Talamasca: The Secret Order Recap: Guy’s Big Trauma

by

I was really enjoying the show again after the previous episode, but “The Puzzle Palace” feels like a letdown. Just after a thrilling sequence, it’s gone back to being a slow, dialogue-heavy drama with uninteresting characters spouting predictable lines. The music tries to tell me how to feel, but it doesn’t work. It’s like the show was behaving, then immediately reverted to frustrating habits. Honestly, as someone who’s recapping this, it’s really annoying!

This episode briefly recaptures the lighthearted tone of the previous one. Guy emerges from the car he used after encountering the Disembodied Leg Chamber and finds himself in Jasper’s surprisingly large parking garage. He’s immediately confronted by Jasper, who’s angry about the person who warned Guy about his predicament. Guy, genuinely surprised, is offended that Jasper would be upset with him. He dramatically accuses Jasper of using him, almost in tears at the thought of being manipulated by such an obviously villainous vampire. It makes me realize how wrong I was to suspect, back in episode three, that Guy might be playing a double game. Guy Anatole doesn’t bother with strategy; he simply says whatever’s on his mind and then gets upset when it doesn’t go his way.

Despite all this, Jasper doesn’t calm down. He jumps onto Guy and starts hitting him, and according to my notes, even begins mimicking sexual movements. Apparently, people on Tumblr (thanks, Olivia!) are interested in seeing this older character interact with the younger one physically, so some viewers might find this scene amusing. However, Jasper’s attempt to transform Guy into a vampire is interrupted when Doris dramatically arrives, wielding a makeshift flamethrower. She sets Jasper ablaze and speeds away with Guy.

Sadly, this leads to a very dull part of the episode. I’ve noticed a pattern with this show: despite hints of queerness – like the openly gay vampire in the first episode and the ambiguous behavior of William Fichtner’s character – it ultimately follows the formula of typical action shows. Basically, scenes with lots of men are filled with action, and the more muscular they are, the more intense it gets. But the moment a woman appears who Guy Anatole is interested in, the scene slows down to just dialogue. And this show, which relies heavily on tired clichés – making me wonder if AI writing tools are involved – isn’t very good at handling those slower, talk-heavy moments.

Even more concerning, Guy’s plan to leave the U.K. with Doris shows he clearly trusts her. This is probably a mistake for him, considering his track record of trusting the wrong people on the show. It also makes for frustrating viewing; whenever Guy trusts someone, he inevitably launches into a long, emotional explanation of his hidden feelings and backstory – something the show has been building towards for weeks.

Okay, so he did finally open up! It all started when he confronted Helen at work – a pretty awkward scene, honestly. I’ve pulled four lines from that conversation so you can see how intense it was. Seriously, try reading them as if Guy and Helen were really putting their all into it, like they were completely focused on delivering the perfect performance. I think you’ll get a feel for how well-written and acted the scene is.

“I need you. I need your help … and you’re going to give it to me.”

“There are bigger forces at play than you can possibly understand.”

“If you won’t help me, Helen … I’m dead.”

“She helped me … and now I’m gonna help her.”

After a moment of overwhelmed emotion, Helen agrees to help Guy reach a safe house. He and Doris plan to stay there for a few days before leaving the country. Bored at the safe house, they pass the time with obvious board games and sharing difficult stories from their pasts. Guy spends a long time recounting the day he believed his mother had died, and then reveals the complicated feelings he has now that he knows she’s still alive.

This segment of the episode was particularly frustrating. I often critique the Talamasca storyline, but it’s usually at least a recognizable imitation of other spy thrillers. While not original or clever, it generally understands the basic structure and purpose of its plot points. However, Guy’s backstory explanation fails even to meet the minimum requirements of a trauma plot. As Parul Sehgal put it, a traumatic backstory should at least be revealed to both the audience and the character hearing it. Guy doesn’t even manage that. He recounts a story that simply restates something we already knew from the beginning of the series, then shares vague glances with a character we barely know. It doesn’t offer any new information; it just needlessly extends the scene. It’s essentially filler, barely better than meaningless content.

This episode’s revelations fall flat for the same reason. The backstory about Helen and her twin – separated as children and involved in some large Talamasca project – doesn’t resonate because we haven’t been given a reason to care about Helen or understand what’s at stake. The supposed twist of Olive being Jasper’s mole feels unearned, as we only know her as a Talamasca employee who supposedly manages Guy, but we rarely see her do so. And Doris having the 752 feels meaningless since the show hasn’t bothered to develop her character or explain her motivations. Ultimately, you can’t build dramatic tension around characters we know nothing about. It simply doesn’t work.

“The Puzzle Palace” feels like a series of plot twists designed to impress, but ultimately fails to engage. It relies on predictable characters and vague performances, assuming viewers will be satisfied with simply recognizing the tropes of the spy genre. It’s not just insulting – it’s genuinely dull. The episode prioritizes the appearance of excitement over meaningful storytelling, character development, or any real sense of intrigue.

Observations of the Order

For the third time in a row, Guy Anatole has the most ‘typical CW Network’ line of the episode! He’ll be receiving a plaque in the mail for saying, while being questioned by Jasper about Doris, “Why do you care so much about some random person?”

The most unforgettable moment from Jasper in this episode was when he said, “I’ve been boppin’ around your porridge bowl all night.” Honestly, it was a terrible line – one of the worst things I’ve ever heard, and I suspect it will stick with me for a long time.

I haven’t spent much time discussing the scenes where a Scotland Yard investigator tries to unlock the flash drive Soledad was hiding. These scenes have a deliberately old-fashioned feel, showing computer hacking as a stream of orange numbers on the screen. My only suggestion would be to have fully committed to that retro aesthetic and used an older operating system like MS-DOS. Seeing a Microsoft Edge logo on the taskbar while watching a program that looks like it’s from the movie The Net (1995, directed by Irwin Winkler) felt jarring and broke the immersion.

Honestly, Guy’s accent is really off this season, and that’s saying a lot! It’s not just the usual little slips – he’s dropping his ‘r’s all over the place. It makes me wonder if he’s as burned out on Talamasca: The Secret Order as I am. And you know what? I totally get it if he is.

Read More

2025-11-17 05:55