The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On Recap: Fortune Favors the Bold

As a seasoned observer of human relationships and someone who has seen more than a few romantic entanglements unravel on reality TV, I must say that this latest experiment in love and self-discovery is as intriguing as it is confounding.

There’s often an intriguing backstory to poorly done tattoos, whether it’s a misunderstood motivational quote, a hastily drawn cartoon, or an oversized phoenix conceived during emotional turmoil. The motivation behind bad tattoo artistry is frequently more captivating than the tattoo itself. In the latest episode of The Ultimatum, we’ve just seen one of the most unexpectedly tragic tattoo blunders – a mishap so perfectly poignant that you might question if it was deliberate.

On every season of Netflix’s most emotionally perilous dating show, one pair’s passion could potentially ignite the entire experiment. Here, Sandy and J.R. are treading on dangerous ground. J.R. appears quite intrigued by the idea of leaving the show with Sandy, and although I’m not entirely certain she’s genuinely smitten by him, Sandy finds his companionship enjoyable enough to plant a few kisses on him, which in turn makes her initial partner, Nick, get a humiliating tattoo just before our trial couples returned to their original partners.

Moving on, our trial couples part ways and assemble for a post-trial discussion, which we refer to as “the changeover”, prior to embarking on their second and concluding trial marriage with their initial partners.

Last week concluded with the gathering of both men and women. J.R. inquired from Scotty if he had ever suggested that J.R. was misplaced, which some anonymous source claimed to be a “hall pass.” This did not go smoothly, and it seems that Scotty believed the secret informant behind this sensational scandal was his own trial wife, J.R.’s former partner.

This week, when Scotty returns to the apartment, he attempts to make Zaina feel uncomfortable with the intensity of a police interrogator, asking, “Have I ever spoken negatively or disparaged JR to you?” He clarifies that this is not about discussing different viewpoints or finding middle ground; it’s a straightforward question. However, Zaina sees through his attempt and advises him to modify his behavior. Scotty’s apology is as insincere as one might expect, stating, “I’m sorry if my demeanor came across as off-putting.” Argh!

The thing about Scotty is that he argues to win — not to find common ground or understand. Zaina clocks this in just a couple of weeks, and her refusal to feed into his little tantrums makes him look like an even bigger jerk. Scotty himself acknowledges this shortcoming during a game of … beer pong (?!) … with Zaina at their apartment. But as they’re packing for the changeover, he still can’t help but pick one more fight. They end on a transcendent note: Zaina telling Scotty that he doesn’t “deserve to experience” her presence. Honestly, good for her.

In simpler terms, it seems that Sandy and J.R. might not share a strong emotional connection. Instead, it’s possible that they’re both hesitant about their current relationships and are using this friendship as an escape or means to create distance from their existing partners.

Prior to the transition, Sandy shed tears at the prospect of meeting up with Nick again. In a separate chat with Mariah, it appeared that Nick concurred with Sandy’s viewpoint about his emotional instability. On the other hand, J.R. was far from pleased that their trial marriage discussions frequently revolved around Nick. I have a feeling that if given a choice, J.R. and Sandy would have progressed beyond the two on-screen kisses they shared.

After spending his days as a bachelor following an unexpected early exit by his partner in their trial, Nick decides to get a tattoo on his arm to mark this emotionally challenging time. However, instead of getting the desired tattoo (“Love conquers all”), he shares one of his alternative ideas with the artist, opting for “Fortune favors the bold.” Interestingly enough, that same phrase is inked prominently on the hands of a well-known figure – J.R.

How on earth did this occur? Was it perhaps an awkward Freudian slip? Could it be that the producers of “The Ultimatum” accessed Nick’s emails to orchestrate the most mortifying reality TV episode ever? Or is it possible that Nick and J.R. share more similarities than they’d care to acknowledge, and are all men simply drawn to the same tired tropes? No matter the cause, I have never felt a stronger urge to hide beneath my couch cushions to shield myself from secondhand embarrassment than in this instance.

It’s understandable why Aria prefers Caleb over Scotty. Unlike Scotty who enjoys passive-aggressive quarrels, Caleb values tranquility in a relationship. However, their long-term compatibility might face challenges due to Caleb’s pacifistic nature, but considering they’re only living together for three weeks with minimal expenses and disagreements, it seems ideal.

It appears that among Aria’s friends, it’s just Caleb with whom they share farewell gifts. Each gives the other a book, and Aria’s gesture of writing a card has moved Caleb. What a sweet pair they are!

From a movie buff’s perspective, this trial marriage felt rather mild, but it appears it will have profound effects on both of their personal relationships. Mariah, sensing something between us and Caleb, directly queries me about my feelings towards him beyond friendship. Though I aim to avoid crossing any lines, I can’t help but suspect that given more enthusiasm from him, I might find myself drawn to Caleb.

