Kevin Smith’s Dogma Returns to Theaters and Sparks New Controversy

Over three decades later, I find myself in awe of Kevin Smith’s enduring impact as a writer, director, and podcasting pioneer within pop culture. It’s no easy feat to maintain such notoriety, but with it comes the challenge of having audiences project their own preconceived ideas onto his work. However, films like “Dogma,” recently resurfacing in theaters after being tucked away due to complex rights issues, serve as a delightful exception. Featuring Ben Affleck and Matt Damon from the Goodwill Hunting era, this seemingly irreverent comedy is actually a profound exploration of faith, hope, and, most significantly, love.

Smith is commonly recognized as Silent Bob, the quiet character known for snootching and bootchin’ in “stoner comedies,” often alongside his partner Jay. This duo has become icons, with their appearances spanning various films, even extending to a cameo in Drake’s Degrassi reunion music video. Dogma was the first film where Smith and his co-star spent more time on screen than off. Although regular players like Affleck, Jason Lee, and other familiar “View Askew” actors are present, the cast also includes faces not commonly associated with Smith’s films, such as Salma Hayek, Alan Rickman, George Carlin, Chris Rock, and Linda Fiorentino. Drawing inspiration from his upbringing as a Catholic, the movie delves into the mythological foundations of the religion and the practical flaws in the people who maintained it for two millennia. Dogma garnered controversy due to its profane language and less-than-flattering portrayals of certain Catholic symbols. However, it also offers a deeply emotional story about humanity’s search for a benevolent God who loves us.

Dogma Isn’t Nearly as Controversial as Religious Groups Made It Seem in 1999

Kevin Smith’s Ode to Religious Faith Even Makes Atheists ‘Want to Believe’

One notable point about these religious films, such as “Dogma” and “The Last Temptation of Christ,” is the intense backlash they received from their intended audience due to their unconventional portrayals of divinity. Created by believers with a humanistic approach, they challenge traditional beliefs, although they do so respectfully, avoiding blatant heresy, especially in regards to Mary’s post-birth children with Joseph. The films can be seen as an invitation for Catholics to deepen their understanding and appreciation of their faith. This theme is encapsulated in a scene within “Dogma” that beautifully illustrates the complex relationship between the sacred and the profane.

Hayek embodies a Muse-like figure, not exactly an angelic being, but more of an abstract concept, who departed from Heaven to compose her own narratives, yet wound up working as an entertainer. Rock portrays Rufus, the 13th Apostle excluded from the Bible due to his ethnicity, who is Black. He confides in Fiorentino’s Bethany that Jesus valued concepts over religious systems because “an idea can be altered.” Carlin’s Cardinal Glick isn’t necessarily a wicked individual but rather a disillusioned clergyman who regards his role more like a PR agent than a spiritual guide. Each character with divine insights displays a harsh perspective on humanity but an idealized view of divinity. Even the fallen angels portrayed by Damon and Affleck express regret for losing the ability to sense “the divine presence.” In a society that’s lost trust in many institutions, .

This version aims to convey the essence of your original text while using simpler language and clearer sentence structures.

Interestingly, what causes the greatest debate in the movie ‘Dogma’ isn’t as sacrilegious as one might think. Instead of Jesus and Mary Magdalene’s child, Bethany is the last human with a blood relation to Christ through his siblings. The Catholic Church maintains that Mary remained a virgin throughout her life. However, as Rufus explains to Bethany in the film, this belief isn’t about faith but rather ‘naivety’. Despite challenging beliefs such as this, the movie champions aspects of faith that offer solace and direction to people.

The Cast Is an Intriguing Mix of Kevin Smith’s Regular Players and ‘New’ Faces

Dogma’s Performances Are Essential to Selling the Film’s Humor and Its Heart

Although Smith was instrumental in writing the screenplay and producing the film, when asked about his own acting abilities, he humbly admitted that he felt he lacked the talent. The movie “Dogma,” with its grand scale, imaginative fantasy genre, and blend of humor and emotion, serves as a compelling contradiction to this statement.

In their roles as Bartleby, a Watcher, and Loki, the Angel of Death, Affleck and Damon delivered earnest performances that were still laced with fun. Their final scenes poignantly depicted the anguish felt by the angels after their long exile, yet retained the characters’ menacing charm and humor. As Metatron, the voice of God, Rickman skillfully combined his wry, disenchanted style with moments of profound kindness and empathy. Jason Lee portrayed Azrael with an extravagant flair, but his argument that nonexistence would be preferable to the torment in Hell gave depth to the antagonistic plotline.

Beyond Rufus and Spiral, Chris Rock truly shone as an actor, especially in the role of Rufus. This unconventional character not only showcased Rock’s signature humor but also provided a solid foundation for some of the film’s most thought-provoking philosophical concepts. Rufus portrayed Jesus as both a friend and a divine figure, rather than “the Lord.” He effortlessly moved between scenes with profound celestial beings and those featuring Jason Mewes’s endearing, vulgar character. At that time, the growth of Jay’s screen presence seemed to risk his character’s comedic gimmick becoming overused. Looking back, it signifies a significant transition from Jay being an extreme caricature of Mewes to a character with genuine emotional depth and sincerity.

