Fear the Spotlight Review – Love at first light

As a seasoned gamer with a heart for narrative-driven games, I found myself utterly captivated by Fear the Spotlight. This isn’t just a game; it’s a labor of love from a married couple who’ve poured their passion for gaming and human connection into every pixel.


If you’re searching for a delightful soft core horror game that offers a thrilling yet sweet experience this festive season, then “Fear the Spotlight” by Cozy Game Pals could be just what you need!

Experience a chilling, dual-narrative journey set in an archetypal U.S. high school, brimming with ghostly encounters, intriguing riddles, and an unexpectedly rich emotional tapestry. Key characters include mysterious drama teachers, their heads adorned with theatrical lights, and a host of other unforgettable personalities.

Initially, I was apprehensive about Fear the Spotlight, as it had already been released some time ago. Given its age and the fact that it’s an indie game, I anticipated some flaws, perhaps even a lack of depth. However, my expectations were exceeded. The updates implemented by the developers after its release on Steam seem to have made a significant impact, as I find myself captivated by this delightful gem.

The horror in Fear the Spotlight

Don’t anticipate Fear the Spotlight to deliver Visage-like psychological torment or Silent Hill 2-style survival horror intensity. This game is unique in its approach and doesn’t lack depth because of it.

The gameplay is remarkably straightforward; it’s surprisingly easy to grasp. As you traverse this eerie school, you’re transported back to the year 1991, but it feels like you’re in a hellish version instead – all for the sake of rescuing your beloved. With only three main controls aside from movement and camera adjustment, you can interact with objects, crouch, and toggle your light source on or off.

Essentially, that’s the gist of it, but the ambiance and narrative in this game elevate it to extraordinary heights. The corridors from 1997 aren’t merely eerie; they seem almost oppressive. It’s as if you’re enclosed on all sides by the remnants of a tragic event, which indeed you are. Each location you visit feels like trespassing, made even more unsettling because you’ve sneaked into school after dark to conduct a seance.

In these notes, you’ll find your primary source of comprehension. Initially, they may appear scattered or incomplete. However, as you delve deeper, the events of 1997 start to fall into place. The more you read, the more the corridors seem subtly confined, and the more glimpses of ghostly eyes peeking from behind shelves you perceive.

Previously mentioned, “Fear the Spotlight” is designed for people of all backgrounds and not primarily focused on traditional horror elements. Instead, it delves into creating an intriguing mystery that keeps you engaged. While it doesn’t aim to frighten you intensely, there are moments in it that undeniably give a chill.

Fear the Spotlight Review – Love at first light

In this scenario, the character at the top, let’s call him “Suspenseful Figure” for a more descriptive name, sends shivers down my spine. He exudes an unsettling vibe, which is fitting as he indeed embodies evil. As you advance, he becomes your sole adversary, leading me to discuss the next aspect of the game.

Throughout your gameplay, you’ll frequently encounter these spectral figures. They are pale, with eyes that gleam white, and have elongated limbs. Aren’t they terrifying? Yet, there’s something intriguing about them, and I must commend the developers for this, as they don’t seem malevolent; instead, they appear as spirits. Spirits in a sense that they are as trapped as you are, and as eager for freedom as you are. This realization of mine was even more gratifying when, at a later stage in the first campaign, they actually assisted me. It was just a small act (moving a shelf so I could reach an item), but at that moment, I knew I hadn’t deceived myself. I knew I was meant to perceive them in this way.

To be honest, the true horror of this experience lies in its captivating narrative that unfolds as you delve deeper. As I unravel more of the story, it grows increasingly uncomfortable and eerie. Although the game may not deliver shocking moments in abundance, what’s present is undeniably unsettling.

Additionally, it’s not just… somewhat tragic. In Fear the Spotlight, you won’t find any sudden jumps or shocks, but when I finally understood what had transpired in 1991, my heart unexpectedly ached. Unveiling the truth about the school fire, identifying the culprit, and recognizing the real victims was almost unbearable. Such an emotional response isn’t common in video games, and it underscores the skill of the developers who knew that a compelling narrative and emotional depth were key to creating a remarkable game.

Putting the fun in… F(un)ear the Spotlight

I’m pleased to report that as a video game, Fear the Spotlight is also just fun. It’s not mechanically complex, and the puzzles are easier than you might expect from your classic survival horrors, but it’s a bloody good time. I love solving puzzles, especially so when I don’t suck at them.

