Final Fantasy: Are Genesis and Angeal Good Additions to the FF7 Lore or Not?

As a long-time connoisseur of the Final Fantasy universe and having spent countless hours immersed in its expansive lore, I must confess that the debate surrounding Genesis and Angeal from Crisis Core has stirred my thoughts as much as the intricate battles within the series have stirred my controller.

Fans of Final Fantasy have always been vocal about the extensive world and well-developed characters in the series. Lately, there’s been an intense debate on a subreddit centered around the franchise, particularly concerning the characters Genesis and Angeal from Crisis Core. Different users have expressed their views on whether these characters enhance or detract from the FF7 storyline within the overall narrative canon. As it happens, opinions are diverse, reflecting a broad range of viewpoints from strong supporters to vehement opponents.

Were Genesis and Angeal From Crisis Core “Bad” Additions To The FF7 Canon In Your Opinion?
byu/bluemarvel99 inFinalFantasy

Summary

The users’ opinions are split, with some appreciating Genesis and Angeal while others find them detrimental to FF7’s story.
Many comments centered on the execution of Genesis’ character, who often felt more like a distraction than a meaningful presence.
Angeal is seen as somewhat bland but fulfilling a necessary role as a mentor figure.
Fans argue that the backstory of Genesis adds complexity to Sephiroth’s character arc, yet some feel it complicates the Nibelheim incident unnecessarily.

The Love-Hate Relationship with Genesis

Delving further into fan perspectives, it seems the character Genesis sparks mixed feelings among viewers. Writer_Man concisely stated: “Their idea surpasses their implementation.” Fans see Genesis as a character with promise, but many express disappointment over his dialogue being repetitive and heavily influenced by the play Loveless. User FlyinBrian2001 exclaimed, “Ninety percent of Genesis’ lines are quotes from Loveless!” This is a common complaint about the character’s lack of development beyond the literary reference. Users like SolidLuxi also point out how the writing style from the mid-2000s has negatively affected not only Genesis but the series as a whole. The inclusion of Sephiroth’s character, interwoven with Genesis’ narrative, has raised some concerns. The negative feedback is clear, and it appears that some fans believe Genesis’ presence overshadows an already complex storyline.

Angeal: The Mentor Figure That Feels Bland

From another perspective, while Angeal’s significance as a character is not universally disputed, it’s often acknowledged that he fails to break free from ordinary qualities. ChasingPesmerga expressed this thought, stating, “Angeal is more significant than Genesis, but just a little.” This viewpoint resonates with several commenters who perceive him as a counterbalance to Zack. Nevertheless, others argue that despite filling the typical mentor role that Zack required, Angeal appears shallow. Some users noted Sephiroth’s lack of fulfilling this role, but the question remains: was Angeal the ideal choice? For some, he seems neither extraordinary nor insignificant; for others, he merely exists—not exceptionally captivating yet not entirely forgettable either. One user even went so far as to say “Angeal is, which is both the best and worst thing that can be said about him.” Essentially, Angeal serves a narrative purpose, but some find his engagement potential lacking.

The Loveless Plotline: Lifting Up or Dragging Down?

A major point of debate is whether Loveless should be part of Genesis’ storyline and its influence on his character development. Fans seem divided, with some seeing it as a valuable addition that enriches the narrative, while others find it annoying. For instance, disposableaccount73 believes that Loveless adds complexity to the series, deepening our understanding of Sephiroth. They note how Genesis’ interactions with both Loveless and Angeal build suspense leading up to Sephiroth’s fall from grace. Conversely, others argue that Genesis becomes irritating, especially since they feel Loveless should have been a minor detail instead of playing such a significant role in his character. TheLucidChiba agrees, stating that Genesis becomes “extremely annoying” at times. Some fans argue that focusing on Loveless takes away from the weight of other important themes within the Final Fantasy universe.

The Sephiroth Connection: Friendship or Fable?

In conclusion, discussions focused on how Genesis and Angeal shaped Sephiroth’s character development, which is central to the poignant tale of Final Fantasy 7. One participant noted that these characters serve as Sephiroth’s sole friends who progressively distanced themselves from him. This viewpoint enriches Sephiroth’s transition from hero to antagonist. The grief of losing his comrades is said to amplify the narrative tension. This shared past makes his eventual fate more authentic, as opposed to contrived, and gives a sense of tragedy that resonates. It suggests a character driven by desperation when his support network disintegrates. On the other hand, some contend that incorporating these characters into the Nibelheim incident muddies an influential scene, potentially diluting Sephiroth’s individual storytelling.

The talks about Genesis and Angeal mirror the larger arguments within the Final Fantasy fandom. These characters may evoke contrasting emotions, yet they undoubtedly spark intense debates among enthusiasts. Whether they’re seen as detrimental or essential, their influence on the iconic FF7 storyline is palpable. The adventure in Final Fantasy isn’t only about the characters themselves, but also the discussions they inspire.

2024-08-30 22:43