9-1-1 Recap: Amber Alert

by

In a surprising turn of events, it’s amazing that we managed to get 116 episodes into the series 9-1-1 without a significant plot line centered around dissociative identity disorder. I must admit, I was quite oblivious about the situation when Detective Braeburn abducted Maddie at the end of last week’s episode. However, the unveiling was quite dramatic and the subsequent hour made “Voices” a captivating finish for this two-part story. Let’s hope that the second half of season eight keeps living up to its potential; I’m ready to move past my minor letdown over the underwhelming bee-nado.

Maddie is the one to uncover the truth about Amber, whom I believe we can refer to by her first name as Maddie does frequently to create a personal bond. This Amber exhibits an unusual condition. When our beloved 911 dispatcher (apologies to Josh) awakens, she finds herself shackled in a basement. Her captor is Amber, or at least a version of her: The detective appears to be engaged in a heated disagreement with herself. There’s a cruel Amber and a kind Amber, only the harsh one was responsible for kidnapping people. However, Maddie struggles to comprehend the multiple personalities; nonetheless, she learns crucial details about the Bullock case. Specifically, that Amber was indeed involved in everything, including the 911 calls. Amber aimed to persuade Maddie that it was all a hoax, but when Maddie presented evidence at her office, Amber had no choice but to implicate Bullock. Despite Bullock’s staged suicide, Amber is concerned that Maddie may have detected something amiss – like the unnatural voice on the 911 calls, for instance – and informed Athena. She didn’t, but Amber isn’t feeling very trustworthy now, and honestly, who could blame her?

At home after Eddie’s farewell dinner, Chimney arrives with some tantalizing leftovers but finds his wife Maddie is nowhere to be found. His friends rally to help, but Chimney is in disarray. Given Maddie’s past history of postpartum depression, it’s plausible she might have disappeared on her own accord. However, Hen reminds them that if Maddie is experiencing a mental health crisis, they should find and aid her. Chimney reports Maddie missing, and luckily, Amber Braeburn, the renowned bloodhound detective, is available to assist! Abigail Spencer delivers an outstanding performance in this episode, particularly in the scene where she subtly probes Chimney for information. You can see that he doesn’t suspect her of being malevolent, but there’s a hint of it lurking beneath. Moreover, she manages to extract crucial details, such as Maddie’s pregnancy and previous suicidal thoughts. Meanwhile, Athena is not immediately able to uncover the culprit, although she senses something amiss. The timing of Maddie’s disappearance is indeed suspicious, even if Bullock could not have been involved. Could it be that he had an accomplice?

Instead of waiting for rescue, Maddie is frantically attempting to flee and making notable progress before her captor reappears. Unfortunately, Amber (or perhaps it’s Peter) doesn’t have much time to spare and has a convincing reason for Maddie’s sudden death. Amber prepares a syringe filled with fentanyl – which could be detected in an autopsy along with Maddie’s other wounds, but I’m not a criminal mastermind, so let me keep quiet. As Maddie pleads to write a farewell letter to Jee-Yun, Amber sees this as a beneficial suicide note for both of them. Complying, she discovers a softer side in the serial killer, and her gentle demeanor resurfaces. Her name is Peter, and he’s deeply troubled by these events. However, he’s not pleased with Maddie’s attempt to coerce him into taking his own life during their 911 call. (It’s uncertain whether Amber’s plot was carefully orchestrated or a result of her mental instability, but logic is often overlooked.) Maddie implores for another chance to aid Peter, and he (or maybe it’s still Amber) consents. Jennifer Love Hewitt delivers powerful performances in these scenes, helping to offset the inherent absurdity of this storyline.

There’s no need to fret; Athena is continuing her investigation. She’s meeting with Detective Romero to discuss the autopsy results on Bullock. The pathologist quickly confirms that Bullock appears to have taken his own life – his finger was on the gun trigger, but there was also a large amount of chloroform in his system. (It seems Amber purchases chloroform in bulk.) The detectives then decide to question Jayna about any potential accomplices. From her hospital bed, she claims she can’t remember anything, but then mentions casually that Bullock argued with an unidentified adult woman during his captivity of Jayna. (Given her traumatic situation, it’s surprising this wasn’t mentioned earlier.) Athena and Romero assume the woman is Isabelle, Bullock’s ex, but she has a solid alibi. They’re at a standstill, so Athena suggests they search for other distress calls made to 911 from victims similar to Jayna. Unfortunately, Jayna has been kidnapped again, this time by Amber, while Maddie remains missing as well. My apologies, Jayna.

