Dave Portnoy breaks pizza review rules with instant re-review

by

In a twist, the head honcho at Barstool Sports, Dave Portnoy, momentarily deviated from his established guidelines by reassessing a pizza following requests made during an initial critique.

For several years now, Dave Portnoy, the proprietor of Barstool Sports, has emerged as an internet authority on pizza critiques. His ‘One Bite’ video series, where he consumes far more than a single bite, have amassed billions of views and significantly impacted the success of numerous pizzerias.

Despite the fact that Portnoy might sometimes be lenient with certain rules, such as only taking one bite, he seldom rushes to re-evaluate an entire pizza so soon following a dissatisfying encounter.

Yet, while at Pizzeria Rustico in Boston, the head of Barstool disregarded the norms as his journey was unexpectedly halted by another patron.

Dave Portnoy instantly re-reviews pizza for first time

In the beginning of his critique, Portnoy pointed out that his pizza was waiting in a box for nearly ten minutes due to another customer pushing ahead in line, causing the staff to work frantically.

He initially stuck with the original pie and gave it a rating of 6.7. However, nearby shop owners who ran businesses next to the pizza shop encouraged him to give it another chance, suggesting he might have had an off day. “I believe you had a bad day,” remarked one employee from a neighboring store. “It’s not typically like that,” added another. “It is usually good, I’m just not sure.

After that incident, Portnoy decided to go back indoors and request another slice, disregarding his personal rule against immediate re-reviews. To his surprise, the pizza shop prepared a brand new pie for him instead. This led to a more favorable review, earning a score of 7.3/7.4. “I’ve become too kind, I’ve become too lenient,” remarked the head of Barstool, expressing some concern over his own behavior.

The repeated review greatly inconvenienced his security team, who warned that they would have to wait “for hours” if they granted a second opportunity to everyone else.

The second look-over really frustrated the security personnel, who threatened that they’d need to spend “hours” waiting if they decided to give another chance to everyone else.

He’s not primarily focused on repeating jobs, but everyone seems to adore him. He’s constantly hustling and moving around, it’s more than just satisfactory – think of it as a 7.3 or even a 7.4 pizza, he’s exceptional, ‘way better’.

Read More

2025-06-02 17:19