I Can’t Get Over How Robert Downey Jr. Went From MCU Golden Boy to Cheap Marketing Trick

by

Robert Downey Jr. was once synonymous with Iron Man. His performance as the wealthy, intelligent, and charismatic Tony Stark truly defined his career. Not only was Iron Man the first member of the Avengers, but he also launched the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe. Downey Jr.’s confident attitude, witty remarks, and the vulnerability beneath the Iron Man armor made the MCU’s story feel meaningful and complex, going beyond a simple quest for Infinity Stones.

Tony Stark, and Robert Downey Jr.’s portrayal of him, was truly the heart of the Marvel universe, far more so than Captain America with his unwavering and sometimes preachy sense of right and wrong. Steve Rogers’ leadership often felt judgmental instead of motivating. Downey didn’t just act as Iron Man; he embodied everything a Marvel hero should be.

His transformation from a careless arms dealer to a selfless hero made the fantastical world feel real and relatable. His death wasn’t just a universe-saving act; it marked the completion of the MCU’s most flawlessly developed character story. Afterwards, the entire world felt like it was crumbling.

The Great Post-Endgame Collapse

Following the massive success of *Endgame*, Marvel struggled to recapture the magic. Subsequent films haven’t lived up to expectations, feeling more like routine episodes than meaningful additions to the overarching story. *Eternals* (2021) aimed high but lacked emotional depth, *Thor: Love and Thunder* (2022) mistook humor for heart, and *Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania* (2023) felt like a hastily-made idea pitched in a meeting.

The idea of the multiverse was supposed to allow for exciting new stories, but it largely became a way for Marvel to reuse old ideas. The planned ‘Kang Dynasty’ storyline was intended to fix this, with Jonathan Majors’ portrayal of Kang as a compelling and unique villain – a successor to Thanos. However, when Majors faced legal issues and was removed from the role, those plans fell apart. Surprisingly, this setback might actually turn out to be a positive thing for Marvel.

A Confused Start For A New Marvel Era

The movie was intended to be a fresh start for Marvel, offering a new take on the Fantastic Four. The actors – Pedro Pascal, Vanessa Kirby, Joseph Quinn, and Ebon Moss-Bachrach – were a strong ensemble. It had a distinctive style, aiming for a blend of classic mid-century science fiction and modern technology. However, instead of feeling innovative, the film came across as fragmented and didn’t quite come together.

The inconsistent tone wasn’t the only issue. The story, about a creature trying to steal a baby for its power, felt very similar to something we’d seen before—and not in a good way. It was essentially a retelling of *Ghostbusters II*; you just swap Vigo the Carpathian for a space monster and baby Oscar for the Storms’ son, Franklin, and the resemblance is striking. It was that obvious.

Even with Julia Garner as the Silver Surfer – a solid, though predictable, casting choice – the movie couldn’t overcome its biggest problem: a wildly inconsistent tone. It jumped between a fun, old-fashioned adventure and a dark, slow-paced story, creating a film that felt assembled by many hands instead of a unified creative vision. It wasn’t terrible, just…okay. But right now, Marvel needs more than just ‘okay’.

James Gunn Gets It

For a long time, DC Comics films were criticized for being too dark and lacking a clear vision. But under James Gunn’s leadership, things seem to be changing for the better. The upcoming film, starring Rachel Brosnahan as Lois Lane and Nicholas Hoult as Lex Luthor, feels reminiscent of earlier Marvel movies – those that prioritized strong storytelling over simply gathering a large cast of famous actors.

Gunn portrays Clark Kent as a genuinely relatable person, thoughtfully examining both his alien origins and the values instilled in him by his adoptive parents, the Kents (played by Pruitt Taylor Vince and Neva Howell). The film feels incredibly sincere, emphasizing that what truly makes a hero isn’t their abilities, but the decisions they make.

Lois Lane, as portrayed by Brosnahan, is arguably the best version of the character we’ve seen in years. She’s intelligent, brave, and witty, and importantly, she’s a fully realized individual, separate from her connection to Superman – something previous films often lacked. James Gunn’s *Superman* prioritizes compelling characters and their stories over simply showcasing iconic figures, and that’s what sets it apart. While Marvel focuses on revisiting familiar heroes, DC appears to be starting fresh with a completely new approach.

The Golden Boy Returns Amid Marvel’s Identity Crisis

Bringing Downey back as Victor Von Doom – a character who fits well within The Fantastic Four universe – feels less like a story decision and more like a desperate attempt to boost viewership. It’s Marvel relying on its biggest star to recapture audience interest, and it’s understandable why they would. Downey is a reliable draw, practically guaranteeing people will tune in. But that’s precisely why this feels like a misguided move.

Robert Downey Jr. was fantastic as Iron Man, and bringing him back for a different role could damage that iconic portrayal. However, Marvel seems willing to take that risk. It appears the studio is relying heavily on familiar faces to maintain its success, feeling pressure to stay relevant. Faced with challenges to their original plans, they’re doing what many studios do when unsure of the future: revisiting what worked in the past.

Avengers: Doomsday hits theaters worldwide on Dec. 18, 2026.

Read More

2025-10-10 17:40