Smite Showdown: Should New Players Begin with Smite 1 or Smite 2?

As a seasoned gamer with over 4,000 hours clocked in League of Legends and a newcomer to Smite, I find myself at a crossroads, much like Odin deciding between the worlds of Asgard and Midgard. After reading through the passionate debates on the Smite subreddit about Smite 1 versus Smite 2, I’m torn between the allure of nostalgia and the promise of innovation.

In a recent post on the Smite subreddit, user Yahuahh finds themselves in a pickle: they’ve been given a free key for Smite 2 but have never played Smite 1. This predicament stirs up a vibrant conversation among experienced players about which version offers the best starting point for newcomers. As an avid gamer with over 4,000 hours under their belt in League of Legends, they’re on the hunt for a more laid-back experience on their Xbox Series X and are eagerly awaiting the joy of couch gaming with Smite 2. The feedback ranges from fond reminiscences of Smite 1 to cautious enthusiasm about Smite 2.

New player. Smite 1 or smite 2? Which one should I play?
byu/Yahuahh inSmite

Summary

The conversation highlights a split sentiment towards Smite 1 and Smite 2, where users appreciate the completeness of the former and the future of the latter.
Many suggest that while Smite 2 may appeal to long-term potential, the current jankiness might deter new players.
Nostalgia plays a significant role in the discussion, with many players sharing fond memories from Smite 1, impacting their advice.
The underlying concern of the game’s player population is recurrent, with users pointing out that neither game offers a casual-friendly environment currently.

Smite 1: The Nostalgic Choice

For numerous gamers, Smite 1 serves not just as a game, but as an adventure through a distinctive and captivating universe. User Popas_Pipas clearly states, “Smite 1 may eventually fade away, but it currently offers more content,” mirroring sentiments shared by others who emphasize the significance of experiencing the entire package. Traditional_Front637 acknowledges that Smite 1 delivers a more refined gameplay experience at present, which can be vital for novice players. Reminiscences suggest a bittersweet feeling of nostalgia—many players recall their initial days in Smite 1, the extensive lore, character development rooted in mythology, and abundant content that provided depth and satisfaction. It’s like diving into a classic with a strong narrative that leaves you craving more, which is usually crucial for newcomers seeking a relatable foundation before exploring the latest version. In an era where completeness frequently outweighs promise, Smite 1 stands as a comfortable, if diminishing, sanctuary for beginners.

Smite 2: The Future Unveiled

From another perspective, players drawn to Smite 2 see past its present shortcomings, as they are eager for what’s coming next. It’s evident that Smite 2 is transitioning from its alpha stage, sparking great anticipation about the game’s future development. User Baecchus simply puts it, “Smite 2 is rather sparse and it might not impress at first,” perfectly expressing the reservations many cautious players hold. Many gamers pondering a dive into this new platform share this sentiment: while Smite 2 shines with potential for future expansions, it currently pales in comparison to its predecessor’s rich content. Smite 2 introduces numerous gameplay advancements, tweaks, and enhancements meant to boost player interaction over time. However, these changes have left some feeling unsure. TrueNova332 succinctly states, “Choose Smite 1 for a fully-fledged game, but Smite 2 if you’re okay with it being in alpha,” neatly summing up the key decision many face when choosing their path.

The Casual Experience (or Lack Thereof)

One of the most significant points of contention among the community is regarding the casual-friendliness of both games. CystralSkye candidly remarks, “Both games have very low populations compared to League of Legends… neither is quite casual friendly, but currently, that would be Smite 1.” This highlights a crucial concern with MOBA games—when the player base is limited, it can often lead to a more hardcore environment where beginners may feel overwhelmed. The sentiment transcends the debate between versions, revealing a communal anxiety about attracting new players in a gaming landscape dominated by titans like League of Legends, which remains heavily populated and casual-friendly. Players shared their hopes for both Smite games, expressing a desire for an engaging experience but simultaneously voicing concerns over the mechanics that may alienate newcomers. With neither version particularly catering to the casual audience, new players might find themselves needing to dig deep or stick with friends who are already familiar with the game.

Recommendations and Personal Choices

Amongst players exchanging views, a palpable atmosphere of fellowship and nostalgia unfolds. Seasoned gamers offer firsthand advice, weighing in on different versions, detailing strengths and weaknesses alike. Remarks reveal a playful tone, for instance TozZu89 proposing delving into Smite 1’s detailed lore amplifies the grasp of its evolving plot. This idea underscores admiration for the game’s complexity, urging novices to explore a captivating narrative beyond mere mechanics. User MythicSlayeer contributes valuable insights on Smite 2’s upcoming open beta, juxtaposing Smite 1’s approaching end, sparking heated discussions on immediacy versus long-term commitment. It’s evident that players are equally dedicated to expressing their affection and apprehensions for both game editions as they are for playing them.

In the fascinating juncture of Smite, two distinct titles present contrasting gameplay experiences to players, making the decision between Smite 1 and Smite 2 largely dependent on whether a player yearns for nostalgia or craves something new. The engaging debates among fans reveal that while one side revels in the wealth of tradition and camaraderie, the other offers tantalizing glimpses into future advancements and fresh ideas. As the community grows, novice players find themselves immersed in this lively dialogue as they embark on their gaming adventure, entering a realm where they can forge bonds, amass tales, and revel in the excitement of clashing in epic battles amongst mythological deities.

2024-12-15 01:58