John Wayne’s Most Violent Western

by

1971 marked the last collaboration between John Wayne and Maureen O’Hara on George Sherman’s movie “Big Jake.” Unlike the traditional Westerns associated with its time, this film stands out as it presents a surprisingly intimate narrative, even though it is recognized as one of Wayne’s most brutally violent. The film unfolds gradually, eschewing high-octane shootouts in favor of character development that culminates in one of John Wayne’s most intense and violent finales in his career.

Although it’s often disregarded within the genre, “Big Jake” is an underrated Western. This is partly due to the fact that it polarized fans. For those who admired Wayne’s traditional heroism, it was deemed too violent. Conversely, for those who expected constant action and shootouts, they found it slow-paced. However, if you enjoy a balance—stories with emotional depth accompanied by enough action to maintain interest—then “Big Jake” is a Western that deserves a watch.

Big Jake Features One of the Greatest Western Duos Ever

In a different setting, Big Jake trails the affluent McCandles clan. A daring heist led by the infamous Fain Gang at their ranch home, managed by Martha McCandles (Maureen O’Hara) and her sons Michael (Christopher Mitchum), Jeff (Bobby Vinton), and James (Patrick Wayne), results in the abduction of Jeff’s little boy, Little Jake. With a $1 million ransom demand and an urgent need to retrieve her grandson, Martha contacts her estranged spouse, Jacob McCandles (John Wayne), for assistance.

Other John Wayne and Maureen O’Hara Films
FilmRelease Year
Rio Grande1950
The Quiet Man1952
McLintock!1963

In the belief he was deceased, Big Jake, accompanied by his faithful canine companion, roamed the Western territories as a gunfighter. However, when word reached him that his kin were in peril, he hastened to their rescue, embarking on a trek through the untamed wilderness to retrieve Little Jake. With the ransom funds secured and mounted on horseback with his mule and packhorses, Big Jake was joined by his elderly Apache friend Sam Sharpnose (played by Bruce Cabot). Together they pursued the outlaws to the settlement of Escondero. In this town, Big Jake employed his traditional abilities to neutralize John Fain (portrayed by Richard Boone), his gang, and ultimately reclaim what was once a forgotten family.

Big Jake Offers a Slow Burn with an Exciting Climax

In contrast to its action-packed Western portrayal, the film Big Jake carries a surprisingly personal touch. Although it features outlaws, a daring rescue operation, and a classic western setting, at its core, it’s a heartfelt tale about a father who abandoned his family, exploring the consequences when he is unexpectedly thrust back into their lives once more.

In a nutshell, Big Jake has been absent from his family for many years. Martha, his wife, views him as an unpleasant individual. He departed his sons when they were still boys and teenagers. Consequently, when he reenters their lives to save Little Jake, they display hostility towards their father. After their own efforts to rescue Little Jake fall short, they are compelled to come together and collaborate with their father in bringing him home. Apart from the animosity they feel towards their neglectful father, the sons have distinct approaches. Michael and James, being younger men, lean on contemporary tools and concepts, whereas Jake openly expresses his disinterest in such things. He prefers horses, mules, and traditional revenge strategies. The movie primarily explores these themes of old versus new ways and absent fathers versus resentful sons throughout its duration.

Big Jake may appear gruff on the outside, but beneath that tough exterior lies a heart full of care and devotion towards his family. Despite his cold demeanor, he’s quick to act when it comes to safeguarding his loved ones. In his unique way, he expresses love by shielding them from harm, putting himself between danger and those he cherishes most. He even goes as far as pursuing a grandson he’s never met, demonstrating his unwavering loyalty.

The movie moves at a leisurely pace, but intentionally so, focusing more on character development than action-packed scenes like gunfights. This might not appeal to everyone initially, but it’s definitely worth persevering as the plot unfolds. Once the family reaches Escondero and the plan is set in motion, “Big Jake” transforms into a full-blown Western, filled with shootouts, ambushes, and dramatic sacrifices. Interestingly, the gradual progression of events heightens the impact of the climax. By the time the first major gun battle occurs, viewers have already developed an emotional connection to the characters and their relationships, making the ending all the more powerful.

Big Jake is John Wayne at his Most Violent

Although it came out during a time when spaghetti Westerns and revisionist Westerns were popular, the film Big Jake retains a traditional John Wayne feel, even if it was near the end of his career. However, compared to some of Wayne’s earlier movies, Big Jake presents a more pronounced grittiness in its depiction of violence.

In a departure from the usual 1800s setting, this film unfolds in the dynamic era of the 20th century, showcasing the impact of technological advancements on the once wild American West. The narrative subtly delves into the role of violence as we transition towards modernity.

I, as a movie critic, find the film masterfully contrasting the established order represented by Martha, with her relentless pursuit of progress and civilization through their cattle enterprise, against the raw, untamed spirit embodied by Big Jake, who clings to the old ways of the West.

However, this divide between the two worlds is momentarily blurred when technology and modernity prove ineffective against the ruthless outlaws who abduct their grandson, forcing both worlds to come together in a struggle for survival.

In “Big Jake,” there’s a shift towards a higher degree of graphic violence compared to what was common in John Wayne’s earlier movies. The portrayal of hand-to-hand combat and gore in this film is quite intense as per Wayne’s usual standards. Although “Big Jake” may not be remembered as one of the bloodiest Westerns, its violence, particularly for a John Wayne movie, was notably severe when it was first released. Despite alternating between violent scenes and quieter moments, it’s evident that this isn’t your typical, bloodless John Wayne film.

Upon release, Big Jake left several critics and spectators taken aback due to its unconventional portrayal of violence in the Western genre. Known for his cleaner, more conventional image of masculinity, John Wayne took a stark departure with this 1971 film, veering towards a grittier, darker tone. Critics condemned the movie for what they perceived as excessive violence, labeling it brutal and going beyond the requirements of the storyline. However, some critics hailed Big Jake as one of Wayne’s finest performances in his later career.

In a unique twist, “Big Jake” isn’t just a heartfelt reunion between two Hollywood legends, but also one of John Wayne’s finest performances. Unlike his conventional Western movies, this film delves into a more intimate narrative that draws viewers in as the characters approach their climactic standoff. In contrast to many Westerns where action overshadows character development, “Big Jake” manages to make audiences emotionally invested by the time the family confronts the Fain Gang, particularly in the reconciled father and sons. For Western genre enthusiasts, “Big Jake” remains a must-watch even after more than five decades.

Read More

2025-04-25 16:06