The puzzles may appear haphazard at first glance, but they are not devoid of thought. For instance, the puzzle in the Gymnasium involving the fuse box might seem confusing initially, as if it’s just a jumble of pieces. However, once you figure it out, it offers an incredibly gratifying ‘aha!’ moment. To put it frankly, I found myself initially struggling with it due to its complexity and the fact that I’m not exactly a genius, even on my best days. But, when I connected two wires to the same panel and saw the lights ignite, I experienced my ‘aha!’ moment. After that breakthrough, I sailed through the remainder of the puzzle with ease, turning dials and solving simple math problems. It’s a delightful sensation to be rewarded with a sense of accomplishment after understanding something on your own.

In a refreshing twist, Fear the Spotlight skillfully avoids monotony typical in similar games by keeping survival sections brief yet not overly challenging. However, this balance results in a slight decrease in suspense as Vivian’s tale progresses, transitioning from an exhilarating experience of “Oh, here comes the Spotlight, oh no!” to a straightforward task of finding a place to hide.

Instead of expecting a run-of-the-mill ending, we were thrown for a loop with an unexpected showdown against a boss character! Frankly, I didn’t foresee that aspect in this game either, but it delivered quite the thrill. Much like the intricate fuse box puzzle, it was fulfilling to outsmart the final adversary and ultimately deal damage to him. To top it off, the climactic moment of thrusting a screwdriver into a glass light cover was nothing short of gratifying!

Fear the Spotlight Review – Love at first light

In contrast to Vivian’s storyline, Amy’s tale unfolds in a more constricting setting, making the danger seem even more overwhelming. Moreover, this menace moves swiftly, causing a surge of tension whenever one is pursued. Despite being shorter than Vivian’s narrative, Amy’s story carries a profound sense of sadness that amplifies the escalating threat level. Delving into her home life, her past, her relationship with her father, and the void left by her brother in her heart gives the house a sense of being shattered. Yet, there are moments where Amy’s resilience emerges, as seen in her tarot cards or her ‘GamePal’, which is at once comforting and bittersweet.

In summary, “Fear the Spotlight” isn’t just a well-crafted game; it’s an enjoyable one too. It offers an appealing blend of tension and excitement, where the survival segments, though they may have low stakes, never outstay their welcome. The contrast between Vivian’s and Amy’s narratives provides a refreshing change in emotional depth, with Amy’s storyline carrying a heavier, more oppressive overall tone.

Made with love

“What really makes video games great is passion, and who better to infuse that passion than a devoted couple? I recall seeing the promotional video for Cozy Game Pals as part of the Blumhouse Games initiative some time back, and it wasn’t just the game they were presenting that caught my attention, but the developers behind it.

A two-person development team, who are married, have created a game intended to be an engaging horror experience that they care deeply about, both for their loved ones and for the players they welcome into this deeply personal project. And let me tell you, they’ve hit the nail on the head. The game, Fear the Spotlight, brims with affection for video games and human connection.

Fear the Spotlight Review – Love at first light

The two characters you control, Vivian and Amy, are not only endearing but also relatable. Vivian confronts her anxieties, eventually finding the courage to put others first. Amy grapples with a heavy family past, discovering that she is not responsible for its burden. Who among us hasn’t battled anxiety or unfair self-blame? Moreover, they share mutual affection for one another, adding an adorable and charming dynamic (I must admit, I’m a fan of both).

I share your fondness for the distinctive art style found in PlayStation games, as it manages to strike a balance between emulating an older gaming era while maintaining high-quality visuals. It’s not just visually appealing, but also customizable, allowing players to adjust certain effects according to their preferences. For instance, someone like me who is sensitive to screen grain can lower the intensity to a comfortable level without losing immersion. The artistic talent behind this game is evident, particularly considering that its creators have worked on popular titles such as Animaniacs and The Last of Us.

Final Verdict

I loved every moment of the admittedly short (around four to five hours total) experience of Fear the Spotlight. A well written, spooky and fun little jaunt, made by a pair with a clear love for the industry, and what they’ve made. I can only hope future games under the umbrella of Blumhouse Games can match up to this incredibly strong first outing, and I look forward to seeing what Cozy Game Pals get up to next.

Fear the Spotlight Review – Love at first light

[Disclosure: A free copy of the game was provided to PGG by the publisher for review purposes.]

We have upgraded our commenting platform! Existing comments will be imported over the next few weeks.

Read More

2024-10-22 04:22