Why Manor Lords Players Want Battle Rewards (And They’re Not Getting Them)

by

Manor Lords keeps gamers hooked with its compelling mix of economic strategy and medieval combat, yet there’s one contentious matter troubling its player base: the lack of battle rewards. After countless battles won and victories earned, players express disappointment about the lack of tangible loot or war spoils. The game’s subreddit buzzes with lively debate, driven by a user named “hornyandHumble,” who strongly advocates for something substantial to be gained after investing resources in battles—such as gold, weapons, or power. Most players seem to enjoy the game but yearn for more than just praise; they desire some form of tangible reward. So, let’s delve deeper into this situation where victory brings no treasure!

Summary

  • Players express a common desire for battle rewards, feeling their effort should be acknowledged not just with victory but with loot.
  • The debate around balance issues emerges, with concerns that generous rewards might overshadow the core challenges of the game.
  • Despite love for the game, players are hesitant to continue when victories feel unrewarding.
  • Discussions hint at possible solutions, including salvaging or looting defeated enemies to enhance the gameplay experience.

The Rant That Sparked the Conversation

The story began when user “hornyandHumble” shared an emotional post on the Manor Lords subreddit, detailing a challenging battle against a baron. Despite heavy losses among the villagers (farewell, villagers), the fight ended with no rewards for their effort. This sparked sympathy from many players, who also expressed feelings of dissatisfaction, as they felt that winning battles should bring more benefits. HornyandHumble pointed out the illogical aspect of not receiving any money, loot, or power, considering they had just defeated a force of 36 soldiers—a valuable prize that should have been plundered. This sentiment echoed throughout the community, prompting calls for improvements.

Balancing Act: The Downsides of Rewarding Every Victory

Amongst the players, some eagerly seek rewards, while others on the subreddit advocate for moderation. User “pudgus” astutely points out that giving players resources for every battle could disrupt the game’s equilibrium. They suggest that winning battles and capturing territories should be enough reward, as adding monetary incentives might diminish the thrill of interacting with mercenaries and combat challenges. In essence, if players were given money for each victory, the significance would decrease, leading to a less stimulating economic strategy and overall gameplay experience. The developers must navigate this situation delicately to prevent any reward system from undermining the strategic complexity that players have grown fond of. It appears there’s a clear split among players—some who want to commemorate their victories with loot, and others who believe some self-restraint is necessary.

Frustration Among the Ranks

Players’ feelings lean towards disappointment as they ponder the consequences of unacknowledged victories. User “Lost_in_speration” shares an experience where, despite skillfully defending the baron, they felt disheartened following the fight due to a significant loss in troops and no reward. This predicament has them doubting the merit of continuing battles. Many players seem to echo this frustration as they struggle to maintain motivation when their hard-fought triumphs bring little more than an empty sensation. The absence of gratification after a tough skirmish can certainly sap the spirit, fostering feelings of futility and demotivation.

The Alternative: What Might Enhance the Experience?

The discussion has sparked some captivating thoughts on how to make the fighting experience more engaging in Manor Lords. Players are proposing various enhancements, such as earning influence points similar to rewards from defeating bandits or salvaging weapons and resources from vanquished enemies. User “DynamicSploosh” jokes that players are already compensated for pillaging bandit camps; perhaps the same benefit could be extended to defeated adversaries? This would not only be enjoyable but also, one might argue, realistic. Other participants share the sentiment for tangible rewards like repurposing enemy armor into resources or trading them for treasury – which could inject an economic strategy layer without making victory solely about collecting loot. Ultimately, it seems that players want their combat efforts to have significance beyond the battlefield screen.

Reflecting on the conversations, it’s clear that this community is deeply passionate about Manor Lords, yet there seems to be some dissatisfaction with the aspects of winning. Beneath their gripes, you can see the glowing embers of enthusiasm for a win that signifies more than just territorial control. As developers, it’s crucial not to overlook the emotional investment players put into their empires. In the end, whether it’s a gleaming new weapon, a satchel full of gold, or some prestige points, players yearn for victories that are grand and satisfying. It’s past due for meaningful victory rewards; remember, a good loot drop can elevate an ordinary win into an epic triumph!

Read More

2025-03-10 11:44