As an intrigued observer, I can’t help but find a significant lead captivating – a girl who managed to break free from her captor. Given her age during the ordeal, her identity has been withheld, but it’s Amber Braeburn whom we’re now tracking down. Athena and Romero make their way to dispatch where Josh kindly supplies the audio from Amber’s 25-year-old call. She discloses a harrowing tale of escape from a man who drugged and abducted her. The pieces start falling into place for Athena, leading her to believe that Amber was responsible for the murders of other girls and kidnapping Jayna, using Bullock as a scapegoat. (I must admit, I’m still left scratching my head. While traumatic experiences can lead to dissociative identity disorder, at what point did Amber’s fragmented psyche transform her into a villain? And who is Peter, exactly? These questions remain unanswered, so feel free to speculate wildly.) Before Athena and Romero pay Amber a visit, Josh informs them that Chimney has already set off for the same destination. After Mara tipped off Chimney about Jee-Yun hearing a crying voice in their home the night Maddie went missing, he came to the realization that Maddie didn’t leave on her own accord. And rather than wait for Amber to respond to his calls, he decides to act swiftly and share this crucial update with the team.

Amber is swamped with work, making it impossible for her to answer calls. She escorts Jayna into the basement to give Maddie a chance to intervene, but in truth, I believe Amber isn’t giving Maddie a fair opportunity. In reality, she intends to harm Jayna further and add more distress to Maddie. However, just as Chimney rings the doorbell, Amber chloroforms Jayna again and plans to ascend upstairs. With Maddie having managed to escape her restraints only to be halted by a locked basement door, she seizes the moment to strike against Amber. Though her attack is brave, it ultimately fails. Amber, annoyed by the disruption, retaliates by slashing Maddie’s throat with her knife. The incident unfolds so swiftly and startlingly that I let out a sound similar to Maddie’s as she recognizes she’s bleeding profusely.

Amber remains composed during her conversation with Chimney upstairs, and so does Chim when Athena reveals that Amber is the kidnapper. However, Amber suspects Athena has figured her out, so she brandishes a gun at Chimney. Suddenly, Maddie, who’s still bleeding, enters to strike Amber with a hammer. The show takes a turn towards a typical horror-movie finale here. For those familiar with the Scream series (which also includes voice changers), you know the villain rarely stays defeated. As Chimney holds Maddie, Amber stands up, planning to shoot again. At that instant, Athena arrives and kills Amber. This scene is quite violent, even by the standards of the show 9-1-1.

In simpler terms, we find out that Maddie and her baby make it through, which is a relief but also brings more pain due to the traumatic events. The show “Voices” concludes on a melancholic note as Eddie, for real this time, prepares to depart. With help from Buck, Eddie packs up his U-Haul and shares a heartfelt goodbye that is both difficult and necessary. I won’t imply the scene is meant to upset fans; instead, let Eddie explain his feelings. He tells Buck that their relationship has been complicated and challenging, but he wants him to understand that he matters to him. After a long pause, they share an emotional hug. Eddie mentions he and Christopher can be reached easily before driving away with some freshly baked chocolate-chip protein cookies from Buck. It’s clear that both Buck and I are feeling sad about this farewell. The writers have subtly woven emotion into the scene, but it can be interpreted differently depending on the viewer.

Call Log

Indeed, it seems I’ve come around to the idea that Eddie might not have left us permanently. After all, who can predict the perils they may encounter in El Paso that would force their return to Los Angeles?

Abigail Spencer played Amber Braeburn exceptionally well, making her a captivating character. However, some viewers, including myself, felt that we could’ve delved deeper into the conclusion. As previously mentioned, I have lingering questions about her unexpected villain turn, and I was hoping for a more comprehensive explanation or revelation similar to the ending of “Psycho.

I appreciated when either Amber or Peter brought up the time it takes for someone to bleed out after having their throat cut, shown in last week’s episode. This gave me renewed optimism about Maddie’s chances of surviving. Despite that, it was still a pretty startling scene.

Regarding Maddie’s impressive survival abilities, I must admit I was puzzled by her method of escaping using a soda can from the restraints, but I’d be eager to enroll in any course she teaches.

Was there any chance that someone finished off the remaining steak frites and chocolate tart from Eddie’s farewell dinner? I wonder if they’re still in the refrigerator, as I just can’t get over how delicious they were.

Read More

2025-03-14 04:59