Doctor Who’s Darkest Fans

by

In episode 2 of season 15, titled “Lux,” one of the standout scenes involves Ncuti Gatwa’s Fifteenth Doctor interacting with dedicated Doctor Who fans, which is quite thrilling. However, the humorous interaction between the characters feels surprisingly authentic. In this episode, the Doctor and Belinda Chandra (played by Varada Sethu) enter a reality where Doctor Who isn’t a time-traveling adventure but just a TV show. Essentially, this scene suggests that the Fifteenth Doctor and his companion might have ventured into our universe, albeit temporarily. However, it seems they didn’t actually cross over, yet the writing was excellent.

The Disney period for Doctor Who has never shied away from breaking the fourth wall, yet “Lux” goes beyond this by openly admitting that the show consists of made-up adventures. I found the meta dialogue between the Doctor and his followers particularly delightful, enhancing the overall uniqueness of “Lux”. Remarkably, a scene featuring Gatwa’s character sharing tea with real-world individuals seems incongruous given the more magical aspects of the show, but it harmoniously integrates into the storyline.

The “Doctor Who Fans” Scene In Season 15, Episode 2 Was Great, I Can’t Lie

It’s tough not to love the weirdest moment in “Lux”

I must confess, when I discovered Russell T. Davies’ move of extracting The Doctor and Belinda from the TV screen in “Lux,” I found myself bracing for a reaction I might not have enjoyed. You see, I’ve got mixed feelings about productions that breach the fourth wall. When it’s done skillfully, as in the Deadpool series, it can be a delight. But if it’s not handled carefully, it can feel contrived and unnecessary. In the case of Doctor Who, this technique has been employed during Jodie Whittaker’s tenure as the lead character, but the “fans” scene in “Lux” took things a step further, to an almost exaggerated level.

Fortunately, Davies skillfully handled the situation with great charisma, ensuring that the essence of “Doctor Who” remained intact throughout. Transforming the scene into Lux’s realm cleverly turned what could have been a damaging revelation about the show’s nature into a plausible diversion to delay or prevent the Doctor and Belinda from returning to 1952 Miami, thus thwarting the God of Light’s scheme. As a devoted “Doctor Who” enthusiast, I was thrilled to sense a connection with the Time Lord in this narrative.

Some Of Doctor Who’s Fan Jokes Hit A Little Close To Home

Davies didn’t hold back during his meta critique of Whovians

The “Lux” fans are particularly passionate about Doctor Who, constantly boasting about their predictions for future events. While not every fandom exhibits such behavior, it’s undeniable that this one ranks high when it comes to fan theories and interpretations of ambiguous storylines. I’ve had numerous discussions with friends about potential plot developments or the deeper meanings hidden in these stories, each of us convinced our ideas are the most insightful.

Observing such self-assured characters on screen, without personally being part of the action, makes me realize how grating overconfidence can be. TV shows often build significant audiences with enthusiastic fans who feel a strong connection to the narrative. This bond can sometimes lead to a sense of rivalry within the fanbase, particularly regarding who holds the most accurate opinions and possesses the deepest knowledge about the show’s details. Even “Doctor Who” isn’t immune to this phenomenon, as I myself have been involved in such competitive dynamics on numerous occasions. The comic “Lux” doesn’t shy away from addressing this issue.

Overall, Doctor Who Season 15’s Fan Scene Was Made With Love… I Think

I don’t think RTD meant to seriously offend anyone

Well, many people say that.” It appears that showrunner Russell T. Davies is voicing his irritation with the fan base and their peculiarities, choosing not to confront them directly but rather letting them respond with a nonchalant, “We couldn’t care less.

Despite instances where the portrayal seems to be a full-blown assault on the “Doctor Who” fandom, I’m not convinced that Russell T Davies is genuinely antagonistic in this script segment. In “Lux,” the fans may indeed come across as rather annoying, but they serve as a comical caricature of the actual “Doctor Who” fan behavior. While some exaggeration might have been necessary, it’s clear that he’s not stretching things too far. Overall, it appears to be a fond tribute to generations of “Doctor Who” viewers rather than a bitter criticism – I certainly hope that’s the case.

Doctor Who Season 15’s Release Schedule On Disney+
Episode Title Release Date (2025)
1 “The Robot Revolution” April 12
2 “Lux” April 19
3 “The Well” April 26
4 “Lucky Day” May 3
5 “The Story and the Engine” May 10
6 “The Interstellar Song Contest” May 17
7 “Wish World” May 24
8 “The Reality War” May 31

Read More

2025-04-19 17:58