Sarah Michelle Gellar Wants to Return to Scream!

by

If Sarah Michelle Gellar gets her way, the Scream series might welcome a high-profile comeback. Gellar has been quite active in the first half of 2025, causing a stir among millennial horror enthusiasts due to her confirmation of participation in a forthcoming Buffy the Vampire Slayer reboot. Although she is primarily recognized for vanquishing vampires, Sarah Michelle Gellar’s horror film resume includes roles beyond Buffy. For instance, she portrayed Cici Cooper, an early victim in the Scream franchise’s Ghostface killer, in 1997’s Scream 2.

Despite her character’s small part and her untimely demise in the series, Sarah Michelle Gellar has expressed her readiness for a comeback in Scream. In an interview with Entertainment Tonight, she stated this openly.

As a devoted fan, I’ve always dreamed of being part of the Scream franchise. Alas, it seemed like an unreachable goal – everyone else was being invited back, but not me. I kept hoping, believing that one day I would receive that coveted phone call. However, as the survivors from all the Scream movies keep reappearing, I can’t help but think, “Maybe they forgot to dial my number? I’m still here, patiently waiting for my chance.

What Sarah Michelle Gellar Wanting A Scream Return Means For The Franchise

Another Legend Scream Can Add To The List?

It’s clear that Sarah Michelle Gellar won’t be making a brief appearance in Scream 7 because she expressed a desire for the return of her character from Scream. Considering what happened to her character in Scream 2, this isn’t too unexpected. However, given her eagerness to bring Cici Cooper back to the silver screen, it seems she won’t have to wait much longer. Following the unexpected exit of Melissa Barrera and Jenna Ortega from Scream 7, the upcoming 2026 installment has gathered a number of familiar faces, including Neve Campbell, Courtney Cox, David Arquette, and Matthew Lillard.

Proposing Sarah Michelle Gellar for a role in Scream would be enticing under any circumstances, but given that Scream is currently emphasizing nostalgia and reviving iconic figures, it’s particularly appealing. If Cici were to return for a future Scream movie, it seems fitting that she’d have a more significant part. Interestingly, Scream 2 debuted the same year as Buffy the Vampire Slayer’s first season was aired, which means Sarah Michelle Gellar’s fame was still in its infancy. In the 2020s, Scream has the opportunity to make a larger and more impactful return with Cici Cooper.

Our Take On Sarah Michelle Gellar’s Potential Scream Return

Did Cici Cooper Actually Survive Scream 2?

Sarah Michelle Gellar has long been asked about potentially reprising her role in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, yet she recently talks about a Scream comeback without much initial prompting. It seems there’s genuine excitement, especially on her part, to jump back into the expanding Scream universe.

The main challenge, indeed, lies in finding a way to work around the sudden passing of Cici. Her character met a clear and definite end, suffering multiple stab wounds followed by being pushed off a balcony. Although there could be a slight chance that Cici got up, shook herself off, and staged her own death, altering those circumstances to imply that Cici miraculously survived might be pushing it too far, even for the creative team behind Scream.

Indeed, you hit the nail on the head with your observation about the creative ways modern Scream films bring back deceased characters. For instance, Skeet Ulrich’s Billy Loomis was seen in a vision, and Matthew Lillard’s Stu Macher, though not as definitive as Cici’s demise, met an ambiguous end in the first Scream. Yet, here we are, anticipating his return in Scream 7 – whether alive or deceased, through some mysterious means. It’s evident that the Scream franchise shouldn’t use death as a reason to delay Sarah Michelle Gellar’s much-deserved reappearance on screen.

Read More

2025-05-23 22:22