
The filming of the How’s That?! pilot in the episode “Valerie Does It All” highlights a problem I have with the season’s portrayal of AI. The audience is shown a cold open where Beth’s comment about feeling unstable after a small accident is met with silence. The writers then try to punch up the joke, but Josh, the human writer, stubbornly defends his line and resists changes. Even suggestions to improve it fall flat. Ultimately, they use a line generated by AI – “Well, I guess those ants were termites.” While not hilarious, it’s noticeably better than what Josh came up with. I understand The Comeback isn’t trying to prove AI can write good sitcoms, and I don’t need the show to agree with my own feelings about the technology. However, I’m unclear what we’re supposed to conclude from this scene, especially considering the previous week showed Val and Jimmy liking an AI-written scene that Josh found too sappy. The show seems unsure whether AI is dangerous because it’s too good, or because it’s simply not good enough.