HBO’s 21-Year-Old Drama Still Reigns Supreme Over Modern Western TV Shows

by

The popularity of the Western genre has experienced a significant comeback, particularly in television programming, yet no series has managed to outshine HBO’s 2004 production. After the 1970s, the Western genre seemed to lose its charm, but the last few decades have witnessed an unprecedented resurgence for this style of storytelling. Notable TV shows in the 21st century include Justified, Longmire, Dark Winds, Hell on Wheels, and numerous others. This doesn’t even begin to mention Taylor Sheridan’s Yellowstone and its associated spinoffs, or many of the top Western shows from the past decade. While Western films may no longer enjoy the popularity they once did, Western television content remains robust.

Over the years, Western television has evolved significantly from the times of “Rawhide” and “Gunsmoke”, leading to a division between the classic and contemporary periods. While the contemporary era of Western TV has produced remarkable series such as “American Primeval” and “Outer Range”, its zenith was in 2004, and no subsequent show has managed to surpass it. Despite the growing popularity of Western shows over the last two decades, even the best modern efforts can’t compete with HBO’s “Deadwood”.

Deadwood Is Still The Best Western TV Show

Many Western Shows Have Come Close, But Deadwood Is Still The Best Example Of The Genre In A Serialized Format

Despite over two decades passing and numerous other Western series emerging since then, HBO’s Deadwood remains unparalleled as the finest modern Western television show ever produced. This isn’t to imply that contemporary Westerns lack merit; rather, it underscores the groundbreaking nature of Deadwood across almost every aspect.

The ensemble cast of Deadwood, featuring characters like Al Swearengen (played by Ian McShane) and Seth Bullock (Timothy Olyphant), was simply outstanding. The show also explored a compelling sociological narrative about power, morality, and greed that remains relevant today, just as it was in 2004.

Additionally, the series boasted remarkable, historically accurate sets and costumes, exceptional writing, and much more, making Deadwood an instant classic.

It’s not just my personal view, it’s a widely shared sentiment that Deadwood stands out as one of the greatest TV shows ever made, not just among Western series but in general. The show has garnered high praise from both critics and audiences, with a 92% rating among critics and 95% among viewers on Rotten Tomatoes. Shows like That Dirty Black Bag and Wynona Earp, which have gained large audiences and achieved success, still fall short when compared to the impact Deadwood made in every essential aspect of what makes a good show. Furthermore, these newer shows owe a significant debt to Deadwood.

Modern Western TV Doesn’t Happen Without Deadwood

Even After Two Decades, Deadwood Has Left An Indelible Mark On Western TV

One clear indication of Deadwood’s immense impact and influence on the Western genre is its lasting impression, which can be seen in virtually every Western series since 2004. In essence, Deadwood has left an indelible mark on the evolution of Western television, shaping it significantly and even giving rise to its current form. For instance, shows like Godless and Yellowstone share Deadwood’s gritty, revisionist take on the Old West, while Yellowstone explores power struggles among multiple characters reminiscent of the complex dynamics within Deadwood’s town. In many ways, Deadwood revolutionized Western TV in much the same manner as Star Trek redefined science fiction television.

Deadwood didn’t merely provide inspiration for contemporary Western TV series; it significantly reshaped the television landscape, paving the way for those later shows to exist. Before Deadwood, Gunsmoke was considered the epitome of Western TV shows, but was often viewed as outdated and excessively sentimental. Deadwood introduced the Revisionist Western movement, which began with films like Unforgiven, into a serialized format, demonstrating that the genre could still be respected in the 21st century. Shows like Yellowstone might not have achieved their level of popularity if Deadwood hadn’t blazed a trail for them first.

Read More

2025-04-18 19:27