‘Dreams in Nightmares’ Review: A Subversive Take on the Road Movie

As a film critic with a background in sociology and a lifelong passion for exploring the intersections of identity, culture, and art, I found “Dreams In Nightmares” to be an absolute gem. Shatara Michelle Ford’s sophomore film is not just a road trip movie; it’s a poetic exploration of what it means to be Black, queer, and striving for creative fulfillment in contemporary America.


“Dreams In Nightmares” initially seems like a familiar tale: Three companions embark on a quest to find their fourth member, uncovering hidden truths about themselves along the way. One character yearns for the classic American road trip experience. However, as viewers prepare for a story that appears routine, Shatara Michelle Ford’s second film proves to be far more than expected. It subtly defies these assumptions to offer something more profound and poetic instead.”

Two individuals, Denée Benton (a university professor) and Sasha Compère (a business consultant), both recently out of work, find solace in each other’s company as they navigate the challenges of unemployment. They reunite with their old college friend Lauren (Dezi Bing), a poet who juggles various jobs to stay afloat, on an adventure to locate their missing companion Kel (Mars Storm Rucker). This quartet, forged over a decade ago in university, is bonded by a shared passion for art and a collective aspiration for creative living. Despite their diverse circumstances – single, in committed relationships, or dealing with strained partnerships – they all identify as queer, though the film subtly emphasizes this aspect without making it the central focus. Their lives are intricate, encompassing various aspects of love and relationships, while their identities transcend traditional gender roles and sexual orientations, reflecting a wide spectrum of human desire.

As a movie enthusiast, I’d say that when creating these characters, Ford delves deep into the experiences of being Black and queer in today’s America. Unlike some films that shout their political messages or rely on complicated storylines, “Dreams in Nightmares” is fundamentally a political piece. The danger these characters face isn’t just a plot device; it stems from societal perceptions and self-presentation. Yet, Ford skillfully avoids turning this into a contrived narrative element. Instead, the film defies expectations by showcasing its characters living, conversing, eating, flourishing, loving, and expressing their intimacy in a way that feels natural and unforced.

As a film enthusiast who has grown up watching American cinema and witnessing the often stereotypical portrayal of Black people on screen, I find Ford’s work to be a breath of fresh air. Their writing and direction exude an abundance of compassion towards every character, even those depicted as objects of mockery are granted moments of grace. While some relationships may seem too idealistic to be realistic, they effectively serve as mirrors reflecting the aspirational potential within this narrative. Ford’s portrayals are magnanimous yet keenly attuned to the familial and societal structures that persistently threaten these characters’ joy. To counterbalance this idealism, it is essential for such contrasts to exist in our stories.

I’m drawn to Benton’s understated yet emotionally profound portrayal in the film, where her facial expressions, though seldom moving, speak volumes. For significant portions of the screen time, she’s the sole focus, capturing a myriad of emotions – from anxious phone calls, flirtatious bar encounters to awkward dinner table moments. As the practical Tasha, Compère masterfully balances comedy and sheer desperation, while Rucker, in stark contrast, infuses Kel – the dreamy, flighty member of our quartet – with vibrant personality and heartwarming presence. Even in a minor role, Jasmin Savoy Brown’s character is a whirlwind threatening to disrupt everyone’s lives. Despite her cluelessness, Brown delivers her lines with precision and uproarious humor.

The heartfelt script of the movie shines even brighter due to Ludovica Isidor’s brilliant cinematography, and Ford’s directing surpasses their initial work “Test Pattern.” The scale is broader, the pace more deliberate yet self-assured. This filmmaker clearly has mastery over their art, compelling viewers to sync with their beat. Powerful music expresses a sense of urgency, while leisurely camera movements emphasize intricate details within the shot – techniques that are predictable but still impactful. Less traditionally, scenes featuring actors gazing straight into the lens and surreal interludes create a dreamlike atmosphere, making “Dreams in Nightmares” an extraordinary artistic journey.

In the end, this movie serves as a guide for leading a rich and satisfying life – one filled with creativity, artistry, strong friendships, and loving family ties. While it acknowledges that such a life might seem unattainable or dreamlike, it still presents it as something achievable through sincerity. It may be challenging to emulate in reality, but watching it unfold on the big screen is truly inspiring.

Read More

2024-08-05 20:46