Every Medical Professional on The Pitt, Ranked

by

Oh boy, what a challenging day it’s been for this film enthusiast! I’m not referring to the tireless heroes on “The Pitt,” the medical professionals who have just battled through a 15-hour shift from hell, but rather myself, tasked with ranking these extraordinary characters. It seems like an insurmountable task, and yes, I’ve shed a few tears over it! Is there any TV drama with such a vast ensemble that consistently delivers captivating characters? I can’t say for sure, but I do know that every employee at the Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center holds a special place in my heart. Even the ones that make me furious, I can’t help but adore. But what makes each character on this gripping portrayal of an underfunded emergency department so compelling? Which one are we most eager to watch each week? Who is the most relatable and why? That’s exactly what we’re going to explore here. So, consider this ranking not as a worst-to-best list but more of a least-favorite-to-most-favorite list. Among all the beloved characters on “The Pitt,” who deserves the title of the most beloved?

28.
Gloria (Michael Hyatt), Chief Medical Officer

Even though I usually admire a woman who confidently wears a pink blazer, if a TV character requires multiple reminders within one season about reading the room, I find it hard to continue my interest in them.

27.
Dr. Eileen Shamsi (Deepti Gupta), Surgical Attending

Discussing the incident, this woman had the popular saying “read the room” shouted at her, surprisingly during a mass-casualty event! And who might have done the shouting? None other than her 20-year-old daughter, Victoria, who is still a medical student. Dr. Shamsi appears competent in her profession – people are eager to be on her good side – yet, Victoria exhibits bratty behavior half of the time. However, we should consider some leniency for Dr. Shamsi given the circumstances. But I have an inkling that much of Victoria’s impertinence could stem from her upbringing, which means it’s a balanced situation overall.

26.
Dr. Mehta (Kinner Shah), Stroke Neurologist

Puns should be banned from all medical settings at all times!!

25.
The Med Techs (Stephen Hart, Jermaine Williams, Matt Mercurio)

Balancing their job responsibilities with managing a triple-tier betting system? We applaud those who juggle multiple tasks, though it appears they’ve got a rather abbreviated workday today, which is surprising!

24.
Kim (Ambar Martinez), Nurse

She’s incredibly kind towards Whitaker even when the Kraken soils him, yet her presence seems elusive during most of the shift. Could it be that she spends the entire day replenishing the scrubs dispenser? A true enigma she is!

23.
Dr. Yolanda Garcia (Alexandra Metz), Surgical Resident

I admire a woman who can endure a painful foot injury while continuing her work, and it’s heartening to see that she supports her colleagues even if there’s a friendly rivalry between them. However, the persistent flirting with an intern throughout the day seems unusual. Is she perhaps under the impression that this behavior is acceptable in a professional setting, as might be portrayed on Grey’s Anatomy?

22.
Kiara Alfaro (Krystel Mcneil), Social Worker

Is it possible to rephrase this statement in a more conversational manner: In the emergency department, Kiara is known for her soothing demeanor, but sometimes she comes across as too rigid with rules, not suggesting alternatives often enough. Could you help her find a bit more urgency in her actions, making her less of a problem and more part of the solution?

21.
Jesse (Ned Brower), Nurse

Could you provide additional details about the second season of “The Pitt“. Specifically, I’m interested in learning more about the tall, reserved character who isn’t afraid to show vulnerability. This man stands as tall as a tree, but his emotions can be as delicate as leaves swaying in the wind. He sheds tears during Robby’s farewell speech, which reveals a side of him that is usually guarded. Could you share the precise height of this intriguing character?

20.
Donnie (Brandon Mendez Homer), Nurse

To be honest, after watching 15 episodes, I had to check this character’s name, which isn’t usually a good indicator of leaving a lasting impact in a group cast. However, the individual who shows up with a cooler for post-work park beers immediately wins my affection.

