Did Ron Secretly Use Dark Magic to Make Hermione Love Him? This Harry Potter Theory Shocks Fans

by

As a devoted fan of the Harry Potter series, I’ve found myself in a bit of a discussion drought ever since the movies wrapped up in 2011. The Fantastic Beasts films, unfortunately, didn’t live up to our expectations, leaving audiences and critics alike feeling let down. This led to dwindling interest and a barrage of criticism towards the franchise. The Cursed Child play was another attempt at keeping conversations going, but its plot inconsistencies and lack of a widespread theatrical adaptation meant that only those who caught it on Broadway, in London, or at select theaters worldwide could truly engage with it. For many of us, it felt like the Wizarding World had come to an end when Harry Potter (Daniel Radcliffe) sent Albus Severus Potter (Arthur Bowen) off to Hogwarts for his first year.

The Harry Potter franchise is poised for a significant comeback, courtesy of an upcoming TV reboot on HBO. This new adaptation aims to immerse viewers in the world of Harry Potter with a greater adherence to the original books. However, the project has stirred controversy due to J.K. Rowling’s public statements about the LGBTQ+ community, sparking criticism since its announcement. Both the upcoming show and the previous movie series have faced similar backlash. Numerous elements of the franchise have been scrutinized, leading to a controversial theory suggesting a darker dynamic between Ron and Hermione.

Ron and Hermione Had a Turbulent Relationship

The Movies Were Not Wholly Faithful

Among the trio – Ron Weasley (portrayed by Rupert Grint) and Hermione Granger (played by Emma Watson) – their relationship was particularly intricate. Initially, they weren’t on good terms because Ron frequently teased Hermione for her bold intelligence and bossy demeanor during the events of “Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone” (2001). Hermione didn’t shy away from retaliating with a sharp remark, but this often escalated tensions significantly. Harry, who was grappling with his own challenges, often found himself playing peacekeeper as his friends frequently clashed in almost every movie.

As the Yule Ball approached, tensions escalated between Hermione and Ron when he openly bullying her. Despite Hermione choosing to dance with Viktor Krum, Ron persistently criticized their relationship, claiming that Krum was merely taking advantage of Hermione. His harsh words left her in tears on the staircase, lamenting that Ron had “ruined everything” for her. This heartbreaking moment should have been a memorable highlight of Hermione’s year, but Ron ensured it would forever be tainted. He treated Hermione as an unwanted commodity, only good enough to serve as a backup option, and this was what made his behavior so painful.

In a manner less formal yet clear, here’s how I would rephrase: The duo shared a rocky bond that extended beyond their initial days and the tumult of the Tri-Wizard Tournament. He teased her skills in “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix” (2007), suggesting that he had “allowed” Hermione to outshine him due to “good manners”. Their conversations were often contentious, yet they lacked the charm typical of romantic sparring. Instead, they seemed more preoccupied with quarrels than genuine bonding moments, and even their rare instances of connection frequently resulted in Hermione crying. This pattern is hardly ideal for fostering a loving, secure relationship, despite culminating in matrimony in the end. The novels, however, portrayed their relationship growth more convincingly, whereas the movies fell short in accurately adapting this dynamic.

A Dark Theory Believes That Ron Cursed Hermione

It Would Explain Everything

Interpreting the dynamics of their relationship can be quite challenging due to its stormy character, but one fan theory proposes an intriguing explanation for why Hermione found herself drawn to Ron. This theory suggests that Hermione never truly fell in love with Ron; instead, she was unwittingly manipulated by a truly malicious plot. Since Ron was unable to persuade Hermione to be his girlfriend, he ultimately resorted to using the Imperius curse against his future partner. Specifically, he used this curse to compel Hermione to feel affection for him.

The Reddit user developed the theory upon observing that Ron effortlessly employed the Imperius curse while trying to silence Goblin Bogrod. He never faltered or appeared to exert himself while casting it. Remarkably, this was a spell he hadn’t had much chance to practice. It’s puzzling how quickly he adapted to it. Ron suggested that he picked up the spell from his father, Arthur Weasley, but given Arthur’s character, it’s doubtful he would teach such dark magic to his children. Keep in mind, Arthur is not the type of wizard who relies on dark magic, and he certainly wouldn’t pass it on to his own offspring.

In summary, it is suggested that Ron used a love-inducing curse on Hermione out of jealousy for her feelings towards Harry. To get back at Harry, he also took away potential girlfriends from him. This theory also implies that Ron, who was uncomfortable with the idea of Hermione being drawn to Harry, manipulated Hermione over time by casting the spell intermittently in the book “Order of the Phoenix.” While Hermione wasn’t entirely under the curse’s control, it is proposed that Ron occasionally used the spell to subtly and gradually affect her thoughts.

There Are Major Holes in the Dark Ron Theory

He Was Probably Just a Terrible Partner

The theory suggests that Ron could become one of the most despicable characters in the series, however, there are significant flaws in this concept. In truth, it’s unproven that continued use of the Imperius Curse causes lasting mental distortions within its victims. For example, Barty Crouch Jr., played by David Tennant, was subjected to the curse for extended periods, yet he never gave in to his father’s control.

Additionally, victims can recall the aftereffects of the curse once it’s lifted, so it seems illogical that Hermione Granger wouldn’t notice Ron’s deception. Given her exceptional intelligence, she should be able to identify the tell-tale signs of someone being under a spell quite easily.

1. Alternatively, there are less complicated ways to make someone fall in love against their will, such as casting an Unforgivable Curse. However, just because Ron behaved poorly towards Hermione in the movies, it doesn’t necessarily mean he is a dark wizard.

2. A significant theme in this universe is that loveless relationships can lead to disastrous outcomes, like Voldemort’s birth. But we don’t witness these consequences in their relationship, suggesting that there may be a genuine bond between them. This could mean that Hermione fell for Ron despite his flaws, which isn’t uncommon in real life.

3. While the idea of an evil Ron is intriguing, it seems unlikely that this theory holds much validity.

Read More

2025-05-09 05:58