Afterward, the second trial marriages commence by the initial pairs experiencing married life for a span of three weeks. During this period, they can choose to remain engaged, remain single, or even start dating other individuals based on their experiences and feelings.

Nick and Sandy

On an emotional level, Nick and Sandy inhabit distinct realms, and it seems unlikely they’ll ever share the same perspective. One instance stands out where Nick encounters Sandy sobbing in bed with her phone, only to discover she was looking at puffin photos, which results in a remark that unintentionally provokes laughter: “Are you crying over puffins, or is there something else?” Now isn’t that an intriguing question…

However, when Nick learns from Zaina that Sandy and J.R. exchanged a second kiss, things turn sour. Sandy’s explanation – “You never specifically asked me if anything else transpired” – doesn’t sit well. She admits that Nick’s response to the first kiss made her hesitant to inform him about the second; instead, she intended to discuss it after filming (or after he might have proposed, for clarification). Nick’s retort? “It will be intriguing to see how I respond when I’m angry with you.” Yikes!

That evening, Nick angrily exits the apartment, and when we meet them again, Sandy is scolding Nick for the disrespect he showed. Although it’s understandable that Nick might have stormed off without thinking, I find it questionable that Sandy would be giving lectures on respect – considering her dismissive attitude towards Nick’s emotional turmoil regarding J.R., which she casually labels as him “losing his marbles” during their lunch with her mother.

Among all the couples this season, I find it hardest to comprehend Zaina and J.R. My understanding of their relationship remains minimal, despite J.R.’s frequent awkward remarks regarding his past with Sandy. It’s not only about attending her Christmas dinner; even his casual comments are puzzling. To give you an idea, here are some examples:

  • To Sandy, at the changeover: “Whoever gets you will be lucky to have you.”
  • To Zaina, when she asks about his connection with Sandy: “We caught feelings. … Am I leaving here with her? Probably not.” (Emphasis mine. But seriously, PROBABLY?!)
  • To Sandy, away from their original partners: “Were we playing house, or was there something there?”
  • To Zaina: “You thought I was leaving here with Sandy.” And when she said that the thought never crossed her mind: “Why not?”

Is there any hint at all that J.R. values his current relationship? If my partner were expressing such irrational behavior on global broadcast television, I wouldn’t wait for the next flight home. Instead, I would pay for in-flight internet to quickly reinstall every dating app ever created. Contrastingly, Zaina surprises J.R. with an Eagles grill set, some slides, and a candle – actions that might suggest she is trying to maintain their bond.

Scotty appears untroubled by Aria’s connection with Caleb, but once again maintains his stance that Caleb is more than just friends with her. In his view, there’s no denying that Caleb has romantic feelings for Aria. However, it seems that Caleb poses a threat to Scotty not because he’s romantically involved with Aria, but rather because he offers her a relationship free from constant bullying.

Following their reunion, Aria expresses the recurring issue in her relationship with Scotty, which echoes the conflict he previously had with Zaina: “It seemed like you prioritized defending yourself over trying to grasp my perspective.” Despite both recognizing they struggle to meet each other’s needs, their reactions to this realization vary. Aria appears somewhat resigned, while Scotty tends to criticize her harshly, even causing her to cry at times. His reaction to her tears? “Feel irritated. I’m going to be straightforward.” Not impressed! In a scene that could easily be labeled as “textbook delusional,” Scotty accuses Aria of always being upset about something — a claim that seems more fitting for him to make, given his reflection-avoidance tendencies.

In a nutshell, Mariah feels uneasy about Caleb’s reluctance to discuss his relationship with Aria. Whenever she brings it up, he seems evasive and eventually becomes irritable. She’s curious about what it would take for them to reconcile emotionally, but he suggests they connect better once conflicts are resolved. However, it’s unclear how they can resolve their issues if Caleb keeps distancing himself from them. Mariah is currently reading Jay Shetty’s book “8 Rules of Love,” hoping to find some insight on the matter.

It appears that Mariah and Caleb are holding a promising future, particularly when observed during their fishing trips where they seem more harmonious. They acknowledge that their relationship has pushed them to confront personal issues, which seems fitting considering their history of conflict. However, it remains to be seen if self-awareness alone will propel them towards resolution.

Notes for the Divorce Lawyers

It’s delightful to see that, even while dining out, everyone uses the iconic metal cups from Netflix, as if they were their favorite mugs. However, it seems that the restaurant scenes in this series are often pointless since nobody is actually seen eating anything!

Which contestant of this current season might appear on “Perfect Match” next summer? Given our observations thus far, it seems likely that Aria may be among those invited to the villa.

As a movie buff, I’ve come to realize that if J.R. genuinely sees lowering the toilet seat as an achievement, then it might be time for Zaina to take the next step and move forward.

Read More

2024-12-11 14:54