Did We Learn Anything in Hulu’s Amanda Knox Series?

by

Hulu’s eight-part documentary series The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox tells the story of Amanda Knox’s experience being accused in the 2007 murder of her 20-year-old British roommate, as seen through her own perspective. Actress Grace Van Patten portrays Knox, even wearing blue contact lenses to resemble her, and the series begins before Knox went to Italy for a study abroad program. The series, which is executive produced by Knox herself and produced by Monica Lewinsky, highlights how inexperienced Knox was at the time, and how severely she was treated by the media and the public in Italy.

The case is well-known due to its sensational details: On November 1, 2007, Meredith Kercher, a 21-year-old student from Leeds, England, was found dead in the apartment she shared with others. Her roommate, Amanda Knox, became suspicious when she returned home on November 2 after spending the night with her boyfriend, Raffaele Sollecito, who was a local Italian. When she arrived, she saw blood stains, a broken window, and Kercher’s room was locked. Thinking it might just be a burglary, she contacted the police, who discovered Kercher’s body and a disturbing crime scene. The recent Hulu series, which concluded on October 1, presents the story from Knox’s viewpoint, even using elements of magical realism to illustrate how surreal those years were for her. Initially, both Sollecito and Knox were found guilty of involvement in the murder and received a 25-year prison sentence. However, after serving only four years, their convictions were overturned, and they were released.

As a fan, I thought it was fascinating how the series, even though it stuck to the facts, really laid out a step-by-step guide of what *not* to do if you’re being questioned in a country where you don’t speak the language well. It clearly showed how easily being treated as a witness can turn into being seen as a suspect. Everything happened so fast for her – the show really highlighted how she didn’t recognize the warning signs and didn’t push to get a lawyer, contact the U.S. Consulate for help, or even just talk to her family. Those simple requests could have completely changed everything! Throughout the season, the show pointed out all the mistakes made in Knox’s investigation, and it felt like a really clear warning of what not to do. Here’s a breakdown of everything I took away from Knox’s story.

Amanda Knox’s lovey-dovey behavior did not translate well.

The closeness between Knox and Sollecito – both at the crime scene and later at the police station – seemed strange to investigators and friends of Kercher. Police asked Knox and Sollecito, who had only met eight days prior, to separate after seeing them cuddling in the waiting room. Knox stated that Kercher’s British friends told police they felt uneasy around her. After questioning Knox, investigators found it odd that she went back to the group house after spending the night at Sollecito’s and showering, even after she noticed blood drops in the bathroom and on the bath mat. According to Knox, Kercher’s British friends also told police that she “brought a lot of men home.” They also mentioned finding a vibrator among her belongings, which Knox explained was a gag gift from a friend before she left for Italy – a going-away present.

Knox realized too late that she was actually a suspect.

So, a couple of days after Meredith Kercher’s death, I learned that Amanda Knox’s mother spoke to her, and they both picked up on this really strange clicking sound during the call. It’s unsettling, to say the least. And the pressure on Knox was immense – she’d already spent 14 hours being questioned the day after the murder, but they brought her back in. She told them she was completely wiped out and hadn’t gotten any sleep. Then, things got even stranger. The police took her back to the crime scene and asked her to open the kitchen drawer where the knives were kept, asking if anything was missing. She apparently became incredibly distressed, starting to cry and even hitting herself on the head, which, understandably, the police found very suspicious. It just felt like a really intense and bizarre situation to witness, even just reading about it. It’s a detail that really stuck with me, and raises so many questions about the way the investigation was handled. You can find more details here.

One lie ruined her credibility.

A roommate asked Knox to conceal the fact that they used marijuana at their home. When Knox told police she hadn’t used marijuana, they accused her of being dishonest.

Under extreme interrogation pressure, Knox confessed to being complicit.

As a real cinema devotee, I’ve been following the Amanda Knox case for years, and it’s always struck me how flawed that initial police interview was. It’s shocking to think her first questioning happened without a translator – so much of what she said seemed to get twisted around. She’s stated there were six officers in the room, just relentlessly questioning her, and she couldn’t properly communicate. It gets even worse – her mother actually called during the interrogation, but the police just took the phone away from her! When a translator finally *did* arrive, she immediately asked if she needed a lawyer, but the officers just kept grilling her, completely ignoring her request. It’s a truly disturbing account of how things unfolded.

Amanda Knox asked to use the restroom, but the police told her she had to hand over her phone first. As soon as they had it, they began searching for clues. They found a text message to her employer, Patrick Lumumba, saying, “See you later, have a good evening,” and wrongly assumed this meant she was planning to meet him on the night of the murder. Knox attempted to explain that this was a common American expression and didn’t imply an actual meeting. The police claimed that Sollecito had destroyed her alibi, accused her of meeting with Lumumba, and even physically assaulted her. Knox stated that one of the officers eventually cracked under the strain and she, under duress, said, “It was Patrick.”

… And then she tried to take it back.

She attempted to retract her statement, but the damage was already done. She requested a pen and paper to write a new account of what actually occurred. However, the police had already concluded the investigation and issued arrest warrants for three individuals: Knox, Sollecito, and Lumumba. It was too late to change the narrative.

Read More

2025-10-04 01:55