Kevin Costner Reveals Why ‘Yellowstone’ Was a Soap Opera in Disguise

by

Yellowstone wasn’t just a highly-rated show – it was a cultural force that revived the Neo-Western genre in popular culture. From its 2018 to 2024 run, Taylor Sheridan’s epic series not only ruled cable television but also rekindled America’s fascination with ranch life, political intrigue, and frontier justice. It paved the way for numerous spin-offs, introduced a new generation to the Western style, and made the Dutton family into contemporary legends. Viewers were captivated by the Dutton clan and the complex network of love, deceit, and violence surrounding the defense of their empire.

In a 2025 interview with ET, I shared my perspective on Yellowstone – a show I was part of. Contrary to the gritty and grounded portrayal it offers, I saw it as borderline soap opera-esque. This might come as a surprise given its focus on land struggles and cattle drives, but there’s some truth to this label. The emotional turmoil that permeated the Dutton family’s world was, in my view, a significant part of what made Yellowstone strong. It wasn’t just about the genre aspects; it was about the messy, chaotic emotions that were at the heart of the story.

Kevin Costner Thinks Yellowstone Was “A Bit Of A Soap Opera”

The Dutton Family Drama Was As Intense As Any Daytime Soap

Kevin Costner didn’t mince words as he discussed the TV series “Yellowstone“, particularly focusing on its intense subtext. In a chat about the show’s enduring impact and his departure from portraying John Dutton, Costner offered an unexpectedly straightforward yet enlightening perspective on the mood of the successful Western production.

It’s contemporary cattle farming, and Yellowstone does an excellent job of portraying that. It can feel like a soap opera at times, though, with its dramatic twists and turns. Some might even say it could pass for a reality show about people who really should be behind bars.

In simpler terms, Kevin Costner’s comment about Yellowstone being like a soap opera isn’t meant to be negative – it’s more like him acknowledging how intense and dramatic the series has become over its five seasons. Although Yellowstone appears to be a realistic Neo-Western with horses, tools, and rugged scenery, the real substance of the storyline is filled with over-the-top drama.

In Yellowstone, there’s a mix of physical altercations, trust issues, hidden agreements, reappearing family members, concealed murders, and romantic entanglements – Yellowstone is brimming with the intricate storylines characteristic of a captivating soap opera. Before we even delve into Beth Dutton’s relentless revenge plots or Jamie Dutton’s (Wes Bentley) deepening identity struggles, the show already offers a compelling narrative.

At a particular viewpoint, Yellowstone seems remarkably similar to a prime-time soap opera such as Dallas, albeit with increased intensity and superior visual storytelling. Costner’s comment about the characters being destined for prison isn’t an exaggeration. The Dutton family spends a significant portion of the series navigating between legal and ethical boundaries, employing tactics like blackmail, under-the-table deals, and murder to preserve their property and heritage.

Although some viewers might consider the Dutton family as heroes, their methods were more akin to criminal organizations rather than noble ranching practices. Remarkably, this very aspect was what made the series so captivating. Taylor Sheridan’s writing brilliantly combined classic Western themes with intense family dramas, making the seemingly ordinary life of ranching brim with an almost unreal level of conflict and tension.

Kevin Costner’s character, John Dutton, portrayed a strong, patriarchal figure, yet he was also entangled in persistent personal turmoil, with a significant portion of it stemming from his own offspring. The volatile nature of these relationships and their frequent eruptions into either emotional or physical conflict align remarkably with the conventions of a soap opera, except this narrative unfolds against the backdrop of the wild west, as if on dusty cowboy boots.

Yellowstone Being A Soap Opera Is Why The Neo-Western Show Works

The Over-The-Top Drama Is What Made Yellowstone So Addictive

In simpler terms, Kevin Costner’s comment that “Yellowstone” is a “bit of a soap opera” actually highlights why the show became so popular. Although it’s primarily a Western and political thriller, people kept watching for the intense betrayals, heated arguments, and emotional breakdowns in relationships that seemed to happen almost every episode.

Yellowstone stands out due to its ability to amplify drama skillfully without veering into absurdity. The series navigates a delicate balance between raw authenticity and over-the-top storytelling, pulling it off effectively. Beth Dutton’s passionate speeches, Rip Wheeler’s brand of justice outside the law, and Jamie’s complex psychological struggles may seem exaggerated, but they fit perfectly in the ethically ambiguous, high-pressure world created by Yellowstone. In truth, these elements are what make the show’s characters so memorable.

Emotional instability is a common element in soap operas, and this is what made “Yellowstone” such an engaging Neo-Western. The Dutton family isn’t merely a group of cowboys; they are walking time bombs filled with trauma, pride, and heritage. Each decision they make sets off ripples that echo throughout the seasons. Taylor Sheridan’s genius lies in combining this volatile family dynamic with the grandeur of a frontier tale, resulting in a Western that is as much about emotional minefields as it is about physical territory.

Yellowstone didn’t merely transport viewers to a specific location; it offered them suspense, sorrow, retribution, and relief. And although this structure may seem reminiscent of popular shows like Dynasty or Knots Landing, Sheridan managed to make it feel new by embedding it within cowboy culture and political machinations. Kevin Costner experienced this contrast directly, and he was correct: Yellowstone might be the top Western series of the decade, but it also ranks among the best soap operas.

Read More

2025-07-05 13:28