How Long Can Poker Face Keep Doing This?

by

Warning: This discussion contains plot points from seasons 2 to the final episode titled “The End of the Road,” which aired on Peacock on July 10.

In the universe of Poker Face, beware if you encounter a small, gravelly-toned wanderer who instinctively exclaims “bullshit” upon hearing untruths. This character, Charlie Cale, portrayed by Natasha Lyonne, inadvertently becomes a danger to herself and others throughout the series. The second season of Poker Face is marked by one calamity after another for Charlie. She develops a bond with a charming man who served her rotisserie chicken and engaged in discussions about Christmas movies, only to discover him murdered and posed like a store mannequin in the same big-box store where their romance blossomed. She forms an alliance with a New Yorker who shares her fondness for the film Michael Clayton, but that woman meets a horrific end by fire. In the season finale, Charlie’s lie-detecting skills are outmaneuvered in a dramatic turn of events by the world’s top assassin, whom she had unknowingly befriended and ended up leading to her target. As the second season comes to a close, Charlie is left with a shattered sense of self, lost friends, and a life in disarray.

The show Poker Face has been vague about how Charlie’s ability functions, intentionally so, making things even more puzzling when we find out that yes, Charlie can be deceived. This twist undermines the fundamental premise of the series. Moreover, considering Charlie’s tendency to unwittingly cause harm to those around her, one might question how much longer Poker Face can subject its protagonist to such treatment.

The second season of the show improved upon the first due to its focus on individual episodes and a deeper exploration of Charlie’s personal life. However, the last two episodes raise concerns about the series’ long-term viability, particularly regarding how it portrays Charlie as a person and the escalating predicaments in which it places her. As we anticipate news of a third season, we wonder which cards Poker Face has already played and what new ones it may reveal.

How long can Poker Face avoid explaining Charlie’s gift?

One of the recurring themes in the TV series “Poker Face” is that Charlie’s special talent, which allows her to instinctively detect lies, remains unexplained, providing the writers with a lot of creative freedom. This ambiguity adds an element of intrigue as we see Charlie’s involuntary “bullshit” response and her struggle to articulate how her ability works. For instance, in the season premiere “The Game Is a Foot”, she admits, “I’m not exactly sure, but that’s not really the point.” The focus instead is on how Charlie responds to the truths she uncovers and how she challenges people about their questionable actions.

In simpler terms, the show “Poker Face” seemed to stumble in its season finale “The End of the Road” by attempting to explain why the assassin known as the Iguana (played by Patti Harrison) deceived Charlie by pretending to be her friend Alex. However, Charlie’s reasoning that the Iguana/Alex got away with lying because she had never done it when Charlie was trying to catch her doesn’t make sense, since we’ve seen Charlie expose lies even without intention.

If the aim is to show that Charlie, due to all the death and loneliness around her, became vulnerable to the Iguana’s tricks, then future seasons could explore Charlie rediscovering her gift and accepting it for what it is (a common superhero theme!). However, the series sometimes slows down its pace by repeatedly emphasizing that Charlie has no backstory and by overloading the hints through characters like John Cho’s con artist, Guy, telling Charlie “nobody is foolproof.” The show has effectively developed Charlie into a skilled investigator beyond her talent; it doesn’t require constant reminders about what she does or doesn’t know about herself.

How long can Poker Face keep emotionally devastating Charlie?

In the second season of Poker Face, it’s evident that the character knows she’s mistreating Charlie due to the growing solitude being a significant plot point. To escape her feelings of isolation while on the road, she takes an office job, talks to Good Buddy over her car radio, and moves to New York City. The character’s unwillingness to forge connections with others because she believes they’ll end up getting hurt is fascinating but also heart-wrenching. Throughout the season, Charlie encounters tragic events such as discovering a dead love interest in “One Last Job,” losing a friend in “A New Lease on Death,” and seeing two of her closest relationships dissolve – Beatrix Hasp being murdered and Luca Clark abandoning her in “The End of the Road.” Initially, Charlie expresses discomfort with introspection, but later she opens up to Alex, confessing, “I know where this ends… people don’t appreciate truth as much as they think they do,” only for Alex to betray her too.

Can Charlie handle any more of this? Will she suffer a breakdown similar to Fletcher Reede from “Liar Liar” in season three? Could it be that she withdraws herself completely from others until a unique case forces her to return? The question of how Charlie’s powers work might not be as crucial as finding ways for her to use her abilities without causing harm or heartbreak to those around her. This is why it seems beneficial to include more episodes like “Sloppy Joseph” in season three, where no human life was lost but Charlie was still able to expose a malicious child’s actions, aid a father-son duo, and make a positive impact on an elementary school community before moving on. Lyonne’s acting skills are impressive enough to convey Charlie’s growing distress, but it seems that “Poker Face” is starting to rely too heavily on the trope of a painful romantic loss for its protagonist. It would be refreshing if the number of days without a friend of Charlie’s being killed weren’t so difficult to count.

How long can Poker Face keep relying on the FBI?

In the first season of the show, it was frustrating that justice often relied on law enforcement when Charlie couldn’t administer it herself. Thankfully, the second season shifted gears by incorporating criticisms of the police. For instance, the cops in “The Game Is a Foot” were ineffective with Charlie’s suspicions about the Kazinsky sisters, and “Whack-A-Mole” showcased John Mulaney’s corrupt FBI agent. The third episode, “The Taste of Human Blood,” even poked fun at police culture and those who rise through their departments. This allowed Charlie to remain central to the show’s themes of right and wrong while developing new relationships instead of being overly tied down by Agent Luca. However, “The End of the Road” disrupted this by having the FBI wrongfully pursue Charlie intensely. It seems counterproductive to reconnect Charlie and Luca’s storylines again and initiate another long-term chase arc. To be honest, the show doesn’t necessarily have to maintain realism in this aspect! As a result, let us discuss…

How long is Poker Face built to last?

As a seasoned movie critic, I must say that in the first installment of “Poker Face,” we saw the prolonged storyline of Charlie evading the Frosts, crooked casino magnates with ties to criminal underworlds. However, in its second season, “Poker Face” chose to step back from this narrative thread, apparently resolving Charlie’s conflicts with the Five Families and mob boss Beatrix Hasp within the first three episodes. What followed was a delightful rollercoaster ride, filled with hour-long encounters between Charlie and a myriad of rogues, keeping the show fresh and more engaging than the repetitive pattern of “then Charlie’s pursuers appeared, and she had to flee.”

The nail-biting climax of “The End of the Road,” where the FBI is hot on Charlie’s heels, hints at a reversion to the format of season one, in which a sole enemy group hampered the show’s capacity to tackle each episode independently. Now that “Poker Face” has honed its skill in creating tension, it no longer needs the shortcuts of assassins chasing Charlie through parking lots or orchards, or a harrowing event forcing her to leave town.

When Charlie ponders, “What was I even running from?,” the scene is humorously played out with hired guns firing into her soda cup and setting her off again. But let’s hope that “Poker Face” heeds this moment. A Charlie who travels across America of her own accord, embodying the spirit of Simon and Garfunkel, could sustain this series indefinitely.

How long until Charlie gets a new ride with another CB radio now that her Barracuda is smashed at the bottom of the Grand Canyon?

Sooner rather than later, as now seems like the ideal time for Charlie to confide in her Good Friend about the challenges she’s currently facing.

Read More

2025-07-10 19:57