Destiny 2 Lore Disagreements: A Deep Dive into Fan Frustrations

As a seasoned gamer with over two decades under my belt, I can confidently say that Destiny 2 has been a rollercoaster of emotions for me. The game’s lore has always been its crown jewel, and it’s disheartening to see certain decisions that have left me scratching my head.

In the expansive world of Destiny 2, the narrative has been significantly influenced by its rich lore since day one. A recent post by user renathena on a popular forum sparked an engaging conversation among fans regarding their opinions about specific lore choices. The topic, “What’s a lore decision you still can’t get over?”, centered around the controversial choice of making Rasputin the sole Warmind stationed on Mars, and limiting the potential for characters like Charlemagne to become fully-realized Warminds. This sparked a wave of nostalgic reminiscing about missed opportunities, with the community expressing a mix of admiration for the game’s story and frustration over how certain plotlines have developed. Fans shared their feelings on various aspects of the lore, demonstrating both their passion for the game’s narrative and their dissatisfaction with certain developments.

What’s a lore decision you disagree with to this day?
byu/renathena inDestinyTheGame

Summary

Fans express disappointment over the decision to make only Rasputin the Warmind.
Several users pointed out significant lore inconsistencies that have marred character arcs.
The Pyramids’ underuse and subsequent narrative changes emerged as a sore point for many players.
Overall, the discussion reflects a deep passion for Destiny 2 lore and a desire for more thoughtful storytelling.

Rasputin and the Warminds

As a dedicated Destiny fan, I can’t help but feel a mix of emotions when it comes to Rasputin, the sole Warmind given significant focus in our community. User Karew poignantly expressed my sentiments when he lamented, “Sagira was taken away off-screen through a blog post. Considering how much Osiris evolved afterward and all the references made to it, she deserved a more dignified farewell.” This sentiment echoes the disappointment that certain crucial story aspects seem to be overlooked or hastily resolved, leaving us, the fans, feeling shortchanged.

Character Arcs and Their Evolution

The discussion soon veered towards the contrasting outcomes of popular figures such as Brother Vance, and some users voiced their displeasure over this character’s alteration: “In Destiny 1, he was a mystical merchant symbolizing the legendary Warlock Osiris… But with the release of The Taken King expansion in Destiny 2, Vance became nothing more than a rambling fool.” This development underscores a broader issue among players regarding character authenticity. It’s not just about how characters appear, but how ongoing storylines can enrich the gaming experience. Although some fans are optimistic that future updates might restore these narratives, the nostalgia lingers as certain decisions have seemed hasty or mishandled. The feelings expressed towards these transformations underscore the deep emotional attachment the fanbase has towards these characters.

The Pyramids and Narrative Potential

During the conversation, it was criticized that the Pyramids were also a point of contention, as several participants expressed disappointment over their supposed lack of fulfilling their initial potential. Disastrous_Focus6180 echoed this sentiment, stating that “the pyramids being completely hollow and essentially non-threatening foes was the most significant disappointment.” The concept that these colossal structures were envisioned as formidable adversaries, only to become mere shadows in lore, was a major letdown. The potential narrative possibilities that the Pyramids could have offered is evident, particularly since they could have functioned as a portal for delving into deep-rooted lore about Darkness. Players like Lamprarian, on the other hand, underlined their dissatisfaction with the alteration of significant lore aspects, such as the veil being associated with the Darkness, which left them feeling unsatisfied with the ongoing narrative progression.

The Need for Consistency in Lore

The main idea emerging from this Reddit conversation centers on the importance of maintaining consistency and care in Destiny 2’s storyline, as fans are deeply invested in both the universe and its characters. As HotMachine9 put it, the reduction in diversity within the gameworld was disappointing: “The titan orders were removed, the fallen houses vanished… It’s a shame to see so much of the universe diminished.” This feeling of loss not only impacts players’ engagement with the game but also restricts the exciting potential stories that such a rich universe could tell. Consistency in storytelling gives players confidence that their experience is long-lasting and that they will continue to encounter captivating narratives.

Analyzing the feedback from the community shows the intricate layers and challenging aspects of Destiny 2’s storyline choices. Players’ intense debates demonstrate a strong yearning for the game to reach its fullest potential, as opposed to being swayed by less-than-satisfactory narrative decisions. Each disagreement also acts as a reminder to Bungie about the significance players place on the quality of Destiny 2’s storytelling. Essentially, fans are expressing their wish for their universe to be rich and complex, instead of veering towards simpler approaches that have sometimes emerged. Be it through compelling characters, intriguing plots, or attentive handling of existing lore, the Destiny 2 community remains optimistic about an evolving narrative with all its possible greatness.

2024-08-03 13:58