Neil DeGrasse Tyson Praises ‘The Island’: Scarlett Johansson’s Sci-Fi Gem

by

In 2005, when Michael Bay’s science fiction action film The Island was first released, it garnered a fairly neutral response from both the public and critics. Regrettably, it flopped at the box office (a failure Bay attributes to a suboptimal marketing strategy), despite the allure of stars like Scarlett Johansson and Ewan McGregor, as well as the direction of Michael Bay. Remarkably, this film managed to gain an unexpected supporter in none other than acclaimed astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson.

Known for speaking out against scientific inaccuracies in movies, Tyson has earned a reputation that many science fiction creators strive to meet. His influence extends beyond the screen and impacts how other professionals work – even Andy Weir, author of “The Martian,” admits he envisioned Tyson while writing his book. Despite appreciating the artistic freedom in Hollywood productions and enjoying a good tale, Tyson is still a strict critic. Therefore, if he praises a movie like “The Island” as a genre gem, it’s worth revisiting.

‘The Island’ Explores Identity and Morality

In the bleak future portrayed in ‘The Island’, I find myself as Lincoln Six Echo, alongside Scarlett Johansson as Jordan Two Delta, living within a secluded society that sprung up after Earth’s devastation, with the lone exception of a pristine island. This island is the sole destination for one fortunate resident each week, selected through a lottery system, to call home. However, my doubts soon start to creep in as I unearth hints of life beyond our encircling walls and experience enigmatic dreams that challenge the narrative we’ve been told.

Following the revelation that they were manufactured as clones for organ harvesting and medical experiments, Lincoln allies with Jordan in a bid to break free from confinement and hold accountable the perpetrators. A conflict ensues between two contrasting factions: one aiming to annihilate the clones, while the other is dedicated to their emancipation.

Reactions to ‘The Island’ Varied

The majority of unfavorable reviews for “The Island” focus on its excessive action scenes that some viewers find too exaggerated given the film’s thought-provoking premise about human morality. Despite this potential discrepancy, acclaimed critic Roger Ebert offered a more complimentary perspective, recognizing the strength of both action and drama while commending the performances of the actors. However, not everyone shared his positive view; other experts also expressed their opinions.

Why Neil deGrasse Tyson Loves ‘The Island’

Neil deGrasse Tyson may not delve deeply into the technical aspects of “The Island,” but he is a big admirer of the film. In an article for the LA Times discussing his preferred sci-fi films, he expressed that it was both thought-provoking and visually captivating. He described it as a unique portrayal of science being used to serve vanity, while also examining corporate greed, human identity, and free will. Tyson even compared it to a more extravagant relative of the 1997 film “Gattaca,” starring Ethan Hawke and Jude Law, which similarly investigates themes of identity, with a focus on genetic manipulation and how sophisticated technology could reshape human self-perception.

Among Tyson’s preferred science fiction films, such as “Back to the Future,” “2001: A Space Odyssey,” and “The Matrix,” it’s quite an accolade for “The Island” to be included. This film delves deeper into the implications of technology on society, human exploitation, and ethics compared to traditional science fiction tropes like aliens or time travel. Yet, it effectively combines elements of a captivating narrative, high-octane action typical of Hollywood, and skillfully crafted sci-fi. If Neil deGrasse Tyson endorses “The Island” as accurate, it’s undoubtedly a film deserving of your attention.

Read More

2025-05-09 05:05