firm was carrying out the roles of a broker, national securities exchange, and clearing agency without having registered for any of these roles.
The legal action further claimed that they had broken securities regulations by selling tokens like Solana (SOL), Cardano (ADA), and Polygon (MATIC). According to their argument, these tokens fit the definition of a security according to the Howey Test.
In June 2023, the involved parties submitted a request to discard the legal case. They based this on the grounds that the assets at issue lack the standard contractual duties associated with securities, and that their activities are not within the scope of the Securities and Exchange Commission’s authority.
In response, the court partly approved and rejected this motion in March 2024, leading them to seek certification for an interlocutory appeal.
Conflicting Opinions
In her decision on January 7th, Judge Failla allowed the case to be appealed, explaining that it centered around a significant legal question – whether the Howey Test applies to cryptocurrencies and if so, how. This issue is contentious with differing viewpoints, and clarifying it would aid in wrapping up the SEC’s litigation against Coinbase.
Moreover, she emphasized similar unresolved matters from well-known cases where the regulator was involved, like its confrontation with Ripple Labs. She clarified that the ruling on Ripple established differences between token sales targeted at institutional investors and individual buyers, a stance Coinbase has recommended courts to uphold.
Moreover, she underscored Coinbase’s stance that commodities possess an intrinsic worth apart from their associated environments. Contrarily, Failla dismissed Coinbase’s restricted understanding of Howey, underlining that the lack of established contractual agreements does not exempt cryptocurrencies from being classified as securities if investors presume profits stemming from other parties’ endeavors.
The document states that there’s a lot of debate about how the Howey Test should be applied to cryptocurrencies, taking into account the broader digital environment involved in this analysis.
Failla admitted the complex legal terrain and penned down that applying the Howey Test to digital environments presents a challenging, unprecedented dilemma for the Second Circuit.
Read More
- SUI PREDICTION. SUI cryptocurrency
- „People who loved Dishonored and Prey are going to feel very at home.” Arkane veteran sparks appetite for new, untitled RPG
- LDO PREDICTION. LDO cryptocurrency
- Destiny 2: A Closer Look at the Proposed In-Game Mailbox System
- Clash Royale Deck Discussion: Strategies and Sentiments from the Community
- Jennifer Love Hewitt Made a Christmas Movie to Help Process Her Grief
- ICP PREDICTION. ICP cryptocurrency
- Naughty Dog’s Intergalactic Was Inspired By Akira And Cowboy Bebop
- Critics Share Concerns Over Suicide Squad’s DLC Choices: Joker, Lawless, and Mrs. Freeze
- EUR IDR PREDICTION
2025-01-08 23:20