‘Scrap’ Review: An Astute Tale of a Slipping-Down Life Amid Problematic Family Dynamics

As a seasoned movie connoisseur with over three decades of cinematic exploration under my belt, I must say that “Scrap” is a remarkable piece of work that beautifully captures the intricacies of family dynamics and the human condition. Vivian Kerr’s directorial debut, though it may seem like a personal project at first glance, is far from being a vanity production. Instead, it’s a poignant portrayal of hidden homelessness and complex sibling relationships that resonates deeply.

The indie film “Scrap,” skillfully produced by American writer-director Vivian Kerr in her debut feature, subtly explores complex family relationships without resorting to typical tropes found in dysfunctional-clan comedies or high-drama narratives driven by heated arguments and sensational twists. After its premiere at the 2022 Deauville Film Festival, “Scrap” has been making the rounds on the festival circuit for over two years. During this time, Kerr has completed her second project, a period thriller titled “Seance.” Despite playing the lead in both films, this is not a self-indulgent project; her character may even be the least likable among the intricately connected lives portrayed in Los Angeles. Kerr is distributing this compelling portrayal of hidden homelessness and problematic sibling dynamics herself, which will be available on demand platforms starting December 13.

Beth Kerr is first seen waking up in her SUV, located on a residential street in a middle to upper-class neighborhood where she once felt she belonged – until she was let go from her corporate job. Now, she’s striving to keep up appearances of stability, even though she’s lost her home and has been harassed by debt collectors behind closed doors. These difficulties have remained hidden from her older brother Ben Rapp. However, Ben is starting to sense something isn’t right, especially since Beth has left her 5-year-old daughter Birdie with him for an unusually long period, supposedly while she was away on business trips.

Despite enjoying a cushioned lifestyle, Ben faces personal struggles. As an author, he’s compelled to abandon projects dear to him to focus on a popular sword-and-sorcery series that he finds trivial. On top of this, he and his wife Stacy (Lana Parilla), a lawyer, are undergoing the stressful process of in-vitro fertilization without success, which is taking its toll. To add to their troubles, Ben’s needy and abrasive sister Beth appears at their doorstep needing help again, after her car gets broken into and a job opportunity falls through. In an attempt to explain this new development, she invents more lies, forcing herself upon them once more.

It’s not until an hour later that Ben learns the truth about his sister’s job – she’s no longer employed. However, Kerr’s screenplay effectively uses this time to delve into intriguing aspects of their complex sibling dynamic. The backstory reveals that Ben had taken on a caretaker role for his “little sis” after their parents’ mysterious demise, a position she both utilized and resented.

It’s clear that she has tested his vast patience on numerous occasions, and some of her choices are questionable enough for her to worry about being labeled as a failure. Additionally, Stacy’s offhand comment about her being like a “vampire” who drains energy suggests a history of strained relationships. Flashbacks hint at a shared trauma from their childhood that may be too emotionally taxing to talk about openly.

The journey hasn’t been sugarcoated with overly dramatic statements; instead, it’s a bumpy ride that concludes on a positive note, without any quick solutions, but rather realistic adjustments. Ben and Stacy must reconsider their vision of married life. Beth needs to be truthful, starting with herself, which might mean accepting a lower rung in her career and financial growth. This change includes facing a past mistake (Brad Schmidt) who left when she got pregnant, but is now apologetic. A new potential partner (Khleo Thomas), from a different social class, enters the picture, someone she would not have considered earlier.

In this production, the characters are skillfully portrayed and their internal conflicts are more felt than explicitly stated. All three primary characters have an inclination to maintain an image of control, even if it leads to self-destructive consequences. The play, “Scrap,” lacks many stylistic embellishments except for a series of Tin Pan Alley songs from the 78 rpm era, which seem to be favorites of the deceased parents. Instead of building up to typical confrontational climaxes, the story subtly avoids such scenes. The narrative isn’t abstract or symbolic; instead, it restrains external emotional displays to a degree that matches characters who might be on the verge of explosion but are still held back by their dignity and decorum.

In this insightful film, their journey unfolds subtly, avoiding dramatic outbursts or intense climaxes. While such a resolution might benefit them, it doesn’t align with their true selves. The movie, “Scrap,” offers enough clarity for viewers to feel content as the siblings reach their destination without resorting to such methods.

Read More

2024-12-13 16:16