‘Everybody’s Live with John Mulaney’ Turns a One-Off Experiment Into Consistently Delightful Chaos: TV Review

by

The show ‘Everybody’s Live with John Mulaney‘ isn’t actually a brand new production. Instead, it represents an evolution of the previous concept called ‘Everybody’s in LA’, which was more like a temporary setup – and apparently, a test run – coordinated with the Netflix Is a Joke festival last year. Over the span of eight days, they managed to produce six episodes. Then, Mulaney spent the next ten months fine-tuning the series, making it less focused on specific regional aspects but still maintaining its unique characteristics.

In his comedy routine, Mulaney humorously mentioned that 10 months is enough time to forget how to perform this specific show. However, the following hour demonstrated that not only had he and his team forgotten the original format, but they had also made changes to it. (It was evident from Mulaney repeatedly calling “Everybody’s in LA” as “this show” instead of a different one.) Key elements like Richard Kind as the announcer, the central panel featuring celebrities with experts, and Mulaney’s questions about car types remained unchanged. While the audience may no longer be in LA, Mulaney certainly is. The updated ’70s-inspired set on a Hollywood soundstage represented the transformation from a one-time trial to a 12-episode weekly run: largely similar with minor adjustments only noticeable to dedicated fans.

It’s fantastic news for fans including myself, as I ranked “Everybody’s in LA” among the top shows of last year in my annual review. However, it’s quite unexpected that Wednesday’s premiere was not explanatory. For instance, the appearance of Saymo the delivery robot didn’t have any background provided. Frequent viewers who witnessed the transformation of this four-wheeled buddy into a full-fledged character during the spring may not have needed an introduction, but newcomers joining a global streamer’s major launch might have been puzzled. Mulaney joked that the name change was due to focus groups disliking LA, but nothing else about the show felt tailored for focus groups or aimed at mass appeal.

The show “Everybody’s Live” mirrors its five-person team as they dominate a significant portion of each episode with their unique and unconventional discussions. When not trimmed or streamlined, conversations like the one between actor Michael Keaton and personal finance columnist Jessica Roy on the topic of lending money to friends and family can stray off course. (Keaton’s narration of Jack Nicholson’s “$500 junkie buyout” strategy was somewhat muddled, but his impression was quite entertaining.) However, we were also entertained by folk singer Joan Baez recounting her accident involving a brand-new Tesla and an oak tree, which brought laughter to the in-studio audience.

What made “Everybody’s in LA” intriguing was its ability to capitalize on the decline of traditional talk shows. Instead of adhering to the daily news cycle or relying on celebrities’ promotional appearances, the show chose to experiment with and subvert the genre’s existing trends, viewing it as a style rather than a set of rules to follow. “Everybody’s Live” continues to embody this spirit of unpredictability and exploration, carrying forward the risks that come along with such an approach. Unlike its predecessor, which had a less structured schedule, “Everybody’s in LA” avoids being a Netflix equivalent of shows like “Late Night” or “The Tonight Show.

Shifting attention from Los Angeles’ complexities to broader topics has its growing pains. I didn’t experience the same captivating interest in Mulaney’s financial etiquette lessons as I did about the O.J. Simpson case, for instance. Conversely, it would be challenging to incorporate a Willy Loman discussion into a TV program centered on Southern California. The sketch prior to Cypress Hill’s closing performance was the hour’s high point, embodying the potential of petty preoccupations given space in a choir of suited actors reciting a monologue together.

As ‘Everybody’s Live’ transitions into its new broadcast routine, it’s natural to expect some minor glitches due to the show’s real-time interaction with live callers and spontaneous hosting style. On a related note, I have some questions about the Redondo Beach trainer’s advanced workout regimen. Despite John Mulaney’s self-effacing humor, he shows an undeniable resilience in resuming his show almost a year after its last episode. Unlike any other TV show, ‘Everybody’s Live’, formerly known as ‘Everybody’s in LA’, operates at its unique wavelength. It’s up to us to synchronize with it.

Read More

2025-03-13 07:46