6 Mind-Blowing Theories on The Sopranos’ Mysterious Finale

by

The last episode of “The Sopranos,” titled “Made in America,” has been one of the most divisive finales in television history. As Tony’s family gathers in a diner, the screen suddenly goes black, leaving viewers guessing about what transpired next. This ambiguous ending has sparked countless discussions since its broadcast, with many initially believing their TV or DVR had malfunctioned at that critical moment. However, when it was revealed that this was the intended finale, some fans expressed disappointment, feeling that David Chase and his team should have provided a clearer conclusion for the mafia series.

Over time, it’s become clear to all that this was a brilliant decision. There are still queries about the events themselves, and Chase continues to create puzzlement by sometimes affirming and other times denying that Tony Soprano is deceased. At present, these theories seem more plausible.

6
The ‘Michael Corleone’ Theory

Many viewers believe that the “Man in the Members’ Only Jacket” is significant because he enters the diner, looks at Tony, goes to the bathroom, and then, according to theory, returns from the bathroom and fatally shoots Tony Soprirano, causing the screen to go black.

Michael Corleone Does a Similar Thing in ‘The Godfather’

Supporters of this theory find it convincing due to a scene in “The Godfather”. In this scene, Michael Corleone takes revenge for his father’s shooting. At a supposed peace meeting with the perpetrators (Captain McClusky and Virgil “The Turk” Sollozzo), Michael briefly leaves the room and goes to the bathroom. There, he had concealed a gun. Upon returning, he shoots the two men. This theory implies that the “Man in the Members’ Only Jacket”, who was also present at the meeting, might have hidden a gun in the bathroom as well.

As a movie buff putting it in my own words:

In the captivating Season 6 opener, titled “Members Only,” Vito Spatafore ridicules Eugene for sporting a jacket emblazoned with the phrase “Members Only.” Later on, tragedy strikes when Tony thwarts Eugene’s plans to relocate to Florida, leading to his unfortunate suicide. It appears that this jacket symbolized an exclusive gang that Eugene was part of, and its members harbored resentment towards Tony, perhaps explaining Eugene’s tragic end.

5
A Robert Frost Reference Means Tony Survived

A theory emerged in the 2024 documentary titled “David Chase and The Sopranos” suggesting that Tony might still be alive. This theory is based on a scene referenced by Chase from Season 3’s “Proshai, Livushka,” where Tony’s daughter Meadow assists her brother AJ with homework about Robert Frost’s poem “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening.” In this scene, when asked what snow symbolizes, AJ responds “Christmas?”. Meadow corrects him, stating “Cold? Endless white? Endless nothing? Death!”, to which AJ retorts “I thought black was death!”. This exchange could imply that Tony’s character may represent the symbol of ‘death’ in this context.

Wrong Color

Meadow consistently outsmarts her siblings in intellect, making her insights seem particularly accurate. She excels academically, unlike AJ who struggles with grades. Furthermore, the recurring description of snow in the poem points to its theme being death, so a sudden blackout wouldn’t signify that Tony was killed.

As a die-hard fan, I can’t help but feel vindicated after this mind-blowing revelation. The series creator masterfully concludes the docuseries by saying “The thing is…” just before the screen fades to black once more. The lyrics of the closing song, subtly hinting at “Don’t stop believing,” only reinforce the idea that Tony is still alive and kicking. To top it off, with the Lupertazzi vs DiMeo war finally over, it seems like there was no one left actively plotting to take out our beloved mob boss.

4
Did Tony and Bobby’s Discussion Forshadow Tony’s Death?

In Season 6’s “Soprano Home Movies,” a conversation between Bobby Baccalieri and Tony is seen as hinting at Tony’s potential demise. During their chat, they discuss the customs of the mob, with Bobby stating, “You likely won’t even notice when it occurs.” The scene where Gerry Torciano was shot earlier in the series also lacked sound, suggesting that he didn’t hear anything, which aligns with Bobby’s statement.

Words Have Power

Just as Bobby’s statement implied, Tony might not have been aware of what occurred at that time since neither he nor the viewers were privy to the event. This is why a flashback to Bobby’s remarks was included in the last minutes of “The Blue Comet”, an episode prior to “Made in America”. Bobby was indeed shot, and his words could be seen as a premonition of his fate; however, for Bobby, the entire execution sequence is depicted, whereas viewers learn about it when it unfolds, which isn’t the case for Tony.

3
Oranges as Bad Omens

Tony has a strong fondness for oranges and orange juice which sometimes leads him to argue with Carmela over it, particularly preferring the ones labeled as having some pulp. Earlier in “Made in America,” we see Tony holding an orange at Carmela’s project house, and certain fans interpret this action as a hint of future events.

Keep Off the Fruits

The concept behind the Orange Juice Theory arises from “The Godfather,” and it carries significant weight given that Tony had recently purchased orange juice prior to an attempted hit on him throughout the series. Here’s how we can rephrase it:

In the story of The Godfather, there’s a theory known as the Orange Juice Theory, which gains credence because Tony was seen buying oranges just before an assassination attempt on him. Interestingly enough, when Vito Corleone later collapses and dies due to health issues, he is depicted holding an orange in his garden while making funny faces at his grandson. This isn’t the only instance where oranges seem significant. They are also present on the table during the meeting of the five families, where the bosses were subsequently assassinated. It’s quite a stretch to call this all just a coincidence.

2
Dead or In Jail

In several episodes of the HBO crime drama, Tony emphasizes to his mob associates that there are essentially two possible outcomes for a Don: either deceased or imprisoned. This statement appears in Season 2’s “The Happy Wanderer” and also kicks off Season 4. And indeed, he is correct about this.

The Trend Repeats Itself

In the television series, two prominent figures met with either a tragic end: Phil Leotardo from the Lupertazzi family was brutally killed, while Johnny Sack went to prison. Throughout the entire show, Tony managed to avoid spending a single day in jail, a feat worthy of praise. His intelligence or perhaps just good fortune kept him out of trouble, until the very end. Since there were no active investigations against Tony, it’s likely he wasn’t arrested. Instead, he was wounded by gunfire.

Tony’s assertion finds support through the historical accounts of criminal figures like John Gotti and Carmine Galante, both of whom ultimately faced imprisonment or met untimely ends, reflecting a common pattern in the underworld.

1
A Fate Worse Than Death?

From a movie enthusiast’s perspective: Life for Tony has taken a drastic turn after the devastating events. The future appears ominous, casting an eerie darkness that blankets the screen. Key figures from his crew have met their end, leaving only Paulie, whose allegiance seems questionable. My sister, Janice, continues to stir trouble as ever, and the state of Tony’s finances is far from promising. It seems like the story may have reached its conclusion, for now there’s little on the horizon that piques my interest.

Nothing to Smile About

It’s quite possible that the days ahead are just difficult for Tony, nothing more. He seems to be feeling rather down as well. This interpretation aligns with what David Chase shared in his interview with The Hollywood Reporter.

As a movie critic, what irked me was the widespread enthusiasm for Tony’s demise throughout the series. Frankly, it troubled me deeply. The audience seemed eager for confirmation that he would meet his end. They yearned to witness him plummeting, face-first into a bowl of linguini, it seemed. And I couldn’t help but think, “Goodness gracious, have we not followed this man’s journey for seven years? Haven’t we grown attached to him, in some way or another? Yet, you desire his death?” It was perplexing and disheartening.

From Chase’s perspective, it appears he never contemplated harming Tony. Instead, he believed the audience appreciated the character and desired to watch more of him. Consequently, hearing discussions about getting rid of him felt somewhat disheartening.

Read More

2025-04-20 23:39