19.
Ahmad (Johnath David), Security Guard

In spite of my limited knowledge about the security guard, when Ahmad discreetly positioned himself close to Dana following her post-patient altercation and took a quiet stance, I couldn’t help but think, “He has won my admiration for eternity.

18.
Lupe (Tracy Vilar), Desk Clerk

On this show, Lupe seems to have one of the toughest roles – she’s constantly dealing with the strange individuals seated in front of her. The thin barrier of the screen in front of her is no match for some of the challenges I can see she faces, that much is clear. I find myself fascinated by the transformation from strict and formal at the reception to compassionate and understanding during emergencies, so I’m eagerly awaiting her next shift.

17.
Victoria Javadi (Shabana Azeez), Third-Year Med Student

Experiencing the challenge of being a 20-year-old caregiver in critical situations! Javadi experiences her first patient encounter with a fainting spell, marking a rocky beginning to her initial day on her emergency medicine rotation. Fortunately, no one compares her to Doogie Howser, which is quite a relief. Javadi may be inexperienced and green, but her determination makes her an endearing character, especially when she displays her quick thinking and resourcefulness during the shift. Notable moments include assisting her transgender patient with their chart, diagnosing her mother’s Crohn’s disease, and performing DIY chest tubes. Despite needing significant growth, resolving personal issues related to her mother, and struggling with basic social interactions, I must admit that she often makes me cringe. However, I admire her tenacity and hope she continues to improve. In spite of my reservations, I wish her the best!

16.
Esme (Misha Gonz-Cirkl), Custodial Worker

Witnessing Esme approach Robby amidst the mass casualty situation, to check on his wellbeing and offer him some food, profoundly impacted me as a person.

15.
Dr. Emery Walsh (Tedra Millan), Surgeon

A clever way for an actor to make a strong impact in just a few remaining episodes is by introducing Walsh. Remarkably, she turns out to be a perfect fit as the lead surgeon during critical mass casualty situations. Despite her tough demeanor, typical of many surgeons, she also grasps that adaptability and flexibility might be required in such high-pressure scenarios. She may not be fond of using EZ-IOs for drilling burr holes, but she recognizes the gravity of the situation. Furthermore, the chemistry between Walsh and Abbot is intriguing, and I can’t help but feel that a touch of romance (just a tiny smooch) could add a delightful layer to the series in the future – purely for dramatic relief or whatever! No need to make a fuss about it!!

14.
Dr. Frank Langdon (Patrick Ball), Senior Resident

Frank Langdon, I must admit I had high hopes for you! Many of us were cheering you on! However, it’s essential we address some concerns. The goodwill towards you, despite your history of deceit and betrayal, largely stems from your heartwarming bond with Dr. King and your impressive medical skills. That said, even Mel King, who is remarkable in her own right, has limitations.

Regrettably, by the end of the season, you squandered much of this goodwill when, instead of acknowledging your mistakes after being confronted about your drug problem and theft, you chose to respond with defensiveness and unkindness. Grow up, Frank! If you want to improve and climb higher on this list, maturity is key.

13.
Dr. Trinity Santos (Isa Briones), Intern

Ah, Trinity Santos, here we are. Just a short while ago, I would’ve swiftly placed Santos towards the bottom of my list, given her abrasive demeanor. However, after considering her background and the reasons behind her arrogance and playful taunts, it becomes clearer. Her actions are understandable, but what truly grates on me is her selective approach to cases – choosing only those she perceives as ‘cool’ or ‘interesting.’ Who does she think she is, dismissing a case during a critical mass-shooting event? Ugh! Apologies for the intensity of my feelings.

Fortunately, The Pitt provides some moments that soften her image; yes, speaking out about Langdon was a bold move (though not entirely selfless, let’s be honest), but it’s her actions in the finale that truly won me over more than I anticipated. Her genuine compassion towards Max, the man who attempted suicide, and her generous offer to let a financially strapped Whitaker stay with her for free – these moments prove that she does possess a heart.

