Fear The Spotlight Review - Blumhouse's First Video Game Is Best Enjoyed As An Intro To Horror

As someone who has spent countless hours immersed in the eerie worlds of horror games, I find Fear The Spotlight to be a refreshingly unique entry into the genre. While its narrative may initially seem disjointed, it manages to weave together a captivating tale that’s both personal and supernatural.


As a horror enthusiast, there’s no denying that Blumhouse Productions has become a dominant force in Hollywood’s chilling landscape. It seems their logo graces nearly every horror movie I watch in theaters. Their dedication to the genre is undeniable, and I can’t help but appreciate it. This focus means there’s always another fright-filled adventure on the horizon, even if the outcomes aren’t always consistent. What particularly excites me now is Blumhouse’s foray into video games with Fear The Spotlight. Just like their movies, their games may not all be masterpieces, but this indie ghost story is a promising debut, not just for Blumhouse as a new publisher, but also for the two talented developers who brought it to life.

In the game titled “Fear The Spotlight,” the main characters are Amy and Vivian, two buddies from high school who secretly wander the school grounds after dark as soon as the story starts. Amy has a punkish style reminiscent of Hot Topic fashion, whereas Vivian appears more scholarly. Their friendship, despite their contrasting appearances, creates an unusual duo. As they navigate through eerie hallways and encounter strange noises, the exploration of their bond serves to establish the narrative. Over the first three-to-four hours of gameplay, they uncover a sordid past hidden within the school’s walls.

Fear The Spotlight blends a retro PS1 ambiance with contemporary elements such as a third-person view, and occasionally switches to classic point-and-click mechanics when dealing with its puzzles. This mix of intriguing puzzles, suspenseful moments, and occasional switch to point-and-click mechanics creates a “gateway-horror” atmosphere that I find appealing, even though I may no longer be the game’s intended audience. While I appreciate games that are genuinely terrifying, I also believe that less seasoned or sensitive horror enthusiasts deserve enjoyable frights they can handle comfortably. Not every horror game needs to be as intense as Outlast or Amnesia in terms of scares.

Fear The Spotlight Review - Blumhouse's First Video Game Is Best Enjoyed As An Intro To Horror

The game “Fear The Spotlight” doesn’t particularly scare me, but it could effectively introduce a new player to the horror genre. This is by design from the two creators, so the game isn’t lacking in its aim. Instead, it aims primarily to be a horror experience tailored for teenagers, and the high-school setting and characters suit this demographic perfectly.

As a gamer, I’ve discovered that this game leans more towards the realm of chilling adventures rather than traditional survival-horror. It’s a tricky subgenre to master, as a horror experience without many combat elements can sometimes seem devoid of tension or threats. However, Fear The Spotlight manages to create several tense encounters that play out like a game of hide-and-seek with the monstrous antagonist. You won’t engage in direct combat with the central figure in this haunting tale; instead, you’ll dart beneath desks, sneak behind library carts, and slink under lunch tables, always trying to stay out of its line of sight. Sometimes, you might even find yourself solving puzzles while it’s watching, albeit unknowingly.

Short stories often incorporate puzzles, adhering to traditional elements found in survival-horror genres. The narrative isn’t straightforward as you navigate its world. You may encounter crumbled corridors, but you can bypass them using items collected through a series of steps that involve deciphering notes for clues and following the footsteps of those who preceded you. Oddly placed locks on doors might require certain symbols or emblems to open, while peculiar dolls need to be broken in a sequence hinted at by a mysterious poem nearby.

For enthusiasts of early Resident Evil and Silent Hill games, the puzzles in Fear The Spotlight will seem reminiscent, but with an unique twist: They’re more compact. Instead of traversing expansive locations such as a large mansion or foggy town where a puzzle piece found earlier may be needed miles away and hours down the line, the puzzles in Fear The Spotlight typically require moving between just a few nearby areas, like transitioning between two corridors and four classrooms at most. Similar to how the scares are adjusted for a beginner horror audience, these puzzles won’t significantly slow your progress. Essentially, they simplify traditional horror-game puzzle design concepts for newcomers.

Fear The Spotlight Review - Blumhouse's First Video Game Is Best Enjoyed As An Intro To Horror

As a gamer, I found myself struggling with the narrative of Fear The Spotlight. Despite being a relatively short game, it seems to bite off more than it can chew by tackling multiple themes at once, initially presenting a bullying motif before veering off in an entirely different direction. Throughout my playthrough, it felt like the game was trying to weave a deeper, personal story between Vivian and Amy, but these threads seemed like they were stitched together as an afterthought rather than being integrated seamlessly into the overall experience.

In the game’s conclusion, this particular aspect receives an upgrade. Essentially, it’s like a separate storyline, lasting approximately 2-3 hours, delving deeper into the events that transpire during the girls’ overnight school trip. This additional narrative is meticulously crafted, as it takes place within a solitary, eerie house, presenting puzzles that are slightly more intricate, serving as an extension of what you learned in the initial campaign, even if you’re new to the genre. It also becomes scarier due to the introduction of a tougher-to-evade enemy, and it ties together neatly with a more substantial, cohesive plot compared to the main storyline. This extra chapter can only be accessed after completing the primary game, making it an impactful finale for Cozy Game Pals, the small team that’s just starting out with Fear The Spotlight.

Over the past year, a significant portion of the team’s efforts went into developing this new campaign, following the removal of Fear The Spotlight from Steam to allow for enhancements, likely as part of the publishing agreement with Blumhouse. This decision proved beneficial, as the second act turned out to be the game’s strongest and most impactful, even enhancing the quality of the initial campaign in certain aspects. Combined, they create a more cohesive and captivating narrative, with the second campaign carrying much of the story’s weight.

Fear The Spotlight Review - Blumhouse's First Video Game Is Best Enjoyed As An Intro To Horror

Even though I generally prefer modern aesthetics, I find myself drawn to a retro vibe in horror games, possibly due to my nostalgia. Fear The Spotlight is particularly appealing as it employs this style, yet it deviates slightly from the original PlayStation look. It possesses more voice acting and an over-the-shoulder perspective, making it seem like a modern game’s demake rather than a faithful representation of the era suggested by its sharp polygonal characters. The school looks fantastic in this style, and it’s evident that the team has been inspired by Silent Hill, as some of its locations resemble the decaying, eerie environments from the Otherworld realm in Konami’s pioneering series.

While “Fear The Spotlight” might not be the most terrifying game this Halloween, for some, its perceived limitations are actually strengths. With classic puzzle designs that are more confined, and encounters with monsters devoid of combat, it uses familiar horror elements to welcome new or younger players. Mechanically, it’s straightforward, and the story doesn’t fully unfold until you’ve completed the second campaign, but its blend of traditional and modern horror gameplay mechanics makes it a chilling and intelligent introduction to a genre I adore, and one that could capture your interest as well.

Read More

2024-10-22 02:09