Linda Fiorentino played the central role as Bethany, who was given a character arc of the “Chosen One,” while simultaneously providing perspective for the audience. Bethany’s task involved asking probing questions that laid the groundwork for the story’s narrative and mythological background, making it more challenging than just delivering exposition. Fiorentino skillfully managed these scenes with a convincing display of doubt and near-palpable emotion, which made her reaction to discovering she was the Last Scion particularly poignant. Meanwhile, Bethany’s recounting of her mission to Bartleby in hysterical laughter added a touch of relatability and authenticity to the otherwise fantastical tale.

Dogma Is a Product of Its Time, but Kevin Smith’s Compassionate Side Is Clearer Today

Every Significant Character In the Movie Is Sympathetic In Surprising Ways

In contrast to the reception it received upon release, many believe that the movie “Dogma” should have garnered much better reviews. This could be due to preconceived notions or personal biases preventing critics from appreciating the film’s unique blend of irreverent humor and heartfelt exploration of religious themes. Given the unconventional origins of this interpretation of the Gospel, it might have been difficult for some viewers to reconcile these contrasting elements. Smith, as the director, was more experienced by this point in his career, guiding a seasoned cast. However, the script, one of his earliest works, retained an endearing naivety, evident in its humor and the yearning for spiritual enlightenment exhibited by the character Bethany throughout the film.

  • The original script was called God, but Smith changed the title because he felt it was inappropriate.
  • The first draft was 148 pages, and before Bethany the protagonist was a high school jock.
  • In the first draft, Bethany blew up the church to prevent the rogue angels from passing through the archway.

The term “Dogma” signifies something that may become outdated for some viewers over time. However, despite the possible incongruity with contemporary perspectives, its underlying intentions are always noble. For a film delving into religious themes, it refrains from passing judgment or adopting cynicism towards its characters. While some characters might be fallen angels or literal demons, the most morally questionable individuals in the entire movie are the board members at Mooby’s, a satirical representation of corporate culture. However, when Loki wreaks Old Testament-like vengeance on them, it is not a moment to rejoice.

In 2025, the themes of the film “Dogma” may hold greater significance due to their relevance. Despite Bethany’s mission being evidently intended to eliminate Bartleby and Loki, she resolutely rejected the notion. When God (portrayed by silent Alanis Morissette) ended Bartleby’s life, the movie portrayed it as an act of compassion rather than vengeance, and it was depicted as forgiving in nature. The film even hinted that Bartleby’s previous acts of harm were miraculously erased by God’s divine intervention. “Dogma” is a movie brimming with characters, both human and otherwise, who may be flawed, but it embraces them all with equal affection.

How Seeing Dogma on ‘The Resurrection Tour’ Enhanced the Experience for Audiences

Kevin Smith’s Film Tours Bring the Film Festival Experience to Places That Rarely Get It

Prior to the nationwide revival of Dogma in AMC theaters, some cities’ fans were granted early access to the movie alongside its director. In recent times, he has been personally conducting tours for his films. Following the show, he engages in a candid Q&A session, providing audiences with a film festival-like experience. Kevin Smith shares behind-the-scenes stories and insights about the filmmaking process, enriching the film’s narrative with real-world emotions. This event is valuable for those who are fans of Smith or simply interested in the art of filmmaking in general.

Kevin Smith’s ‘View Askew-niverse’ Films
Film TitleYear
Clerks1994
Mallrats1995
Chasing Amy1997
Dogma1999
Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back2001
Clerks II2006
Jay & Silent Bob’s Super-Groovy Cartoon Movie!2013
Jay and Silent Bob Reboot2019
Clerks III2022
Jay and Silent Bob Store WarsTBA
Unwritten Dogma sequelTBA

At a gathering in Pittsburgh, PA – where the film “Dogma” was produced – he reminisced about how his late dad introduced him to the humor of George Carlin. He elaborated on how the comedy icon stated that laughter is an instinctive reaction. This not only highlights why sharing these chuckles with his father held such significance, but it also illuminates why Smith devoted his career to creating opportunities for his audience to expose their true selves. Long after his dad passed on the gift of George Carlin’s comedy albums to him, Smith repaid that kindness by presenting the comedian to his parents.

When Disney acquired Miramax, it obtained a film that wasn’t part of their initial portfolio, as it was personally owned by Harvey Weinstein, a convicted abuser. For years, this movie has been referred to as “the devil’s movie” by Smith, due to its theme about God. However, Weinstein no longer has any connection to the film, allowing it to return to theaters. The current world atmosphere seems darker compared to 1999, making a film like “Dogma” potentially more impactful for audiences today. Watching it again on the big screen feels almost spiritual.

Dogma returns to AMC theaters on June 5, 2025, followed by new home media releases.

Read More

2025-06-05 06:08