Trinity Santos is complex, prickly, and often irritating, but there’s no denying that I find myself intrigued every time she enters the scene.

12.
Mateo (Jalen Thomas Brooks), Nurse

In my personal opinion, Mateo’s performances on this show are nothing short of remarkable. Here’s a snapshot of what makes him stand out:

He displays an impressive balance of firmness and calmness when dealing with Doug Driscoll’s racially insensitive behavior. His interactions with Javadi, where he gracefully accepts her affection, are heartwarming to watch.

One of the most intriguing aspects about Mateo is his secret life as a babysitter, which adds an unexpected layer to his character. His dimples certainly don’t hurt either!

Mateo has a unique ability to make McKay’s ex, Chad, green with envy just by being himself. And let’s not forget about the headband – it’s become a signature part of his on-screen persona.

But perhaps one of Mateo’s most memorable moments comes when he helps Javadi perform a chest-tube MacGyver maneuver, showcasing both his intelligence and resourcefulness. Lastly, the way he says, “You’re a rockstar, Victoria,” leaves me speechless – it’s a moment that feels truly life-changing.

11.
Dr. John Shen (Ken Kirby), ED Attending

As a follower, I find myself drawn to Dr. Shen more than I expected, appreciating the intriguing blend of casual demeanor and exceptional skills in critical situations. It’s almost like watching a master orchestrate human carnage while secretly excelling at crisis management in triage.

Interestingly, The Pitt has cleverly introduced a fresh attending physician into their cast, one who is still learning the ropes and making resident-like mistakes. This move serves as a valuable reminder that every doctor, regardless of their title, continues to learn and grow in their profession.

10.
Dennis Whitaker (Gerran Howell), Fourth-Year Med Student/Rat King

It’s clear that everyone’s shift was tough, but let us not forget that Whitaker’s day was difficult long before the PittFest incident. He endured a series of unpleasant events, such as having to change scrubs frequently due to various encounters with bodily fluids, including being urinated on. Moreover, early in his shift, he experienced a loss when Mr. Milton died from an unknown heart condition while being transported down the hallway on a gurney. This was hard for him to move past, but Whitaker’s resilience and determination are commendable. His compassionate yet firm approach when dealing with Robby during a breakdown shows maturity beyond his years. Additionally, we discover that Whitaker unwinds from a challenging day by having a dance party in the shower. I genuinely want the best for this young man due to all these reasons, but honestly, it was his snap of that rat’s neck with his bare hands that truly captured my attention.

9.
Dr. Parker Ellis (Ayesha Harris), Senior Resident

Night Shift” with more Ellis and Shen? Bring it on, series!

8.
Dr. Jack Abbot (Shawn Hatosy), ED Attending

He’s a war veteran dealing with long-term existential struggles, who is deeply attuned to the emotional wellbeing of his friends, freely discusses his therapy sessions, and even attaches blood bags to his leg for donations while working on trauma cases. Yes, I am smitten by him.

7.
Dr. Cassie McKay (Fiona Dourif), Second-Year Resident

McKay stands out among the competent doctors in this series, not just for her efficiency as an ED resident, but also for her boldness. She’s the only one who would drill a hole into their ankle monitor and scold a 25-year-old for wearing a “Bonus Mom” T-shirt, which makes her unique and endearing to us.

6.
Dr. Samira Mohan (Supriya Ganesh), Third-Year Resident

It took some time for Mohan to become appealing, but now she’s moved up to being one of those doctors from The Pitt I’d be happy to meet in person. She exudes confidence without coming off as arrogant. She is a composed and fair educator. Instead of just seeing her patients as symptoms, she treats them as complete individuals. Unlike some others, she doesn’t crumble under embarrassment when someone yells “Slo-Mo No Mo!” at her foolishly. It’s this last trait that makes me trust in her competence.

