Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree Review: Short of a screaming success

by

As a passionate gamer, I’ve always been captivated by the Metroidvania genre, with its unique blend of world exploration, tantalizing glimpses into unreachable realms, and demanding platforming and combat challenges. However, if you were to infuse this formula with Soulslike elements and ratchet up the difficulty significantly, you’d find yourself embarking on a merciless journey such as Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree. This game tests your mettle, with your tenacity being the sole source of your endurance.

In my opinion, Mandragora is a game that strives to captivate me with its hidden mysteries, yet the depth of exploration largely hinges on my persistence and tolerance for challenging boss battles, inconsistent platform levels, and a narrative that recedes into obscurity. It puts forth a valiant effort to impress, but some baffling design flaws keep it from reaching true greatness.

An Inviting World with a Story That Puts You to Sleep

One key strength of Mandragora lies in its eerie ambiance. Right from the get-go, it establishes a somber tone for a dark fantasy odyssey brimming with castles, catacombs, spectral creatures, and witch trials. The game’s stunning vistas effectively sustain this gloomy atmosphere during its 25-hour escapade as you navigate through dismal, foreboding terrains teeming with zombies, werewolves, and malevolent bandits armed with fireballs – all serving as persistent reminders of the ominous fantasy realm you are immersed in.

Sadly, although the environment is captivating, the narrative falls short compared to it. The game Mandragora is let down by a tepid plotline that lacks cohesion. The monotony of the storyline or the inconsistent voice performances may be contributing factors, as the tale fails to make a lasting impact. Your character acquires magical abilities by sparing a witch during an inquisition and is later directed on his quest to find others. Remarkably, he is aided in this endeavor by a cryptic voice that appears in his mind.

The narrative fails to captivate you, and its supposed twists are more foreseeable than unexpected. Remarkably, the world surrounding you appears more vibrant than the primary storyline itself. Intriguingly, towns and taverns resonate with background dialogue that lends a sense of liveliness and authenticity to the setting, but your own character lacks this vitality. Instead, he frequently mumbles self-dialogues—particularly when obstructed by locked doors—repeating familiar one-liners that mostly serve as hints for revisiting the area later. Regrettably, that’s the extent of his given character traits.

Soulslike Exploration Meets Metroidvania Level Design

In the Metroidvania-style game, Mandragora, you’ll enjoy robust level layouts that gradually unveil themselves as you delve deeper into exploration. The excitement lies in not knowing exactly where each new path might take you. During your journey, you’ll come across Witch Stones, which serve multiple purposes: they act as respawn points upon death, replenish your potions, and allow you to boost your character using the essences of defeated monsters – elements commonly found in Soulslike games.

The main problem isn’t the exploration itself, but rather enduring long enough to hit the next milestone. Regrettably, Mandragora tends to be sparing with its Witch Stones, which might have enhanced the difficulty level, but instead, it frequently throws an overwhelming number of enemies at you. This often shifts from being challenging to becoming frustrating. After losing count of times in specific areas, I found myself evading enemy waves to reach a checkpoint initially. Later, I would return and eliminate them for experience—a strategy that felt essential as I yearned to delve into an unexplored region rather than combat.

Initially, I found the game’s platforming segments thrilling and challenging. However, as I progressed, it became apparent that enemies started to capitalize on the game’s own mechanics, making the experience increasingly frustrating rather than fun. These foes would hurl spells at me while I was hanging onto ledges or mid-jump, adding an extra layer of difficulty. Moreover, traps like wall-mounted crossbows were lurking around every corner, and a single misstep could lead to my untimely demise.

While there were numerous treasures and rewards waiting at the end of these platforming sections, reaching them sometimes felt more like a test of patience than a reward in itself.

PROS:

  1. beautiful areas and an atmospheric setting that sets the mood for a fantasy adventure;
  2. a sprawling skill tree really lets you customize the kind of character you want to fight the darkness.

CONS:

  1. its story is predicable, forgettable, and doesn’t hook you in;
  2. platforming elements are unfair in various areas teeming with enemies;
  3. bosses can get repetitive like all the giant rats you will kill.

Plenty of Class-Building Choices

In the game Mandragora, the fights initially seem enjoyable and fulfilling, but soon lose their charm due to repetition. At first, clashes between Witch Stones are thrilling and perilous, but eventually, they become more of an inconvenience than a true challenge. You’ll quickly learn their routines, and before long, it feels like you’re merely fighting to advance to the next location rather than engaging in a genuine battle. Similarly, boss fights make a strong impression with their diverse attack styles at the start, but after encountering numerous rodent-themed bosses, the formula becomes tiresome. While Mandragora does introduce several unique enemies, it also recycles many of them, making battles challenging, yet somewhat repetitive and predictable.

On a positive note, this game provides extensive customization for your character’s development. This ranges from picking your character’s gender to determining the type of magical warrior you’ll be, offering a great deal of flexibility. With six classes to select, I opted for the Wyldwarden, a nature-focused combatant capable of conjuring roots from the earth and firing lightning bolts at enemies. As you progress by gathering essences, you’ll accumulate talent points that can be invested in an expansive skill tree, granting stat increases like additional health and mana, as well as new spells. While new offensive spells aren’t common to unlock, critical upgrades to stamina and defense are crucial for surviving the game’s more challenging encounters.

Over time, you can acquire or learn spells from different classes, as well as find items granting additional talents not tied to your current class. This flexibility enables you to create the character that best suits your playstyle, given you’re prepared to put in the effort and resources to discover these magic abilities and relics. The process of unlocking a new skill tree may be expensive, but it offers the opportunity to customize your spells and skills in unique ways.

With Mandragora, you have the opportunity to personalize your adventure by tailoring weapons and items through crafting. You can acquire resources and invest them in vendors to create new equipment. Nevertheless, crafting may seem a bit hit-or-miss—some upgrades might not greatly enhance your character, making the effort to collect materials feel less rewarding at times. Nonetheless, for explorers eager to uncover all of Mandragora‘s secrets, there are numerous hidden treasures and items waiting to be discovered. However, access to these areas requires finding special map fragments that serve as keys. The rewards—additional treasures and crafting materials—make the quest worthwhile if you’re determined to amass everything this game has in store.

Final Thoughts

In essence, Mandragora appears promising with its engaging plot and visually appealing design, yet it falls short in its execution. To reach its full potential as a Soulslike Metroidvania standout, it needs further refinement. The captivating atmosphere and immersive world construction entice exploration, but the frequent, challenging, and sometimes monotonous enemy battles mar the experience. This is particularly true when players find themselves frequently revisiting certain areas to unlock previously inaccessible paths.

When all pieces fall into alignment, Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree delivers an engaging character-building system that empowers you to shape your character as desired, while enveloping you in a brooding environment yearning for discovery. A deeper emphasis on who you’re battling and why you’re traversing various locations would have elevated it to something truly exceptional.

Read More

2025-04-28 13:04