Blue Bloods Fans Were Way Too Harsh on Erin Reagan

by

One of the most iconic police procedurals ever made, “Blue Bloods,” held audiences spellbound for an impressive 14 seasons and will further solidify its legacy with the debut of “Boston Blue.” We’ve been provided a sneak peek into what the new show promises, and it has already sparked debate among fans. This isn’t unexpected, as followers of the original series are known for their passionate discussions about every facet of the show, including characters, plotlines, and how closely it mirrors real life within the NYPD. Nevertheless, when it comes to character debates, few can match the divisiveness surrounding Erin Reagan.

In many viewers’ eyes, she forms the moral foundation of the show, earning both admiration and grudging respect due to her unwavering principles, even when her actions don’t align with fan expectations. However, as the seasons progress, a growing number of fans have developed mixed feelings towards her. It’s challenging to pinpoint exactly why this shift has occurred. Maybe it’s because we, as devoted fans of fictional TV shows, sometimes become so attached to our favorite characters that we overlook ethical issues for their sake.

By taking such actions, fans frequently voice opinions that might not be moral stances we’d maintain in the real world. Shows like Blue Bloods and characters such as Erin (Bridget Moynahan) are remarkably complex because they resonate with our hidden depths. However, Erin has faced a significant amount of criticism online due to her shifting loyalties, moving away from what fans anticipated for her character – choosing family ties over what she felt was the correct path in the end.

The Reagan Family Dynamic Always Cast Erin as the Odd One Out

Initially on the series “Blue Bloods”, Erin entered as an Assistant District Attorney with high ideals and a strong sense of ethics, guided by her moral compass. Moreover, she was a dedicated single mother, demonstrating both resilience and kindness. Over time, she emerged as something of a moral guide for the Reagan family, earning praise for these qualities. However, television shows like “Blue Bloods” can spark heated debates among viewers, and Erin found herself at the heart of this divisiveness.

As the series delves into the daily lives of a police precinct, viewers often grow fond of its members, particularly those linked to the Reagan family. Regrettably, the stronger the bond formed with the Reagan officers, the more likely they were to distance themselves from Erin. This pattern became increasingly evident whenever her job clashed with her family’s needs, as episodes like “Reagan V. Reagan” in Season 2 demonstrated.

Erin’s Progression Through the Show Was in Keeping With Her Talent

In the course of Erin’s career advancing significantly on the show, it was clear that she deserved her success, given the increasing intricacy and high-profile nature of the cases she handled, which enhanced her reputation as a competent and tenacious prosecutor. However, this also led to her becoming increasingly hardened. By the middle seasons, her son had already moved out on his own. Such events often exacerbated Erin’s sense of isolation, particularly in contrast to the rest of her family.

Her increased dedication to work over time didn’t make things easier. With the possibility of her being nominated for the DA position and taking on intense cases that affected her family’s police work, Erin grew more rigid as time passed. However, as Jack Ori of TV Fanatic points out, this trait is perceived negatively only when it’s Erin who demonstrates it.

Erin became stricter at work due to her potential promotion and family cases, but many people see this as a negative aspect because she’s the one exhibiting it. (TV Fanatic says this is the case.)

The reason Frank is perceived as a man of integrity and Erin as troublesome might stem from outdated prejudices. It’s no secret that traits appreciated in men are often criticized when found in women. In this context, it becomes understandable why people view Frank as upholding integrity when he resists being pressured into doing something unethical, while they see Erin as inflexible when she does the same thing. It’s not to say that this is the entire picture, but it’s crucial to question our own biases and why we perceive Erin in the way we do.

Why Erin Was Always Unfairly Treated by ‘Blue Bloods’ Fans

Erin Reagan was an individual who strongly adhered to her principles, feeling a greater purpose beyond herself. Her unwavering commitment to these values, even when they contradicted her family’s interests, is admirable. In a society where morals often bend and truth and justice are frequently overlooked in favor of wealth, blood, or power, Erin’s steadfast integrity is exceptionally rare.

Beyond that, it’s not just about her always standing on the moral high ground, but also that the resentment expressed on fan forums and Reddit discussions often escalates into a level of toxicity that barely resembles logic. As anticipation mounts for the upcoming spinoff series, it’s evident that the established dynamics need to change. While her strong-willed character rubbed some viewers the wrong way, criticisms against her soon morphed into personal attacks on aspects ranging from her perceived cold and robotic demeanor to the apparent double standard applied to her. In truth, Erin was far from flawless. Yet, no character in Blue Bloods was without fault, but only Erin was labeled as the problematic one and the villain of the Reagan family. Ultimately, this portrayal was undeserved. You can catch Blue Bloods on Paramount+ and Fubo TV.

Read More

2025-04-19 00:03