5.
Perlah (Amielynn Abellera) and Princess (Kristin Villanueva), Nurses

It’s impossible for me to pick one of these women over the other; their friendship is priceless. Their chatter about colleagues in different languages is remarkable. Princess’s nostalgic tales of having an encounter under a picnic blanket with a man resembling Dave Navarro at Lollapalooza are captivating. Perlah’s bravery when diving on a patient in the ER, even with the potential danger of a gun being present, leaves me questioning if tears are being cut nearby. These two women are truly shining stars, and I could never decide between them.

4.
Dr. Heather Collins (Tracy Ifeachor), Senior Resident

Every young resident ought to strive to mimic Heather Collins’s exemplary approach (and many have been doing so successfully!). She embodies the ideal balance of compassionate and understanding alongside firm and unyielding, a unique blend that says “I have no time for your nonsense.” Her devotion to protocols never wavers, yet she consistently finds creative ways to ensure her patients receive the best care. (Her handling of her abortion patient is a testament to this.)

Collins possesses a captivating, paradoxical essence at her heart, and although she was missed in the last few episodes, no one deserves a relaxing bath, a glass of wine, and postponing all calls until tomorrow more than her. So go for it!

3.
Dr. Melissa King (Taylor Dearden), Second-Year Resident

Melissa King is exceptional and the Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center is fortunate to have her. Every moment featuring King in season one stands out as a highlight. It seems that only Robby truly appreciates her worth, but I, like many others, am grateful she’s part of the team. Here’s hoping Melissa King continues to shine and remains safe and protected for years to come.

2.
Dr. Michael “Robby” Robinavitch (Noah Wyle), ER Attending

1. Initially, it’s hard to believe the name of this character is Michael.
2. Moreover, given the series’ impressive portrayal of intense, unyielding, and authentic medical narratives, you wouldn’t expect an intricate, multifaceted character on top of that, right? Yet, here we have Dr. Robby. It could have been simple to make him an infallible saint or arrogant, but he is neither. Instead, he is a compassionate and skilled doctor doing his best. He’s not always perfect in his decisions — taking the measles father into the morgue to prove a point in the finale was quite a move! — and he grapples with personal issues, which makes him easy to support. The fact that he knows multiple ways to intubate someone doesn’t hurt his appeal (we appreciate a man who excels at his job). Having a protagonist with such intricate layers sets The Pitt apart from other medical shows. Although the medical aspects are fantastic, watching Robby hold himself together during this grueling shift has been just as captivating.

1.
Dana Evans (Katherine LaNasa), Charge Nurse

As a devoted fan, I’d liken Dana Evans to Wonder Woman, but that comparison falls short – her most remarkable quality is her undeniable humanity. She embodies the essence of an ordinary person, yet extraordinary in her understanding and empathy towards others. Her keen insight into people’s needs and timely assistance have proven invaluable, be it navigating the Kraken crisis or comforting a colleague in distress.

However, I believe her true prowess lies in fostering a harmonious work environment, both logistically and emotionally. She senses when her peers require firm guidance or simply a shoulder to cry on during tough times. Her ability to balance pressure and understanding is unparalleled – knowing when to push and when to provide space for reflection.

Dana’s backbone is unyielding, evident in her swift intervention during conflicts and her commanding presence that makes even the most assertive phrases sound intimidating in 2025. Yet, beneath this tough exterior lies a heart of gold. It’s this blend of strength and compassion that leaves us stunned when she experiences adversity herself.

When Robby suggests the hospital couldn’t function without her, he speaks the truth. Her impact on the team is immeasurable – yet, it’s her contemplation of leaving at season’s end that leaves viewers torn between heartbreak and triumph. It’s a testament to her selflessness and dedication to her well-being, even if it means stepping away for a while. (Though we hope she stays!)

What a remarkable woman Dana is, both on screen and as a character. Nurses like her deserve recognition and compensation that reflects their invaluable contributions to society.

Read More

2025-04-12 00:56